Yahoo Forum Archive

This is an archive of the MEFA Yahoo Group, which was shut down by Yahoo in 2019. The archive can be sorted by month and by topic ID. You can use your browser to search by keyword within the month or topic you have open.

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2004---18210426558925263362316285
20051895610753834744697276194358565136
200623166277611713912756676615979
200720257-297299143318583103
2008561335424014127477516090106
2009283-39194101722722153624
201067-14103138129321316330
20111-172625906132758
201230---812276-----
2013------------
2014---------1-2
2015------------
2016------------
2017------------
2018------------
2019---------1--

Msg# 10596

looking for a volunteer Posted by telperion1 July 05, 2010 - 15:04:18 Topic ID# 10596
Hey guys,

In a few weeks, reviews will start showing up on our website. This means
that authors will be able to reply to their reviews. They essentially
send an email to an email address, which a volunteer then reads over to
make sure it's not a flame and passes on to the reviewer.

I'm looking for that volunteer. The main requirement is availability.
You'd need to check in every 2-3 days at least, from now through
mid-December, though another volunteer could take over if you need a
short break. You also need to be able to follow directions well. It is
essentially "grunt" work, and the kind of thing that doesn't attract a
lot of attention if it's done right. But it is a huge help to me for
someone else to do that, and while it's not exactly high profile you
*will* have my appreciation as well as an official "thank you" on the
list of MEFA volunteers.

If this seems like something you're interested in, drop me a line at
mefasupport@gmail.com - either to say you want to do it, or to get more
info on what is required.

Thanks!

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10597

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by brandy bartoli July 05, 2010 - 17:10:02 Topic ID# 10596
What directions are we talking about Marta? I am usually on the net every night for a few hours unless I have to be at work at like dawn or something. Tell me more. I am interested.

Brandy, Haldirsbaby

Life without laughter is not worth living!     THE wise one.....ME


--- On Mon, 7/5/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:

From: telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com>
Subject: [MEFAwards] looking for a volunteer
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Date: Monday, July 5, 2010, 4:04 PM







 









Hey guys,



In a few weeks, reviews will start showing up on our website. This means

that authors will be able to reply to their reviews. They essentially

send an email to an email address, which a volunteer then reads over to

make sure it's not a flame and passes on to the reviewer.



I'm looking for that volunteer. The main requirement is availability.

You'd need to check in every 2-3 days at least, from now through

mid-December, though another volunteer could take over if you need a

short break. You also need to be able to follow directions well. It is

essentially "grunt" work, and the kind of thing that doesn't attract a

lot of attention if it's done right. But it is a huge help to me for

someone else to do that, and while it's not exactly high profile you

*will* have my appreciation as well as an official "thank you" on the

list of MEFA volunteers.



If this seems like something you're interested in, drop me a line at

mefasupport@gmail.com - either to say you want to do it, or to get more

info on what is required.



Thanks!



Marta

(MEFA Admin.)























[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10598

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by erynlasgalen1949 July 06, 2010 - 10:16:45 Topic ID# 10596
You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation of privacy.

This is usually not an issue, but in the past some of my review replies have been to people I know personally. I'll bear in mind that someone else may be seeing what I wrote.

Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer then not get to see it?

Msg# 10599

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by Diana Nevins July 06, 2010 - 11:11:05 Topic ID# 10596
As I recall, MEFA story reviews (at least for the winning stories) have always been publicly viewable on the MEFA website. They're no more private than reviews anywhere else are. Certainly on most archive sites I'm familiar with, story reviews are always public.

Ithilwen


-----Original Message-----

From: erynlasgalen1949

Sent: Jul 6, 2010 10:13 AM

To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com

Subject: [MEFAwards] Re: looking for a volunteer

You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation of privacy.

This is usually not an issue, but in the past some of my review replies have been to people I know personally. I'll bear in mind that someone else may be seeing what I wrote.

Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer then not get to see it?

Msg# 10600

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by erynlasgalen1949 July 06, 2010 - 11:42:00 Topic ID# 10596
I'm talking about the review _replies_. Of course the reviews themselves are public.

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Diana Nevins <dlnevins@...> wrote:
>
> As I recall, MEFA story reviews (at least for the winning stories) have always been publicly viewable on the MEFA website. They're no more private than reviews anywhere else are. Certainly on most archive sites I'm familiar with, story reviews are always public.
>
> Ithilwen
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
>
> From: erynlasgalen1949
>
> Sent: Jul 6, 2010 10:13 AM
>
> To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
>
> Subject: [MEFAwards] Re: looking for a volunteer
>
> You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation of privacy.
>
> This is usually not an issue, but in the past some of my review replies have been to people I know personally. I'll bear in mind that someone else may be seeing what I wrote.
>
> Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer then not get to see it?
>

Msg# 10601

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by Diana Nevins July 06, 2010 - 13:08:24 Topic ID# 10596
Sorry! I misunderstood you.

Ithilwen

-----Original Message-----

From: erynlasgalen1949

Sent: Jul 6, 2010 12:40 PM

To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com

Subject: [MEFAwards] Re: looking for a volunteer

I'm talking about the review _replies_. Of course the reviews themselves are public.



--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Diana Nevins <dlnevins@...> wrote:

>

> As I recall, MEFA story reviews (at least for the winning stories) have always been publicly viewable on the MEFA website. They're no more private than reviews anywhere else are. Certainly on most archive sites I'm familiar with, story reviews are always public.

>

> Ithilwen

>

>

> -----Original Message-----

>

> From: erynlasgalen1949

>

> Sent: Jul 6, 2010 10:13 AM

>

> To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com

>

> Subject: [MEFAwards] Re: looking for a volunteer

>

> You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation of privacy.

>

> This is usually not an issue, but in the past some of my review replies have been to people I know personally. I'll bear in mind that someone else may be seeing what I wrote.

>

> Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer then not get to see it?

>

Msg# 10602

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by telperion1 July 06, 2010 - 17:31:30 Topic ID# 10596
Hi Brandy,

Thanks for your interest. I already had another person email me at the
mefasupport@gmail.com address, so we're all set this time. But basically
I was offering to answer any questions you had, if you thought you might
be interested but weren't sure.

Marta

On 7/5/2010 6:09 PM, brandy bartoli wrote:
>
>
> What directions are we talking about Marta? I am usually on the net
> every night for a few hours unless I have to be at work at like dawn or
> something. Tell me more. I am interested.
>
> Brandy, Haldirsbaby
>

Msg# 10603

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by telperion1 July 06, 2010 - 18:37:17 Topic ID# 10596
Hiya Eryn Lasgalen,

> You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I
> would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation
> of privacy.
>

"Skim" is probably a better description than "read." The volunteer just
needs to make sure that replies aren't flames of some kind, because
they're going out under the "MEFA" name. (The email address they'll be
coming from is mefareviews@gmail.com.) To many people, this makes it
seem like the reply is somehow from the MEFAs as an institution, or that
we approve of what was said because we're passing it on. So a flamey
review might not only create bad feelings between the reviewer and that
particular author, but between the reviewer and the *MEFAs.* That's
something we need to avoid.

Believe me, we don't want it to be like big brother peeking over your
shoulder! Our volunteers have better things to do anyway. We're just
trying to strike the right balance between protecting the MEFA name (so
most people have a positive association rather than a negative one with
it) and giving authors and reviewers a service they have asked for. But
if you feel we're erring too far toward one side or the other, we can
always consider it in our post-mortem after the awards. If you ever see
something you would like us to consider changing, you can suggest it at

http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/1994/05/15/

and the volunteers will consider it for 2011 once this year's awards are
over.

> Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer
> then not get to see it?
>

If we decide a review is a flame, we'll reply back to the author saying
we haven't passed the reply on. So no, the reviewer doesn't get to see
it. But the author *knows* the review wasn't passed on for some reason
or another, so they can try to get in touch some other way if they like.

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10604

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by telperion1 July 06, 2010 - 18:47:14 Topic ID# 10596
Hi Ithilwen,

You're right, reviews are always public. When you enter a review you
give it a status, and if that status is Hidden or Final, the review will
be shown to other people eventually. (The difference is that with Hidden
reviews, you can keep editing them until the end of the awards, at which
point they'll be displayed.)

But Eryn Lasgalen was talking about something a bit different. When an
author reads a review, there is a link to *reply* to that review. This
opens up an email that a MEFA volunteer will pass on to the reviewer.
And that's not shown on our website at the moment, but it *is* read by a
volunteer to make sure we aren't passing along a flame.

Marta

On 7/6/2010 12:11 PM, Diana Nevins wrote:
>
>
> As I recall, MEFA story reviews (at least for the winning stories) have
> always been publicly viewable on the MEFA website. They're no more
> private than reviews anywhere else are. Certainly on most archive sites
> I'm familiar with, story reviews are always public.
>
> Ithilwen
>

Msg# 10605

Re: looking for a volunteer Posted by dwimmer\_laik July 06, 2010 - 19:44:00 Topic ID# 10596
Just to say - before the "reply to reviewer" link was programmed into the site, I would just go through the MEFA Yahoo Group member database and use it to get in touch with anyone whose e-mail address I didn't already have. It's not that much more time intensive (I found, anyway), and with probably three exceptions, I was able to find every reviewer who had written something for my stories, even if I had to branch out and look at FFN or some other archive site to find a means of contacting him or her.

