Yahoo Forum Archive

Is there anyway that I can see the stories I have already reviewed?

Many thanks!
Agape

Agape wrote:

>
>
> Is there anyway that I can see the stories I have already reviewed?
>
> Many thanks!
> Agape
>

Hi Agape,

There sure is.

1. Log in to http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2007/
2. Click on the "Browse Nominated Stories" link.
3. Do you see a list of filters? (Story Type, Author, etc.) If not,
click the "Show Filter" link.
4. From the "Review Status" link click "All Reviews".
5. Click the "Display selected nominations" button.

This will show you all the stories you've reviewed. You can also display
all the ones you've entered a certain type of review (Final, Hidden, or
Draft) by selecting that option at step 4.

HTH,
Marta

This might be a silly question, but when will we able to see any
reviews given to the nominated tales (I'm sure I missed something, but
bear with me and just try to help me - so far I can only see the
reviews I have written myself so far). And yes, I'm still behind with
my goal, but I keep trying to catch up. *grins*

Cúthalion

Hi Cuthalion,

Excellent question!

You can see the reviews you have written any time through the "browse
nominated stories" page (just click the "Edit [Draft/Hidden/Final]
Review". But that's probably not what you were asking. *grin*

On October 1, a new link will show up on the page you see when you log
in to the voting website. It will say "Read Reviews" and will be right
under the "Browse Nominated Stories" link. If you click on it, you'll be
able to read all the final reviews people have written so far. Hidden
reviews will be displayed either when the reviewer changes them to final
reviews, or after voting closes on 12/30.

Marta

beleg1cuthalion wrote:

>
>
> This might be a silly question, but when will we able to see any
> reviews given to the nominated tales (I'm sure I missed something, but
> bear with me and just try to help me - so far I can only see the
> reviews I have written myself so far). And yes, I'm still behind with
> my goal, but I keep trying to catch up. *grins*
>
> Cúthalion

A related question -- will there ever be a way for me to see all reviews that I have written (for all stories) on a single page? E.g. if I want to see a list of all my draft reviews so I can look through them and decide which ones to promote to final, etc. Or will I always be required to search for the reviews one-by-one by searching for each story?

Thanks!

Marta <melayton@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi Cuthalion,

Excellent question!

You can see the reviews you have written any time through the "browse
nominated stories" page (just click the "Edit [Draft/Hidden/Final]
Review". But that's probably not what you were asking. *grin*

On October 1, a new link will show up on the page you see when you log
in to the voting website. It will say "Read Reviews" and will be right
under the "Browse Nominated Stories" link. If you click on it, you'll be
able to read all the final reviews people have written so far. Hidden
reviews will be displayed either when the reviewer changes them to final
reviews, or after voting closes on 12/30.

Marta

beleg1cuthalion wrote:

>
>
> This might be a silly question, but when will we able to see any
> reviews given to the nominated tales (I'm sure I missed something, but
> bear with me and just try to help me - so far I can only see the
> reviews I have written myself so far). And yes, I'm still behind with
> my goal, but I keep trying to catch up. *grins*
>
> Cúthalion

---------------------------------
Yahoo! oneSearch: Finally, mobile search that gives answers, not web links.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Hi Geek Chick,

When the reviews start going public on 10/1, there will be a second page
where you can view all the reviews by a certain reviewer. There will
be a link to it from the main page right under the "Read Reviews" links.
However, I'm pretty sure this will only display your reviews that are
currently visible--which while the award is still going on means only
final reviews.

There is a way to see all of the stories you have submitted a certain
type of review for. And you can even see it now. You don't even have to
wait for October 1. Log in, click the "Browse Nominated Stories" link,
and look at the filters, the drop-down lists that let you limit what
stories are displayed. (If you don't see these, you may need to click
the "Show Filter" link.) One of the filters is Review Status. If you
select "Draft" and then click the "Display selected nominations" button,
this will show all the stories you've entered a draft review for. The
other options let you show those stories you've entered hidden or final
reivews for, or some combination of those.

If you do that, to edit a review you'd still need to click the "Edit
[Draft/Hidden/Final] Review" link in the right-hand column. But at least
you'd see all the stories you've reviewed together. Does that do what
you want it to?

Marta

Geek Chick wrote:

>
>
> A related question -- will there ever be a way for me to see all reviews
> that I have written (for all stories) on a single page? E.g. if I want
> to see a list of all my draft reviews so I can look through them and
> decide which ones to promote to final, etc. Or will I always be required
> to search for the reviews one-by-one by searching for each story?
>
> Thanks!
>

Hi Geek Chick,

When the reviews start going public on 10/1, there will be a second page
where you can view all the reviews by a certain reviewer. There will
be a link to it from the main page right under the "Read Reviews" links.
However, I'm pretty sure this will only display your reviews that are
currently visible--which while the award is still going on means only
final reviews.

