2004 Author Reviews for
Gecco

I love Gimli, and I love the way that Gecco has written him. Gecco takes the time to let Gimli's anger and hurt fester, and then Gimli is set loose only to find that vengeance isn't all it's cracked up to be. Much of the story is told in flashbacks, which can be difficult, but Gecco pulls it off well. Beorn and Gandalf are somewhat minor characters, but their personalities are laid out well, and as for Gimli himself…let me just say that I love this version of him. Gecco pays homage to my favorite dwarf and does him justice, and for that I offer up an endless stream of thanks. Gecco takes into account situations, Gimli's relative youth, and when the Battle of Fire Armies starts up, we dive into Tolkien's work seamlessly. Beautiful blending, great characterization, and a wonderful ability to deal with feelings and the fiery emotions of the dwarves.