So if you want to e-mail your reviewers and still have total privacy, it's completely doable.

Dwim

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, "erynlasgalen1949" <erynlasgalen1949@...> wrote:
>
> You mean a third party will be reading our emails? I had no idea. I would almost rather risk having to see a flame than lose the expectation of privacy.
>
> This is usually not an issue, but in the past some of my review replies have been to people I know personally. I'll bear in mind that someone else may be seeing what I wrote.
>
> Idle question: what if the review reply is a flame? Does the reviewer then not get to see it?
>

Msg# 10606

ADMIN - Categorization III - Check Ballots Posted by telperion1 July 07, 2010 - 21:19:06 Topic ID# 10606
Hey guys,

In a moment I will post the first of the check ballots. So I wanted to
devote this week's educational post to that, so I can explain how check
ballots work.

If you're new to the MEFAs, you may be unfamiliar with the term. Unlike
with many competitions, stories aren't nominated for a particular
category; they are simply nominated for the awards *generally*. Authors
then provide information about their stories, and volunteers sort the
nominated pieces into main categories and subcategories.

(Need a reminder about how stories are categorized? See the previous two
weeks' educational posts:


--- http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/196823.html
--- http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/196874.html )

The volunteers working with categorizing try to get everything right,
but with 600+ nominations, mistakes occasionally happen. Sometimes
authors accidentally select the wrong item when describing their
stories. And sometimes volunteers make a mistake entering information
onto the website - a stray mouse click can mean the difference between
Horror and Humor, or First Age and Fourth Age. So we ask authors and
everyone else to look over the check ballots. Think of these as "draft"
categories and subcategories, which we will make changes to if someone
catches an error; after this week, we will only move WIPs that are finished.

When I say "mistake," I mainly mean mistakes made by those volunteers
setting up the categories. We want you to check that we put things where
they need to be. These volunteers worked hard to set up equitable
subcategories and depended on the information authors provided. Now, if
you see that you made a mistake, we do want to know about it, but we may
not be able to move you around at this point. It all depends on the
sizes of the category you are moving out of and into. But you can ask.

The one change we *won't* make is if you described a story as having
certain characters, locations, etc., and you're in a subcat based on
that, but you see a subcategory you think is a better fit. Let me give
you an example. Say that you wrote a story about Merry, Pippin, and
Boromir, and you selected all three as characters for categorization.
The categorizer sets up a subcategory for stories involving Boromir, and
another for stories involving Hobbits. You end up in the Boromir
subcategory but would prefer to run against Hobbits. But in this
situation we wouldn't move you, because you're in a subcategory you
selected for. With each story moved, it becomes that much harder to move
other stories later on; and so I like to "save" the moving about for
stories where someone made a real error.

All of what I've just said is in general. In any particular case, it's
ultimately up to me and the other categorizing volunteers to decide
whether or not to move a story. We'll do our best, but we do sometimes
have to say no, in the interest of fairness to the other stories competing.

You can also ask that we change the name of a subcategory. We've done so
in the past. For instance, some people suggested we change "Eriador" to
"Eriador or Shire," to make it clearer that the subcategory included
hobbit stories as well as ones about the Rivendell Elves, Bree,
Dunedain, and so on. Those kind of changes are much easier to do than
moving stories around.

***************************************

Most of the subcategory names are self-explanatory. In general:

--- Poems should be competing in the "Genres: Poetry" subcategory
--- Drabbles and Drabble Series should be competing in the subcategories
ending in the word "Drabbles", in all the main categories.
--- Non-Fiction should be competing in the "Genres: Non-Fiction" main
category.
--- WIPs should be competing in subcategories ending in the word
"Incompletes", in all the main categories.
--- Stories should be competing in all other subcategories.

There is one exception regarding "Incompletes": we didn't have enough
Incompletes subcategories to have one in very many main category, and
some authors were given the choice to run against finished fic rather
than go into a main category that didn't really fit. This affects 238. A
Singular Honour by Shemyaza1; it is a WIP but is competing in Genres:
Crossover: Incomplete. If you see a WIP other than this one running
against finished fic, we need to know that now.

Also, some of you may be confused by the phrase "Mixed Drabbles." I
tried to keep single Drabbles in separate subcategories from Drabble
Series, but that wasn't always possible. When I had to combine the two
types of Drabbles, the subcategory is called "Mixed Drabbles."
Otherwise, subcategories with "Drabble Series" in the name contain only
series of drabbles, while subcategories with just "Drabbles" in the name
contain individual drabbles.

I think those are the most confusing points, naming-wise. Of course if
you are confused, you are welcome to ask questions. Better now than down
the line.

*************************************

One last thing: please, if you're asking to move reply to this list by
11:59 PM on July 14. And please trim your replies, and include only the
subcategories you are talking about! People on digest will thank you.

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10607

Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 07, 2010 - 21:30:20 Topic ID# 10607
Hey guys,

Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
would be:

--- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
--- The story is competing against different-type stories.
--- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
locations you didn't select.

For more on checkballots, see:

http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/197122.html


***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***

The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***

Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
Before the Fall (141): Elleth
To be Black (290): Encairion
The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
Choices (224): Linaewen
When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
King's Ransom (673): splix


***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***

A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
Starship (50): shirebound
Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy


***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***

In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
The Light (303): Pearl Took
Bruises (368): Soledad
In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
Broken (515): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***

Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
Walls of White (27): Elleth
Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
The Return of the King (573): Jael
A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
Rebuffed (524): MithLuin


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn***

In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
The New Queens Bounty (136): Larner
Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***

To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***

The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
A Copper Band (251): Himring
Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***

A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
Sisterhood (535): Marta
Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***

Innocence (662): Dwimordene
Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
Good News (392): Paranoidangel
Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
Vigilance (647): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***

What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
First Time (547): Tanaqui
Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
Calm (80): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***

Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
Flying Free (343): Keiliss
Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***

Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
Celeritas
Unravelling (142): Elleth
RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza


***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***

To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
Encore (268): Lady Roisin
To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***

Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***

Half-Brother (82): Ellie
The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
Little Bird (379): Soledad
Find Me (95): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***

Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
Weapons Forged (175): Larner
What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***

Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
Choosing (498): rhyselle
The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***

The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
The Lady (670): alex_quine
The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
Promises (81): Lialathuveril
A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***

Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
Fruition (551): Tanaqui
Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***

The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
Kin No More (516): Ellie
The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
Explaining (54): Larner
Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***

Quest (198): Cathleen
A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
Duty (674): Lindelea
The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***

Ghost (588): Aeärwen
Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***

After the Fall (482): clotho123
Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
Envy (317): Larner
Different Terms (170): Lyra
Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha


***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***

Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
Farewell (78): mirasaui
After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***

Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***

For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
Spring Dance (301): Leianora
The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***

No Regrets (483): clotho123
Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
Crude Material (608): Ygrain


***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***

Judgment (115): Aeärwen
Unrequited (163): elfscribe
Balrog (521): Phyncke
Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***

Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
Sand and Flame (250): Marta
Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***

Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
From the Ashes (185): Marta
Lessons (607): Nath
Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***

Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
Questioning (258): Larner
Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach


***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***

A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
Transformation (590): Larner
Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
Holiday (20): Nath
The Coimas War (275): Russandol
The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***

The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
A Gift (151): KyMahalei
And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***

For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
(304): Cathleen
Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***

A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
Fresh Meat (534): Marta
Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***

The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***

'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
Mightier than the Sword  Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***

Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv


***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***

Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
I Entulesse (204): MJ
Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***

A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
Yew (207): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***

A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
Into the Woods (75): Wormwood


***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***

'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
confusing (280): Darth Fingon
Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
Darth Fingon
Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
Dreamflower
Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest


***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***

A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***

Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
The Drums (430): Malicean
Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***

Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
Contrapposto (531): Marta


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***

How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
Descent (625): Lady Roisin
Forty Days (295): Marta
Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***

Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
A New Light (400): Marigold


***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***

Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
First Glance (148): Marta
The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love & (245): Súlriel
The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5


***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***

Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
When Winter Comes (138): Marta
A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad


***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***

Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Strange Land (519): Elfique
Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
Uldor (284): Himring
A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
The Courier (32): Jael
The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***

Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***

The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***

Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
Another Road (314): KyMahalei
Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***

Triptych (604): Adaneth
An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
Giants' Game (429): Larner
Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***

In Durin's Day (373): Marta
A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
Questing (117): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***

In His Eyes (92): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
Anna Wing
Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldos Guide to Coping with
Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***

Determined (426): Aeärwen
Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
More Than Memory (241): Marta
Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***

Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***

Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
Brightness (427): Faenel
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth


***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***

Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
(114): Dreamflower
One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***

Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
Marigolds Yule (306): GamgeeFest
Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***

When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
Dearest Dora (445): Larner
The Research Project (602): Larner
I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***

Memorial Day (358): Antane
Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Races: Men: General***

Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
Death and Life (511): Golden
Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
Penance (278): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***

The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles***

Mother Country (329): Altariel
Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
Hospitality (79): Wormwood


***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***

One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
Cleansed (337): Larner
Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
The Fool (216): Marta
Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
Kinslayer (192): Russandol
Many Hands (276): Russandol
Living Jewels (182): shirebound


***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***

Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
Treed (618): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***

In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
Tutelage (230): Marta
Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***

Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
The Vessel (617): Elleth
This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***

The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***

Comfort (119): Aeärwen
In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
The Last Hero (263): Jael
Grace (558): Lanyon
For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance


***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***

Dance (672): alex_quine
A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***

Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***

Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***

Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
Passing Grace (313): Virtuella


***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***

Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***

A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
To See the Light (89): Mirach
The Awakening (203): MJ
In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***

Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***

Eradication (93): Breemon
The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
Resistance (554): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***

Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta


***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***

Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
Coda (376): Marta
Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui



Marta

Msg# 10608

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Barbara Rich July 07, 2010 - 22:20:31 Topic ID# 10607
Marta, all of mine look just fine as they are!
Dreamflower


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10609

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Marlyn Bumpus July 07, 2010 - 22:27:33 Topic ID# 10607
Hi there!

My story, "In The House of Elrond", is definitely in the wrong category. In the first place, it's a WIP - although the details on the site don't list it as incomplete, I know I entered it as incomplete on the form. Secondly, it is NOT a character study of Aragorn; frankly, although Aragorn II is in the story, it is as a minor character only. There was no listing for Gilraen that didn't include Aragorn. Frankly, I would feel better if this story were in Cross-Cultural: Incomplete.

Is that possible?

Thank you.

Cuio mae.

Aeýrwen

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10610

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Elizabeth Nield July 07, 2010 - 22:29:30 Topic ID# 10607
Mine's good too, I think!

Kaylee Arafinwiel

----- Original Message -----
From: "telperion1" <marta.fandom@gmail.com>
To: <MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Wednesday, July 07, 2010 7:30 PM
Subject: [MEFAwards] Check Ballot v. 1


> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
> know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
> would be:
>
> --- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
> --- The story is competing against different-type stories.
> --- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
> locations you didn't select.
>
> For more on checkballots, see:
>
> http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/197122.html
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***
>
> The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
> A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
> Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
> Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
> Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
> Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***
>
> Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
> Before the Fall (141): Elleth
> To be Black (290): Encairion
> The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
> Choices (224): Linaewen
> When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
> The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
> Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
> The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
> King's Ransom (673): splix
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***
>
> A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
> You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
> Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
> Starship (50): shirebound
> Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
> Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
> Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***
>
> In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
> Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
> In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
> To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
> Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
> The Light (303): Pearl Took
> Bruises (368): Soledad
> In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
> Broken (515): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***
>
> Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
> No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
> Walls of White (27): Elleth
> Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
> The Return of the King (573): Jael
> A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
> Rebuffed (524): MithLuin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn***
>
> In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
> Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
> Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
> The New Queens Bounty (136): Larner
> Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
> The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***
>
> To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
> Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
> A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
> Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
> Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
> Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
> Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
> Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***
>
> The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
> Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
> A Copper Band (251): Himring
> Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
> Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
> The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***
>
> A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
> Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
> Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
> Sisterhood (535): Marta
> Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
> Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
> Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
> Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***
>
> Innocence (662): Dwimordene
> Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
> The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
> Good News (392): Paranoidangel
> Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
> Vigilance (647): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***
>
> What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
> The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
> Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
> A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
> First Time (547): Tanaqui
> Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
> Calm (80): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***
>
> Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
> Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
> Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
> The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
> Flying Free (343): Keiliss
> Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
> Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***
>
> Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
> Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
> Celeritas
> Unravelling (142): Elleth
> RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
> Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
> The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
> Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***
>
> Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
> The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
> At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
> Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
> When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
> Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
> Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
>
> A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
> The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
> Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
> The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
> All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***
>
> Half-Brother (82): Ellie
> The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
> King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
> Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
> Little Bird (379): Soledad
> Find Me (95): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***
>
> Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
> The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
> Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
> Weapons Forged (175): Larner
> What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
> Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
> Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
> BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
> Choosing (498): rhyselle
> The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
> The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
> The Lady (670): alex_quine
> The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
> Promises (81): Lialathuveril
> A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
> Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
> Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
> A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
> Fruition (551): Tanaqui
> Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
> In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***
>
> The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
> Kin No More (516): Ellie
> The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
> A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
> Explaining (54): Larner
> Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
> Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***
>
> Quest (198): Cathleen
> A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
> To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
> The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
> Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
> Duty (674): Lindelea
> The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
> Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
> And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***
>
> Ghost (588): Aeärwen
> Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
> The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
> The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
> Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
> Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
> Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***
>
> After the Fall (482): clotho123
> Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
> A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
> A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
> Envy (317): Larner
> Different Terms (170): Lyra
> Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
> The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***
>
> Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
> Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
> A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
> Farewell (78): mirasaui
> After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
> The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***
>
> Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
> In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
> Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
> Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***
>
> Judgment (115): Aeärwen
> Unrequited (163): elfscribe
> Balrog (521): Phyncke
> Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
> Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
> A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***
>
> Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
> A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
> Sand and Flame (250): Marta
> Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
> Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
> From the Ashes (185): Marta
> Lessons (607): Nath
> Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
> Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
> Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***
>
> Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
> The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
> Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
> Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
> Questioning (258): Larner
> Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***
>
> A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
> More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
> Transformation (590): Larner
> Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
> In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
> Holiday (20): Nath
> The Coimas War (275): Russandol
> The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***
>
> The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
> Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
> O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
> A Gift (151): KyMahalei
> And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
> Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
> This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***
>
> For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
> Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
> (304): Cathleen
> Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
> The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
> The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
> A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***
>
> A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
> A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
> Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
> Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
> Fresh Meat (534): Marta
> Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
> Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***
>
> The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
> Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
> Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
> Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
> Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
> Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> 'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
> The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
> Mightier than the Sword  Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
> Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
> Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
> The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***
>
> Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
> Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
> The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
> By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
> Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
> Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
> Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
> Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
> Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***
>
> Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
> Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
> Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
> The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
> The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
> Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
> The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
> I Entulesse (204): MJ
> Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***
>
> A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
> Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
> The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
> The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
> Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
> The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
> Yew (207): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***
>
> A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
> Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
> A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
> Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
> Into the Woods (75): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***
>
> 'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
> confusing (280): Darth Fingon
> Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
> off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
> Darth Fingon
> Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
> Dreamflower
> Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
> Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
> Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***
>
> A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
> Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
> Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
> Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
> An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
> Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
> Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***
>
> Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
> The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
> Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
> The Drums (430): Malicean
> Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
> The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
> A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***
>
> Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
> Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
> What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
> Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
> Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
> A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
> Contrapposto (531): Marta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***
>
> How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
> And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
> Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
> Descent (625): Lady Roisin
> Forty Days (295): Marta
> Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
> End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***
>
> Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
> Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
> Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
> And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
> Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
> Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
> A New Light (400): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***
>
> Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
> Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
> Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
> Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
> Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
> The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
> First Glance (148): Marta
> The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
> A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love & (245): Súlriel
> The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***
>
> Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
> Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
> We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Strange Land (519): Elfique
> Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
> Uldor (284): Himring
> A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
> The Courier (32): Jael
> The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
> Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***
>
> Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
> Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
> The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
> Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
> Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
> Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
> Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
> Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
> The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
> Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
> Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***
>
> The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
> To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
> Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
> A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
> Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
> At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
> The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
> Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
>
> Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
> Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> 'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
> Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
> Another Road (314): KyMahalei
> Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
> Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Triptych (604): Adaneth
> An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
> Giants' Game (429): Larner
> Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
> Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
> Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***
>
> In Durin's Day (373): Marta
> A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
> In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
> Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
> Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
> Questing (117): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***
>
> In His Eyes (92): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
> Anna Wing
> Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
> Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldos Guide to Coping with
> Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
> A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
> Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
> Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
> The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
> The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
> Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***
>
> Determined (426): Aeärwen
> Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
> First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
> Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
> More Than Memory (241): Marta
> Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***
>
> Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
> A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
> Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
> Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
> The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
> The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***
>
> Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
> Brightness (427): Faenel
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
> Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
> By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
> No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
> Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***
>
> Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
> (114): Dreamflower
> One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
> Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
> A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
> Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
> Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
> A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***
>
> Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
> To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
> A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
> Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
> September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
> Marigolds Yule (306): GamgeeFest
> Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
> Dearest Dora (445): Larner
> The Research Project (602): Larner
> I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
> For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
> Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***
>
> Memorial Day (358): Antane
> Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
> Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
> The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
> Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
> Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Men: General***
>
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
> Death and Life (511): Golden
> Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
> Penance (278): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***
>
> The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
> Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
> Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
> The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
> Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
> Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Mother Country (329): Altariel
> Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
> Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
> Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
> A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
> Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
> Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
> Hospitality (79): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***
>
> One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
> Cleansed (337): Larner
> Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
> The Fool (216): Marta
> Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
> A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
> Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
> Kinslayer (192): Russandol
> Many Hands (276): Russandol
> Living Jewels (182): shirebound
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***
>
> Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
> I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
> The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
> How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
> Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
> Treed (618): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***
>
> In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
> Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
> Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
> Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
> The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
> The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
> Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
> Tutelage (230): Marta
> Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
> Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
> Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
> Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
> The Vessel (617): Elleth
> This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***
>
> The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
> A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
> The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
> Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
> Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
> Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
> Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
> A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***
>
> Comfort (119): Aeärwen
> In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
> Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
> The Last Hero (263): Jael
> Grace (558): Lanyon
> For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***
>
> Dance (672): alex_quine
> A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
> The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
> Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
> Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
> Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
> Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
> Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***
>
> Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
> Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
> Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
> Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
> In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
> Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***
>
> Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
> Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
> The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
> Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
> Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
> Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***
>
> Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
> Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
> Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
> Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
> Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
> Passing Grace (313): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***
>
> Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
> Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
> Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
> The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
> A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
> A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
> A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
> Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***
>
> A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
> Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
> Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
> No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
> The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
> To See the Light (89): Mirach
> The Awakening (203): MJ
> In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
> Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***
>
> Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
> Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
> On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
> The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
> The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
> Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Eradication (93): Breemon
> The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
> Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
> Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
> Resistance (554): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***
>
> Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
> Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
> How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
> Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
> All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
> Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***
>
> Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
> Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
> Coda (376): Marta
> Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
> All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui
>
>
>
> Marta
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>

