ED1: Hannon Le by Lady Aranel
I very much enjoyed this! Lady Aranel has a wonderful gift of
wordplay and provides the reader with a fun surprise at the end.
EI3: Oak and Willow by Marnie
This is one of my favorites. Marnie has a real talent of
characterization and Celeborn is especially good in this one. I love
this picture of his courtship and interaction with Galadriel's
brothers.
EI6: Wayland The Smith by Jilian Baade
This is an enjoyable tale, I especially enjoy seeing Elrond and
Earendil playing Monopoly. I hope to see it finished before too long.
E4-1: Elrohir's Tale by Miriel361
I always enjoy reading about my one of my favorite guys.
E4-6: War Dust by Earmire
Wonderful job in the blending of tales. Great Job. It feels
historical rather than fictional.
ER6: Unbound by Two-point
Well handled emotion and romance.
EV2 Cold Comfort Lady Aranel
Lady Aranel paints a beautiful and poignant picture of heartfelt love
and companionship in a way that we seldom see in this genre. Kudos
for so well handling an unusual situation
EV4: Dinner Guests by Salsify
Fabulous use of canon wordplay.
E4: Across Dark Waters by Zimraphel
Fabulous. Wonderful pacing and style. Characterizations are
extraordinary.
E5: Battle of the Golden Wood by Marnie
Extraordinary depth of characterizations, both canon and OC. Well
plotted, with every detail thought out, but none overdone. It is
refreshing to read a novel of this length that doesn't plant red
herrings or leave loose ends.
E8: Fated Twins by Cirdan
I very much enjoyed this unique viewpoint of the attack.
E12: Lord of the House of the Golden Flower by Jilian Baade
This is well done and very enjoyable, with a heart-warming ending.
E18: The Smith by Jilian Baade
This is insightful. I like the way that the Smith connected between
Narsil and Anduril.
ES3: Coming of Age by Jilian Baade
An interesting glimpse of one of my favorite characters. I
especially like the characterizations in this fic that shows Maedhros
boarding between childhood and adulthood.