There is a way to see all of the stories you have submitted a certain
type of review for. And you can even see it now. You don't even have to
wait for October 1. Log in, click the "Browse Nominated Stories" link,
and look at the filters, the drop-down lists that let you limit what
stories are displayed. (If you don't see these, you may need to click
the "Show Filter" link.) One of the filters is Review Status. If you
select "Draft" and then click the "Display selected nominations" button,
this will show all the stories you've entered a draft review for. The
other options let you show those stories you've entered hidden or final
reivews for, or some combination of those.

If you do that, to edit a review you'd still need to click the "Edit
[Draft/Hidden/Final] Review" link in the right-hand column. But at least
you'd see all the stories you've reviewed together. Does that do what
you want it to?

Marta

Geek Chick wrote:

>
>
> A related question -- will there ever be a way for me to see all reviews
> that I have written (for all stories) on a single page? E.g. if I want
> to see a list of all my draft reviews so I can look through them and
> decide which ones to promote to final, etc. Or will I always be required
> to search for the reviews one-by-one by searching for each story?
>
> Thanks!
>

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Marta <melayton@...> wrote:

>
> Hi Geek Chick,
>
> When the reviews start going public on 10/1, there will be a second

page

> where you can view all the reviews by a certain reviewer. There will
> be a link to it from the main page right under the "Read Reviews"

links.

> However, I'm pretty sure this will only display your reviews that are
> currently visible--which while the award is still going on means only
> final reviews.
>

Hi Geek Chick,

I wanted to follow up on this point. I was talking about this with
Aranel Took (one of our web programmers) and she says that your draft
and hidden reviews will also be visible to you. So beginning on
October 1, you should be able to see all of your reviews by clicking
on the "Read Reviews by Reviewer" page and selecting your own name as
the reviewer whose reviews you'd like to see.

Marta

Hmm. I just got a notice that I've met my reviews quota, although I've
not. I set my quota at 100, and have done not quite fifty so far. Is
the counter off? Any ideas?
Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

I mourn for this nation.

Yes, that's just what I was looking for! Thanks!

Marta <melayton@gmail.com> wrote: Hi Geek Chick,

When the reviews start going public on 10/1, there will be a second page
where you can view all the reviews by a certain reviewer. There will
be a link to it from the main page right under the "Read Reviews" links.
However, I'm pretty sure this will only display your reviews that are
currently visible--which while the award is still going on means only
final reviews.

There is a way to see all of the stories you have submitted a certain
type of review for. And you can even see it now. You don't even have to
wait for October 1. Log in, click the "Browse Nominated Stories" link,
and look at the filters, the drop-down lists that let you limit what
stories are displayed. (If you don't see these, you may need to click
the "Show Filter" link.) One of the filters is Review Status. If you
select "Draft" and then click the "Display selected nominations" button,
this will show all the stories you've entered a draft review for. The
other options let you show those stories you've entered hidden or final
reivews for, or some combination of those.

If you do that, to edit a review you'd still need to click the "Edit
[Draft/Hidden/Final] Review" link in the right-hand column. But at least
you'd see all the stories you've reviewed together. Does that do what
you want it to?

Marta

Geek Chick wrote:

>
>
> A related question -- will there ever be a way for me to see all reviews
> that I have written (for all stories) on a single page? E.g. if I want
> to see a list of all my draft reviews so I can look through them and
> decide which ones to promote to final, etc. Or will I always be required
> to search for the reviews one-by-one by searching for each story?
>
> Thanks!
>

---------------------------------
Boardwalk for $500? In 2007? Ha!
Play Monopoly Here and Now (it's updated for today's economy) at Yahoo! Games.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Have all the reviews been tallied and posted? I'm a bit confuzzled on this.

Elvish Writer

Hi Elvish Writer

All the "scoring" reviews left for each story are now visible at the
voting website, and are being posted in batches by annmarwalk at the
mefas LJ.

The final results and winners in each subcategory will be available on
the voting website and announced here just after midnight GMT on 4 January.

We need a couple of days to check that everything is as it should be,
and to send individual emails to each of the winning authors (these will
be going out over the next day or so) before we release the results here
and at the website.

Hope that lessens the confuzzlement.

Tanaqui
The MEFA Admin Team

elvishwriter wrote:

>
>
> Have all the reviews been tallied and posted? I'm a bit confuzzled on this.
>
> Elvish Writer

Hi Tanaqui!

Yes this lessens my confuzzlement! :)

Elvish Writer

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Tanaqui <tanaqui@...> wrote:
>
> Hi Elvish Writer
>
> All the "scoring" reviews left for each story are now visible at the
> voting website, and are being posted in batches by annmarwalk at the
> mefas LJ.
>
> The final results and winners in each subcategory will be available on
> the voting website and announced here just after midnight GMT on 4 January.
>
> We need a couple of days to check that everything is as it should be,
> and to send individual emails to each of the winning authors (these will
> be going out over the next day or so) before we release the results here
> and at the website.
>
> Hope that lessens the confuzzlement.
>
> Tanaqui
> The MEFA Admin Team
>
> elvishwriter wrote:
> >
> >
> > Have all the reviews been tallied and posted? I'm a bit confuzzled on this.
> >
> > Elvish Writer
>