Msg# 10611

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by linaewen0 July 07, 2010 - 22:46:10 Topic ID# 10607
My stories are very well placed, thanks!

Lin

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
> know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
> would be:
>
> --- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
> --- The story is competing against different-type stories.
> --- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
> locations you didn't select.
>
> For more on checkballots, see:
>
> http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/197122.html
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***
>
> The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
> A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
> Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
> Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
> Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
> Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***
>
> Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
> Before the Fall (141): Elleth
> To be Black (290): Encairion
> The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
> Choices (224): Linaewen
> When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
> The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
> Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
> The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
> King's Ransom (673): splix
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***
>
> A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
> You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
> Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
> Starship (50): shirebound
> Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
> Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
> Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***
>
> In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
> Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
> In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
> To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
> Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
> The Light (303): Pearl Took
> Bruises (368): Soledad
> In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
> Broken (515): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***
>
> Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
> No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
> Walls of White (27): Elleth
> Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
> The Return of the King (573): Jael
> A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
> Rebuffed (524): MithLuin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn***
>
> In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
> Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
> Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
> The New Queen's Bounty (136): Larner
> Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
> The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***
>
> To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
> Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
> A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
> Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
> Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
> Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
> Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
> Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***
>
> The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
> Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
> A Copper Band (251): Himring
> Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
> Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
> The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***
>
> A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
> Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
> Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
> Sisterhood (535): Marta
> Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
> Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
> Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
> Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***
>
> Innocence (662): Dwimordene
> Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
> The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
> Good News (392): Paranoidangel
> Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
> Vigilance (647): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***
>
> What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
> The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
> Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
> A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
> First Time (547): Tanaqui
> Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
> Calm (80): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***
>
> Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
> Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
> Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
> The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
> Flying Free (343): Keiliss
> Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
> Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***
>
> Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
> Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
> Celeritas
> Unravelling (142): Elleth
> RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
> Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
> The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
> Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***
>
> Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
> The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
> At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
> Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
> When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
> Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
> Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
>
> A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
> The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
> Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
> The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
> All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***
>
> Half-Brother (82): Ellie
> The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
> King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
> Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
> Little Bird (379): Soledad
> Find Me (95): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***
>
> Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
> The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
> Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
> Weapons Forged (175): Larner
> What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
> Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
> Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
> BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
> Choosing (498): rhyselle
> The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
> The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
> The Lady (670): alex_quine
> The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
> Promises (81): Lialathuveril
> A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
> Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
> Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
> A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
> Fruition (551): Tanaqui
> Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
> In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***
>
> The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
> Kin No More (516): Ellie
> The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
> A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
> Explaining (54): Larner
> Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
> Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***
>
> Quest (198): Cathleen
> A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
> To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
> The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
> Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
> Duty (674): Lindelea
> The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
> Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
> And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***
>
> Ghost (588): Aeärwen
> Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
> The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
> The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
> Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
> Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
> Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***
>
> After the Fall (482): clotho123
> Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
> A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
> A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
> Envy (317): Larner
> Different Terms (170): Lyra
> Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
> The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***
>
> Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
> Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
> A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
> Farewell (78): mirasaui
> After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
> The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***
>
> Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
> In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
> Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
> Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***
>
> Judgment (115): Aeärwen
> Unrequited (163): elfscribe
> Balrog (521): Phyncke
> Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
> Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
> A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***
>
> Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
> A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
> Sand and Flame (250): Marta
> Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
> Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
> From the Ashes (185): Marta
> Lessons (607): Nath
> Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
> Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
> Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***
>
> Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
> The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
> Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
> Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
> Questioning (258): Larner
> Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***
>
> A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
> More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
> Transformation (590): Larner
> Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
> In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
> Holiday (20): Nath
> The Coimas War (275): Russandol
> The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***
>
> The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
> Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
> O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
> A Gift (151): KyMahalei
> And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
> Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
> This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***
>
> For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
> Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
> (304): Cathleen
> Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
> The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
> The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
> A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***
>
> A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
> A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
> Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
> Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
> Fresh Meat (534): Marta
> Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
> Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***
>
> The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
> Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
> Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
> Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
> Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
> Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> 'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
> The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
> Mightier than the Sword – Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
> Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
> Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
> The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***
>
> Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
> Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
> The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
> By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
> Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
> Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
> Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
> Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
> Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***
>
> Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
> Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
> Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
> The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
> The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
> Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
> The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
> I Entulesse (204): MJ
> Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***
>
> A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
> Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
> The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
> The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
> Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
> The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
> Yew (207): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***
>
> A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
> Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
> A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
> Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
> Into the Woods (75): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***
>
> 'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
> confusing (280): Darth Fingon
> Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
> off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
> Darth Fingon
> Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
> Dreamflower
> Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
> Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
> Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***
>
> A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
> Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
> Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
> Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
> An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
> Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
> Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***
>
> Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
> The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
> Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
> The Drums (430): Malicean
> Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
> The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
> A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***
>
> Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
> Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
> What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
> Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
> Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
> A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
> Contrapposto (531): Marta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***
>
> How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
> And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
> Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
> Descent (625): Lady Roisin
> Forty Days (295): Marta
> Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
> End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***
>
> Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
> Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
> Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
> And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
> Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
> Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
> A New Light (400): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***
>
> Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
> Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
> Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
> Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
> Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
> The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
> First Glance (148): Marta
> The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
> A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love … (245): Súlriel
> The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***
>
> Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
> Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
> We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Strange Land (519): Elfique
> Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
> Uldor (284): Himring
> A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
> The Courier (32): Jael
> The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
> Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***
>
> Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
> Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
> The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
> Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
> Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
> Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
> Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
> Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
> The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
> Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
> Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***
>
> The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
> To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
> Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
> A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
> Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
> At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
> The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
> Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
>
> Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
> Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> 'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
> Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
> Another Road (314): KyMahalei
> Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
> Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Triptych (604): Adaneth
> An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
> Giants' Game (429): Larner
> Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
> Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
> Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***
>
> In Durin's Day (373): Marta
> A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
> In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
> Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
> Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
> Questing (117): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***
>
> In His Eyes (92): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
> Anna Wing
> Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
> Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldo's Guide to Coping with
> Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
> A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
> Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
> Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
> The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
> The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
> Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***
>
> Determined (426): Aeärwen
> Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
> First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
> Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
> More Than Memory (241): Marta
> Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***
>
> Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
> A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
> Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
> Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
> The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
> The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***
>
> Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
> Brightness (427): Faenel
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
> Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
> By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
> No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
> Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***
>
> Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
> (114): Dreamflower
> One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
> Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
> A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
> Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
> Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
> A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***
>
> Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
> To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
> A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
> Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
> September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
> Marigold's Yule (306): GamgeeFest
> Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
> Dearest Dora (445): Larner
> The Research Project (602): Larner
> I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
> For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
> Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***
>
> Memorial Day (358): Antane
> Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
> Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
> The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
> Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
> Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Men: General***
>
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
> Death and Life (511): Golden
> Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
> Penance (278): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***
>
> The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
> Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
> Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
> The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
> Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
> Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Mother Country (329): Altariel
> Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
> Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
> Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
> A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
> Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
> Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
> Hospitality (79): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***
>
> One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
> Cleansed (337): Larner
> Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
> The Fool (216): Marta
> Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
> A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
> Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
> Kinslayer (192): Russandol
> Many Hands (276): Russandol
> Living Jewels (182): shirebound
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***
>
> Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
> I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
> The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
> How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
> Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
> Treed (618): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***
>
> In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
> Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
> Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
> Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
> The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
> The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
> Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
> Tutelage (230): Marta
> Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
> Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
> Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
> Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
> The Vessel (617): Elleth
> This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***
>
> The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
> A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
> The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
> Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
> Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
> Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
> Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
> A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***
>
> Comfort (119): Aeärwen
> In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
> Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
> The Last Hero (263): Jael
> Grace (558): Lanyon
> For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***
>
> Dance (672): alex_quine
> A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
> The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
> Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
> Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
> Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
> Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
> Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***
>
> Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
> Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
> Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
> Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
> In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
> Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***
>
> Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
> Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
> The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
> Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
> Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
> Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***
>
> Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
> Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
> Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
> Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
> Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
> Passing Grace (313): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***
>
> Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
> Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
> Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
> The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
> A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
> A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
> A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
> Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***
>
> A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
> Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
> Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
> No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
> The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
> To See the Light (89): Mirach
> The Awakening (203): MJ
> In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
> Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***
>
> Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
> Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
> On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
> The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
> The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
> Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Eradication (93): Breemon
> The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
> Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
> Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
> Resistance (554): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***
>
> Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
> Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
> How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
> Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
> All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
> Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***
>
> Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
> Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
> Coda (376): Marta
> Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
> All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui
>
>
>
> Marta
>

Msg# 10612

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 -- a question Posted by linaewen0 July 07, 2010 - 22:59:56 Topic ID# 10607
Question -- is it a good idea to send this check ballot around to the authors under my care as a liaison? I think I did that last year, but I can't recall if it was helpful or even necessary -- how many authors are not actually members of this group or have access to the LJ community?

