2006 Author Reviews for
Primsong
Reviews for Genres: Drama
Reviewer: Larner Category: Genres: Drama Valid Characters: 123 Score: 2
Primsong\'s writing is exceptionally well done; and in the poem on Legolas\'s sea longing it shows her marvelous skill with words to best advantage.
Reviews for Times: Late Third Age
Reviewer: Dreamflower Category: Times: Late Third Age Valid Characters: 473 Score: 5
There are not many authors who specialize in stories about Bilbo, but Primsong does so delightfully. She makes him come alive--one can easily see in him both his Tookish and his Baggins sides--both very well balanced. He loves his adventure, but he also loves his comfort. He is very much \"canon\" Bilbo! This comes across not only in her nominated stories, but in her WIP, \"Stone of Erebor\", which deals with Bilbo\'s second visit to the Lonely Mountain. She has a delightful light style, and a very dry sense of humor. I really enjoy her work, and wish there were more of it!
Reviewer: Imhiriel Category: Times: Late Third Age Valid Characters: 157 Score: 3
Her Bilbo is one of the most accurately captured I\'ve ever read. He shines with curiosity, mischief, love of adventures, and yet never loses his \"hobbityness\" and generous, caring heart.
Reviewer: Larner Category: Times: Late Third Age Valid Characters: 269 Score: 3
No one has as strong a handle on Bilbo Baggins than does Primsong. Her humor and her imagination has served to spark my own, and I love the humor she displays. Even her chapter titles can evoke humor.
I only regret in this one we are looking at the darkness of what MIGHT have been had Bilbo\'s envelope not come into Frodo\'s hands.