2006 Author Reviews for
daw the minstrel

Reviews for Genres: Adventure

Reviewer: dkpalaska Category: Genres: Adventure Valid Characters: 664 Score: 6
I always enjoy the characterizations of the royal family in Daw\'s stories. Their interactions and personalities feel real to me: complex, developing over time, with occasional to chronic conflicts. Her work is mostly populated by OC\'s, which are richly drawn and believable individuals. She does a wonderful job of blending in details - about archery or woodcraft, for example - that add depth to the story but do not overwhelm it (as well as often providing quite an education for me!). Bits of foreshadowing and canonical information are woven smoothly into a rich and complex tapestry of original storytelling, with twists and turns of both drama and humor to draw me in and keep me reading. Truly, Daw has created an amazing and entertaining universe for Thranduil, his family and his people.
Reviewer: Marta Category: Genres: Adventure Valid Characters: 214 Score: 3
Usually elflings irritate me but not daw\'s. Young Legolas resonates emotionally and Mirkwood is convincingly connected to what Tolkien tells us in \"The Hobbit\". It\'s a world I find myself accepting, and her stories always sweep me up in what\'s happening.

Reviews for Genres: Humor

Reviewer: Marta Category: Genres: Humor Valid Characters: 214 Score: 3
Usually elflings irritate me but not daw\'s. Young Legolas resonates emotionally and Mirkwood is convincingly connected to what Tolkien tells us in \"The Hobbit\". It\'s a world I find myself accepting, and her stories always sweep me up in what\'s happening.

Reviews for Races: Elves

Reviewer: Imhiriel Category: Races: Elves Valid Characters: 186 Score: 3
Entertaining stories, that all manage to stand on their own, but gain from the resonances of other stories of her well-developed universe. Wonderful portrayals of canon- and original characters and their interactions.
Reviewer: dkpalaska Category: Races: Elves Valid Characters: 663 Score: 6
I always enjoy the characterizations of the royal family in Daw\'s stories. Their interactions and personalities feel real to me: complex, developing over time, with occasional to chronic conflicts. Her work is mostly populated by OCs, which are richly drawn and believable individuals. She does a wonderful job of blending in details - about archery or woodcraft, for example - that add depth to the story but do not overwhelm it (as well as often providing quite an education for me!). Bits of foreshadowing and canonical information are woven smoothly into a rich and complex tapestry of original storytelling, with twists and turns of both drama and humor to draw me in and keep me reading. Truly, Daw has created an amazing and entertaining universe for Thranduil, his family and his people.
Reviewer: Marta Category: Races: Elves Valid Characters: 214 Score: 3
Usually elflings irritate me but not daw\'s. Young Legolas resonates emotionally and Mirkwood is convincingly connected to what Tolkien tells us in \"The Hobbit\". It\'s a world I find myself accepting, and her stories always sweep me up in what\'s happening.
Return to the Author Awards