Just wondering how other liaisons deal with check ballots and their authors!

Thanks!

Lin

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
> know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
> would be:
>
> --- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
> --- The story is competing against different-type stories.
> --- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
> locations you didn't select.
>
> For more on checkballots, see:
>
> http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/197122.html
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***
>
> The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
> A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
> Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
> Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
> Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
> Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***
>
> Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
> Before the Fall (141): Elleth
> To be Black (290): Encairion
> The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
> Choices (224): Linaewen
> When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
> The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
> Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
> The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
> King's Ransom (673): splix
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***
>
> A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
> You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
> Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
> Starship (50): shirebound
> Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
> Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
> Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***
>
> In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
> Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
> In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
> To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
> Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
> The Light (303): Pearl Took
> Bruises (368): Soledad
> In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
> Broken (515): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***
>
> Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
> No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
> Walls of White (27): Elleth
> Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
> The Return of the King (573): Jael
> A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
> Rebuffed (524): MithLuin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn***
>
> In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
> Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
> Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
> The New Queen's Bounty (136): Larner
> Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
> The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***
>
> To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
> Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
> A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
> Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
> Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
> Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
> Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
> Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***
>
> The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
> Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
> A Copper Band (251): Himring
> Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
> Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
> The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***
>
> A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
> Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
> Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
> Sisterhood (535): Marta
> Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
> Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
> Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
> Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***
>
> Innocence (662): Dwimordene
> Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
> The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
> Good News (392): Paranoidangel
> Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
> Vigilance (647): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***
>
> What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
> The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
> Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
> A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
> First Time (547): Tanaqui
> Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
> Calm (80): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***
>
> Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
> Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
> Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
> The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
> Flying Free (343): Keiliss
> Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
> Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***
>
> Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
> Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
> Celeritas
> Unravelling (142): Elleth
> RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
> Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
> The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
> Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***
>
> Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
> The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
> At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
> Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
> When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
> Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
> Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
>
> A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
> The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
> Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
> The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
> All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***
>
> Half-Brother (82): Ellie
> The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
> King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
> Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
> Little Bird (379): Soledad
> Find Me (95): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***
>
> Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
> The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
> Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
> Weapons Forged (175): Larner
> What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
> Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
> Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
> BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
> Choosing (498): rhyselle
> The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
> The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
> The Lady (670): alex_quine
> The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
> Promises (81): Lialathuveril
> A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
> Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
> Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
> A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
> Fruition (551): Tanaqui
> Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
> In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***
>
> The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
> Kin No More (516): Ellie
> The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
> A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
> Explaining (54): Larner
> Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
> Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***
>
> Quest (198): Cathleen
> A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
> To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
> The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
> Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
> Duty (674): Lindelea
> The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
> Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
> And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***
>
> Ghost (588): Aeärwen
> Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
> The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
> The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
> Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
> Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
> Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***
>
> After the Fall (482): clotho123
> Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
> A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
> A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
> Envy (317): Larner
> Different Terms (170): Lyra
> Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
> The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***
>
> Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
> Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
> A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
> Farewell (78): mirasaui
> After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
> The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***
>
> Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
> In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
> Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
> Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***
>
> Judgment (115): Aeärwen
> Unrequited (163): elfscribe
> Balrog (521): Phyncke
> Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
> Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
> A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***
>
> Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
> A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
> Sand and Flame (250): Marta
> Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
> Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
> From the Ashes (185): Marta
> Lessons (607): Nath
> Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
> Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
> Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***
>
> Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
> The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
> Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
> Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
> Questioning (258): Larner
> Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***
>
> A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
> More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
> Transformation (590): Larner
> Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
> In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
> Holiday (20): Nath
> The Coimas War (275): Russandol
> The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***
>
> The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
> Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
> O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
> A Gift (151): KyMahalei
> And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
> Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
> This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***
>
> For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
> Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
> (304): Cathleen
> Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
> The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
> The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
> A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***
>
> A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
> A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
> Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
> Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
> Fresh Meat (534): Marta
> Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
> Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***
>
> The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
> Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
> Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
> Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
> Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
> Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> 'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
> The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
> Mightier than the Sword – Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
> Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
> Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
> The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***
>
> Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
> Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
> The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
> By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
> Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
> Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
> Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
> Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
> Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***
>
> Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
> Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
> Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
> The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
> The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
> Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
> The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
> I Entulesse (204): MJ
> Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***
>
> A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
> Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
> The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
> The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
> Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
> The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
> Yew (207): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***
>
> A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
> Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
> A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
> Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
> Into the Woods (75): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***
>
> 'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
> confusing (280): Darth Fingon
> Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
> off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
> Darth Fingon
> Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
> Dreamflower
> Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
> Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
> Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***
>
> A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
> Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
> Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
> Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
> An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
> Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
> Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***
>
> Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
> The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
> Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
> The Drums (430): Malicean
> Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
> The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
> A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***
>
> Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
> Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
> What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
> Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
> Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
> A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
> Contrapposto (531): Marta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***
>
> How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
> And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
> Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
> Descent (625): Lady Roisin
> Forty Days (295): Marta
> Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
> End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***
>
> Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
> Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
> Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
> And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
> Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
> Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
> A New Light (400): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***
>
> Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
> Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
> Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
> Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
> Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
> The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
> First Glance (148): Marta
> The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
> A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love … (245): Súlriel
> The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***
>
> Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
> Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
> We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Strange Land (519): Elfique
> Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
> Uldor (284): Himring
> A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
> The Courier (32): Jael
> The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
> Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***
>
> Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
> Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
> The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
> Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
> Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
> Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
> Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
> Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
> The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
> Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
> Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***
>
> The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
> To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
> Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
> A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
> Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
> At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
> The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
> Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
>
> Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
> Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> 'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
> Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
> Another Road (314): KyMahalei
> Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
> Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Triptych (604): Adaneth
> An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
> Giants' Game (429): Larner
> Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
> Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
> Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***
>
> In Durin's Day (373): Marta
> A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
> In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
> Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
> Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
> Questing (117): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***
>
> In His Eyes (92): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
> Anna Wing
> Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
> Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldo's Guide to Coping with
> Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
> A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
> Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
> Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
> The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
> The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
> Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***
>
> Determined (426): Aeärwen
> Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
> First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
> Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
> More Than Memory (241): Marta
> Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***
>
> Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
> A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
> Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
> Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
> The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
> The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***
>
> Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
> Brightness (427): Faenel
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
> Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
> By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
> No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
> Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***
>
> Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
> (114): Dreamflower
> One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
> Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
> A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
> Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
> Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
> A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***
>
> Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
> To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
> A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
> Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
> September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
> Marigold's Yule (306): GamgeeFest
> Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
> Dearest Dora (445): Larner
> The Research Project (602): Larner
> I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
> For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
> Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***
>
> Memorial Day (358): Antane
> Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
> Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
> The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
> Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
> Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Men: General***
>
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
> Death and Life (511): Golden
> Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
> Penance (278): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***
>
> The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
> Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
> Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
> The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
> Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
> Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Mother Country (329): Altariel
> Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
> Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
> Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
> A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
> Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
> Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
> Hospitality (79): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***
>
> One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
> Cleansed (337): Larner
> Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
> The Fool (216): Marta
> Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
> A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
> Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
> Kinslayer (192): Russandol
> Many Hands (276): Russandol
> Living Jewels (182): shirebound
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***
>
> Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
> I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
> The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
> How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
> Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
> Treed (618): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***
>
> In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
> Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
> Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
> Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
> The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
> The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
> Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
> Tutelage (230): Marta
> Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
> Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
> Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
> Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
> The Vessel (617): Elleth
> This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***
>
> The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
> A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
> The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
> Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
> Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
> Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
> Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
> A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***
>
> Comfort (119): Aeärwen
> In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
> Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
> The Last Hero (263): Jael
> Grace (558): Lanyon
> For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***
>
> Dance (672): alex_quine
> A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
> The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
> Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
> Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
> Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
> Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
> Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***
>
> Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
> Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
> Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
> Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
> In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
> Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***
>
> Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
> Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
> The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
> Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
> Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
> Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***
>
> Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
> Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
> Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
> Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
> Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
> Passing Grace (313): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***
>
> Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
> Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
> Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
> The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
> A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
> A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
> A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
> Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***
>
> A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
> Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
> Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
> No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
> The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
> To See the Light (89): Mirach
> The Awakening (203): MJ
> In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
> Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***
>
> Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
> Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
> On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
> The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
> The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
> Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Eradication (93): Breemon
> The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
> Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
> Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
> Resistance (554): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***
>
> Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
> Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
> How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
> Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
> All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
> Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***
>
> Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
> Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
> Coda (376): Marta
> Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
> All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui
>
>
>
> Marta
>

Msg# 10613

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 07, 2010 - 23:41:31 Topic ID# 10607
Hiya Marlyn,

Thanks for letting us know about this problem. I need to discuss it with
the other categorizers, but we'll do our best to accommodate you. I'll
reply back in a day or two about this.

Marta

On 7/7/2010 11:27 PM, Marlyn Bumpus wrote:
> Hi there!
>
> My story, "In The House of Elrond", is definitely in the wrong category. In the first place, it's a WIP - although the details on the site don't list it as incomplete, I know I entered it as incomplete on the form. Secondly, it is NOT a character study of Aragorn; frankly, although Aragorn II is in the story, it is as a minor character only. There was no listing for Gilraen that didn't include Aragorn. Frankly, I would feel better if this story were in Cross-Cultural: Incomplete.
>
> Is that possible?
>
> Thank you.
>
> Cuio mae.
>
> Aeärwen
>

Msg# 10614

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Sharon July 07, 2010 - 23:42:37 Topic ID# 10607
Mine look pretty good. I'm not hysterical about the placement of 'A Lesson Learned,' but that is an odd one anyhow. *smiles* I had trouble categorizing it!

Blessings,
Agape

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
> know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
> would be:
>
> --- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
> --- The story is competing against different-type stories.
> --- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
> locations you didn't select.
>
> For more on checkballots, see:
>
> http://community.livejournal.com/mefas/197122.html
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***
>
> The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
> A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
> Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
> Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
> Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
> Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***
>
> Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
> Before the Fall (141): Elleth
> To be Black (290): Encairion
> The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
> Choices (224): Linaewen
> When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
> The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
> Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
> The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
> King's Ransom (673): splix
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***
>
> A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
> You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
> Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
> Starship (50): shirebound
> Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
> Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
> Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***
>
> In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
> Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
> In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
> To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
> Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
> The Light (303): Pearl Took
> Bruises (368): Soledad
> In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
> Broken (515): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***
>
> Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
> No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
> Walls of White (27): Elleth
> Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
> The Return of the King (573): Jael
> A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
> Rebuffed (524): MithLuin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn***
>
> In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
> Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
> Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
> The New Queen's Bounty (136): Larner
> Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
> The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***
>
> To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
> Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
> A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
> Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
> Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
> Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
> Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
> Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***
>
> The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
> Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
> A Copper Band (251): Himring
> Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
> Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
> The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***
>
> A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
> Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
> Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
> Sisterhood (535): Marta
> Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
> Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
> Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
> Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***
>
> Innocence (662): Dwimordene
> Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
> The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
> Good News (392): Paranoidangel
> Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
> Vigilance (647): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***
>
> What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
> The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
> Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
> A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
> First Time (547): Tanaqui
> Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
> Calm (80): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***
>
> Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
> Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
> Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
> The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
> Flying Free (343): Keiliss
> Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
> Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***
>
> Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
> Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
> Celeritas
> Unravelling (142): Elleth
> RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
> Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
> The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
> Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***
>
> Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
> The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
> At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
> Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
> When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
> Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
> Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
>
> A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
> The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
> Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
> The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
> All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***
>
> Half-Brother (82): Ellie
> The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
> King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
> Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
> Little Bird (379): Soledad
> Find Me (95): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***
>
> Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
> The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
> Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
> Weapons Forged (175): Larner
> What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
> Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
> Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
> BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
> Choosing (498): rhyselle
> The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
> The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
> The Lady (670): alex_quine
> The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
> Promises (81): Lialathuveril
> A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
> Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
> Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
> A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
> Fruition (551): Tanaqui
> Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
> In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***
>
> The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
> Kin No More (516): Ellie
> The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
> A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
> Explaining (54): Larner
> Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
> Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***
>
> Quest (198): Cathleen
> A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
> To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
> The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
> Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
> Duty (674): Lindelea
> The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
> Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
> And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***
>
> Ghost (588): Aeärwen
> Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
> The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
> The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
> Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
> Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
> Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***
>
> After the Fall (482): clotho123
> Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
> A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
> A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
> Envy (317): Larner
> Different Terms (170): Lyra
> Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
> The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***
>
> Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
> Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
> A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
> Farewell (78): mirasaui
> After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
> The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***
>
> Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
> In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
> Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
> Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***
>
> Judgment (115): Aeärwen
> Unrequited (163): elfscribe
> Balrog (521): Phyncke
> Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
> Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
> A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***
>
> Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
> A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
> Sand and Flame (250): Marta
> Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
> Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
> From the Ashes (185): Marta
> Lessons (607): Nath
> Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
> Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
> Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***
>
> Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
> The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
> Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
> Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
> Questioning (258): Larner
> Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***
>
> A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
> More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
> Transformation (590): Larner
> Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
> In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
> Holiday (20): Nath
> The Coimas War (275): Russandol
> The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***
>
> The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
> Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
> O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
> A Gift (151): KyMahalei
> And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
> Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
> This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***
>
> For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
> Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
> (304): Cathleen
> Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
> The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
> The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
> A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***
>
> A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
> A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
> Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
> Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
> Fresh Meat (534): Marta
> Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
> Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***
>
> The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
> Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
> Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
> Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
> Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
> Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> 'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
> The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
> Mightier than the Sword – Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
> Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
> Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
> The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***
>
> Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
> Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
> The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
> By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
> Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
> Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
> Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
> Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
> Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***
>
> Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
> Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
> Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
> The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
> The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
> Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
> The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
> I Entulesse (204): MJ
> Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***
>
> A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
> Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
> The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
> The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
> Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
> The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
> Yew (207): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***
>
> A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
> Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
> A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
> Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
> Into the Woods (75): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***
>
> 'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
> confusing (280): Darth Fingon
> Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
> off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
> Darth Fingon
> Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
> Dreamflower
> Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
> Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
> Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***
>
> A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
> Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
> Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
> Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
> An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
> Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
> Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***
>
> Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
> The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
> Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
> The Drums (430): Malicean
> Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
> The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
> A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***
>
> Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
> Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
> What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
> Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
> Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
> A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
> Contrapposto (531): Marta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***
>
> How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
> And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
> Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
> Descent (625): Lady Roisin
> Forty Days (295): Marta
> Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
> End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***
>
> Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
> Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
> Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
> And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
> Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
> Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
> A New Light (400): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***
>
> Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
> Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
> Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
> Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
> Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
> The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
> First Glance (148): Marta
> The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
> A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love … (245): Súlriel
> The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***
>
> Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
> Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
> We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Strange Land (519): Elfique
> Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
> Uldor (284): Himring
> A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
> The Courier (32): Jael
> The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
> Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***
>
> Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
> Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
> The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
> Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
> Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
> Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
> Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
> Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
> The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
> Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
> Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***
>
> The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
> To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
> Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
> A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
> Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
> At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
> The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
> Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
>
> Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
> Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> 'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
> Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
> Another Road (314): KyMahalei
> Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
> Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Triptych (604): Adaneth
> An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
> Giants' Game (429): Larner
> Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
> Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
> Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***
>
> In Durin's Day (373): Marta
> A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
> In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
> Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
> Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
> Questing (117): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***
>
> In His Eyes (92): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
> Anna Wing
> Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
> Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldo's Guide to Coping with
> Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
> A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
> Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
> Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
> The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
> The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
> Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***
>
> Determined (426): Aeärwen
> Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
> First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
> Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
> More Than Memory (241): Marta
> Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***
>
> Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
> A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
> Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
> Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
> The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
> The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***
>
> Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
> Brightness (427): Faenel
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
> Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
> By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
> No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
> Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***
>
> Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
> (114): Dreamflower
> One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
> Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
> A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
> Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
> Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
> A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***
>
> Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
> To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
> A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
> Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
> September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
> Marigold's Yule (306): GamgeeFest
> Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
> Dearest Dora (445): Larner
> The Research Project (602): Larner
> I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
> For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
> Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***
>
> Memorial Day (358): Antane
> Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
> Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
> The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
> Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
> Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Men: General***
>
> Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
> Death and Life (511): Golden
> Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
> Penance (278): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***
>
> The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
> Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
> Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
> The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
> Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
> Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Mother Country (329): Altariel
> Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
> Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
> Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
> A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
> Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
> Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
> Hospitality (79): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***
>
> One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
> Cleansed (337): Larner
> Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
> The Fool (216): Marta
> Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
> A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
> Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
> Kinslayer (192): Russandol
> Many Hands (276): Russandol
> Living Jewels (182): shirebound
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***
>
> Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
> I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
> The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
> How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
> Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
> Treed (618): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***
>
> In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
> Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
> Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
> Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
> The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
> The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
> Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
> Tutelage (230): Marta
> Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
> Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
> Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
> Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
> The Vessel (617): Elleth
> This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***
>
> The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
> A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
> The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
> Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
> Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
> Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
> Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
> A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***
>
> Comfort (119): Aeärwen
> In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
> Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
> The Last Hero (263): Jael
> Grace (558): Lanyon
> For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***
>
> Dance (672): alex_quine
> A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
> The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
> Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
> Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
> Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
> Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
> Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***
>
> Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
> Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
> Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
> Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
> In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
> Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***
>
> Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
> Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
> The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
> Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
> Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
> Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***
>
> Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
> Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
> Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
> Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
> Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
> Passing Grace (313): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***
>
> Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
> Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
> Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
> The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
> A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
> A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
> A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
> Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***
>
> A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
> Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
> Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
> No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
> The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
> To See the Light (89): Mirach
> The Awakening (203): MJ
> In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
> Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***
>
> Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
> Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
> On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
> The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
> The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
> Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Eradication (93): Breemon
> The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
> Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
> Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
> Resistance (554): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***
>
> Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
> Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
> How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
> Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
> All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
> Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***
>
> Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
> Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
> Coda (376): Marta
> Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
> All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui
>
>
>
> Marta
>

Msg# 10615

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 -- a question Posted by telperion1 July 07, 2010 - 23:51:28 Topic ID# 10607
On 7/7/2010 11:59 PM, linaewen0 wrote:
>
>
> Question -- is it a good idea to send this check ballot around to the
> authors under my care as a liaison? I think I did that last year, but I
> can't recall if it was helpful or even necessary -- how many authors are
> not actually members of this group or have access to the LJ community?
>
> Just wondering how other liaisons deal with check ballots and their authors!
>
> Thanks!
>
> Lin
>

Hi Lin,

I just checked, and out of the first twenty-five authors
(alphabetically), eight are *just* authors - not also members of
MEFAwards. So if that trend holds, a fair few don't get MEFAwards
emails. Technically anyone can see the mefas LJ, but I have no way of
knowing how many authors actually read here.

I think it's a good idea to let your authors know about the check
ballot. (A good idea, but maybe not 100% necessary, if other liaisons
don't want to do this.) It may be a good idea to point them to one site
or the other and let them know the check ballots are available, rather
than email them the check ballot. That way they can see the most up to
date version, and can reply there if they need any changes made. It's
probably best to send them to the mefas LJ, since anyone can reply
there, and since only the first post (not the follow-up comments) will
show up.

Marta

Msg# 10616

a reminder - trim your posts Posted by telperion1 July 07, 2010 - 23:54:47 Topic ID# 10616
Hey guys,

It's important to trim your replies to messages from this group. Many
members are on "Digest" mode, which means they only receive one or two
emails a day, with all of the messages listed one after the other.

This is especially important with the check ballot, because it is so
long. Imagine having to scroll past the whole check ballot any time
people replied. So please, only quote the part you are replying to, or
delete the whole check ballot if you don't need to quote any of it. In
most email programs you can do this by holding down the shift key and
"Page Down" until you have selected the whole digest. Or you can start a
new message rather than replying. Those people on daily digests will
thank you. :-)

Marta

Msg# 10617

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Neume Indil July 08, 2010 - 1:29:21 Topic ID# 10607
Slight problem with one of mine:

"***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad"

It's Eowyn/Faramir, so if it's under a race it should be the collective
House of Denethor one, or at least Gondorians. :)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10618

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 1:46:53 Topic ID# 10607
Hi Neume,

We use the word "Dunedain" to refer to all the Numenor-descended men.
That means all the Gondorians, Aragorn, and any other of Aragorn's folk
in the North (Gilraen, Halbarad, etc.) The Romance: Dunedain subcategory
includes some Aragorn/Arwen stories, but also some involving Gondorians.
I know my own story, "When Witner Comes" is Faramir/Eowyn, and some
others may be as well.

We could *maybe* change the subcategory name, but I was trying to keep
it short to help out the banner makers. Or if you prefer we can add
"Dunedain" to our glossary, so anyone who isn't sure what it means could
look it up.

If you still feel this isn't an appropriate group, let me know.

Marta

On 7/8/2010 2:28 AM, Neume Indil wrote:
>
>
> Slight problem with one of mine:
>
> "***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
> >
> > Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> > Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> > Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> > A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> > When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> > A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> > Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad"
>
> It's Eowyn/Faramir, so if it's under a race it should be the collective
> House of Denethor one, or at least Gondorians. :)
>

Msg# 10619

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 08, 2010 - 1:59:43 Topic ID# 10607
Hi!

The list of categories/genres is final, right? I mean, perhaps there might be some mistakes about authors, but there won't be new categories added?
I ask because, according to this list, I can start making winner banners little by little. ;)

Ellynn


--- On Wed, 7/7/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:

From: telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com>
Subject: [MEFAwards] Check Ballot v. 1
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, July 7, 2010, 7:30 PM

Hey guys,

Here is the first version of the checkballot.





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10620

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 2:20:41 Topic ID# 10607
On 7/8/2010 2:59 AM, Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
>
> Hi!
>
> The list of categories/genres is final, right? I mean, perhaps there
> might be some mistakes about authors, but there won't be new categories
> added?
> I ask because, according to this list, I can start making winner banners
> little by little. ;)
>
> Ellynn
>

Hiya Ellynn,

The categories and subcategories are basically set - we will move some
stories around, but I don't think we'll be creating whole new
subcategories. However, we *may* be renaming the current ones. So, if
you can hold off another week that would probably be best. After the
16th, the names will be final and you can count on them to stay as they
are at that point.

Marta

Msg# 10621

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Voirrey July 08, 2010 - 2:53:16 Topic ID# 10607
Hi Marta,

I was going to say the same thing about 'Pure Morning' - which is in that same category and is about Boromir, Theoden, and Éowyn - none of which would usually be considered 'Dunedain'; but if 'Dunedain', is being used as a much bigger blanket term than some of us, at least, understand the term, then that's fine, it is in the right place and competing against similar. (It looks, from this short thread, as if at least 2 out of 7 of us found the group name confusing... perhaps a change of name for the category could be considered for the future?)


All mine are, therefore, fine. Thanks to the hard working volunteers for doing such a good job.

Curiouswombat


----- Original Message -----
From: telperion1
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Cc: Neume Indil
Sent: Thursday, July 08, 2010 7:46 AM
Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] Check Ballot v. 1



Hi Neume,

We use the word "Dunedain" to refer to all the Numenor-descended men.
That means all the Gondorians, Aragorn, and any other of Aragorn's folk
in the North (Gilraen, Halbarad, etc.) The Romance: Dunedain subcategory
includes some Aragorn/Arwen stories, but also some involving Gondorians.
I know my own story, "When Witner Comes" is Faramir/Eowyn, and some
others may be as well.

We could *maybe* change the subcategory name, but I was trying to keep
it short to help out the banner makers. Or if you prefer we can add
"Dunedain" to our glossary, so anyone who isn't sure what it means could
look it up.

If you still feel this isn't an appropriate group, let me know.

Marta

On 7/8/2010 2:28 AM, Neume Indil wrote:
>
>
> Slight problem with one of mine:
>
> "***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
> >
> > Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> > Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> > Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> > A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> > When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> > A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> > Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad"
>
> It's Eowyn/Faramir, so if it's under a race it should be the collective
> House of Denethor one, or at least Gondorians. :)
>




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10622

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by nelyo\_russandol July 08, 2010 - 3:51:58 Topic ID# 10607
Hi, this is my first MEFA competition, so apologies to all if my query is not relevant.

I am concerned that two of my nominated stories, "Many Hands", which revolves around Narsil/Anduril through the ages, and Kinslayer, which is an irreverent piece about the Valar, seem to have ended up in the same bag (***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***), when they are absolutely disparate stories.

Given the lack of sub-categories for "Other beings" - everything falls under "General" I was wondering if Kinslayer could perhaps be moved to ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General*** or to ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor*** Perhaps my liaison can advise on where it fits best?

Thanks,
Russandol.

Msg# 10623

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by melissa chandra July 08, 2010 - 4:58:30 Topic ID# 10607
Hello,
 
I noted a mistake in the placement of one of my stories, and another story's placement that I would really love to see changed.
 
The mistake is in the placement of:
***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
It is because the Eriador/Shire part is actually not that consequencial to the story; it is just a sort of epilogue. So could you please put it under another category? Related to the Silmarillion, hopefully? If not, something more neutral would work, I guess... but definitely not this. (It could be misleading to readers.)
 
And then I noticed this:
***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Like the first, it could prove misleading to readers, as it is a crossover. Could you please put it with other crossovers? But if it cannot be done, then I can say I am satisfied with the placement. (I noticed the same thing with Not Quite a Maia by Kara's Aunty... but I have no right to speak for her, nor have I gotten a permission from her to do so. :) I have not checked if there were similar cases.) Please consider it...
 
My other stories were already in their proper categories, and I thank you, volunteers, for the hard work you put up in categorising everything. :)
 
Thank you and best wishes,
Rey




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10624

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 6:35:40 Topic ID# 10607
> Hi, this is my first MEFA competition, so apologies to all if my query
> is not relevant.
>
> I am concerned that two of my nominated stories, "Many Hands", which
> revolves around Narsil/Anduril through the ages, and Kinslayer, which is
> an irreverent piece about the Valar, seem to have ended up in the same
> bag (***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***), when they are
> absolutely disparate stories.
>
> Given the lack of sub-categories for "Other beings" - everything falls
> under "General" I was wondering if Kinslayer could perhaps be moved to
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General*** or to ***SubCategory: Genres:
> Humor: Parody or Black Humor*** Perhaps my liaison can advise on where
> it fits best?
>
> Thanks,
> Russandol.
>

Hi Russandol,

I hear your concern, and I understand why you feel that way. However,
I'm not sure it's the problem you think it is. Here's why.

Stories can be grouped in many ways. Just looking at the varieties of
main categories, there are three ways stories can be split up - Race,
Time Period, or Genre. So each story selects three main categories, but
they only end up in one of those. The end result is that, whatever main
category you are in, there's a good deal of variety regarding the other
two. (First Age stories would involve the same timeline, but could
contain fluff about Feanor's children growing up in Valinor, to romance,
to action/adventure, to angst, to give just one example.) The Races:
Other Beings is set up for those stories that involve characters that
are a bit off the beaten track: inanimate objects, the Valar/Maiar, and
characters like Tom Bombadil and Gollum that don't really seem to fit in
anywhere else. That is the common thread, and they will draw people who
want to read about characters that are a bit off the beaten track. A
story about Narsil and the Valar qualify, I think. Even though they are
very different from each other, they have that in common.

This isn't that different from a larger category. It may not be so
obvious because you might not have two stories together, but you will
find a lot of diversity in the various subcategories, if you're familiar
with the other stories. Humor will involve all the different Races and
Time Periods; Elves will involve all the different Genres and Time
Periods, and so on. The important thing is what they do have in common.
In this case, that means that all the sotire sare about characters that
don't fit into the more common races.

So unless you feel strongly about this, I think your pieces are actually
in a pretty good place. :-) And so I'd like to leave them there.

Marta

Msg# 10625

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 6:42:27 Topic ID# 10607
Hi Rey,

Thanks for noticing these. I saw your email and want to discuss the
options for moving your stories around with the other categorizing
volunteers. Hopefully I'll have an answer for you by tonight or tomorrow.

Marta

On 7/8/2010 5:58 AM, melissa chandra wrote:
>
>
> Hello,
>
> I noted a mistake in the placement of one of my stories, and another
> story's placement that I would really love to see changed.
>
> The mistake is in the placement of:
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> It is because the Eriador/Shire part is actually not that consequencial
> to the story; it is just a sort of epilogue. So could you please put it
> under another category? Related to the Silmarillion, hopefully? If not,
> something more neutral would work, I guess... but definitely not this.
> (It could be misleading to readers.)
>
> And then I noticed this:
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
> Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
> Like the first, it could prove misleading to readers, as it is a
> crossover. Could you please put it with other crossovers? But if it
> cannot be done, then I can say I am satisfied with the placement. (I
> noticed the same thing with Not Quite a Maia by Kara's Aunty... but I
> have no right to speak for her, nor have I gotten a permission from her
> to do so. :) I have not checked if there were similar cases.) Please
> consider it...
>
> My other stories were already in their proper categories, and I thank
> you, volunteers, for the hard work you put up in categorising everything. :)
>
> Thank you and best wishes,
> Rey
>

Msg# 10626

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by nelyo\_russandol July 08, 2010 - 7:16:34 Topic ID# 10607
Marta,
Thanks for your quick reply! Perhaps it is because I don't understand this setup completely, but I still disagree.

"Many Hands" main category was "Multi-Age", not "Other beings". It has ended up with "Kinslayer" by default.

You say the "Other beings" category is no different to the others, but I can see a myriad of of subcategories for Elves, Hobbits and Men, so that they are split into "humour" or "angst", or "family" or by period or length. But there is only one bucket for "Other beings". "One size fits all," if the key character is an unusual one. But, as I say, the stories are complete opposites, they were submitted under different categories and they have ended up together by chance, when I think they are like cheese and chalk.

Thanks,
Russandol


PS. You may prefer to take this discussion off-line.

Msg# 10627

Re: ADMIN - Categorization III - Check Ballots Posted by elhanan\_austin July 08, 2010 - 11:08:22 Topic ID# 10606
Hi Marta,

I checked my stories and everything looks hunky-dory. I do find one thing confusing, though. You state:

'There is one exception regarding "Incompletes": we didn't have enough Incompletes subcategories to have one in very many main category, and some authors were given the choice to run against finished fic rather than go into a main category that didn't really fit. This affects 238. A Singular Honour by Shemyaza1; it is a WIP but is competing in Genres: Crossover: Incomplete.'

This makes no sense. There is no Genres: Crossover: Incomplete. And "A Singular Honour is not a WIP. You have the story listed under Genres: Crossover: General:
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella

Shemyaza's other story "Dark Power Arising" is the WIP and you have it listed correctly under Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete.

At any rate, I do recall that during the nomination period I pointed out to you that "A Singular Honour" was incorrectly labeled as a WIP and you said you would fix it. I also contacted Shemyaza about it as well and I believe she agreed that it wasn't a WIP. Apparently, the WIP tag was never removed? Just thought you should know. You might wish to contact Shemyaza and ask her. She's new to the MEFAs and may not be aware of these check ballots or their significance and so may not bother to look at them.

Kudos to the volunteers for a great job in getting all these stories into categories.

Fiondil

Msg# 10628

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Robert Hoy July 08, 2010 - 11:14:04 Topic ID# 10607
Hi. I don't think "Not so like Luthien, after all" should be categorized as
a Silmarillion ficlet. It is set in the Fourth Age, at the time of
Aragorn's 200th birthday, and deals with the thoughts of Arwen, who isn't
mentioned in the Quenta Silmarillion (for obvious reasons :) ). Maybe the
title and her thoughts on Luthien and Beren, Idril and Tuor confused the
matter :)

As far as what category it *should* be put in, there are so many, but
perhaps something involving Fourth Age, character studies, or cross-culture?

Thanks,
Maeglin



On Wed, Jul 7, 2010 at 10:30 PM, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:

> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the first version of the checkballot. Look it over and let me
> know if you see anything you think needs to be moved. Possible moves
> would be:
>
> --- The piece is in a main category you didn't select.
> --- The story is competing against different-type stories.
> --- The story is in a subcategory built around characters, subgenres, or
> locations you didn't select.
>
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10629

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Bonnie L. Sherrell July 08, 2010 - 12:36:20 Topic ID# 10607
I've not seen any of mine inappropriately placed this year.
Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

Msg# 10630

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Marlyn Bumpus July 08, 2010 - 13:50:13 Topic ID# 10607
Hi there!

> Thanks for letting us know about this problem. I need to discuss it with
> the other categorizers, but we'll do our best to accommodate you. I'll
> reply back in a day or two about this.

That works for me. Thanks for the assistance.

Cuio mae.

Aeärwen

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10631

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by thunderatiger July 08, 2010 - 14:33:17 Topic ID# 10607
Since everyone else was chiming in, I decided to jump in, too, even if only to say that I'm very happy with both the categories and the subcategories my stories landed in. Many thanks to all the hard-working volunteers! I can only imagine how complicated this became in trying to make viable categories with 600+ stories.

Thundera

Msg# 10632

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by Berni Crumb July 08, 2010 - 16:36:20 Topic ID# 10607
I'm good with the placement of my four stories. I realized after I'd
submitted my form that "Unravelling the Past" probably could have been
considered AU from some perspectives, but I think that the First Age time
period thing it ended up in is perfectly fine.

You MEFA volunteers are doing a fantastic job!

Vorondavë ar linalmië,
Rhyselle


Fantasy remains a human right: we make in our measure and in our derivative
mode, because we are made: and not only made, but made in the image and
likeness of a Maker. -- J.R.R. Tolkien, On Fairy-Stories, 1939


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10633

move request - In the House of Elrond by Aearwen Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 16:50:05 Topic ID# 10633
Hey guys,

After conferring with the other categorizing volunteers, I decided to
move Aearwen's story "In the House of Elrond" to Races: Cross-Cultural:
Incomplete. This is because it was incorrectly marked as a completed fic
(which I've now also fixed at our website). Moving it made its old
subcategory too small to compete, something I try very hard to avoid at
this stage, but for a genuine error like this we decided to make an
exception.



To deal with the too-small subcategory, I moved some stories out of
Genres: Character Study: General into Genres: Character Study: Aragorn.
These stories involved Gondorians, and so I think they will appeal to
similar readers. We are tentatively renaming that subcategory "Genres:
Character Study: Dunedain," but are discussing alternate names since so
many people were confused by that Dunedain label elsewhere. We may make
it "Genres: Character Study: Aragorn or Gondorians" or something
similar. Once we make a final decision on what to do with the "Dunedain"
subcategory names (there are several), I'll make another post about
that. But for the mean time, the new subcategories are:


***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***

Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
The Light (303): Pearl Took
In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
Broken (515): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Dunedain***
[was: SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Aragorn]

*In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
The New Queens Bounty (136): Larner
Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
*Bruises (368): Soledad


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***

Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
*In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
Another Road (314): KyMahalei
Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1

(Asterisk'd stories were moved.)

Marta

Msg# 10634

move request - Earille's "The Imperishable Flame" Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 17:02:42 Topic ID# 10634
Hey guys,

I'm following up on Earille's request to have her story "The
Imperishable Flame".

On Imperishable Flame, Earille said:

"It is because the Eriador/Shire part is actually not that consequencial
to the story; it is just a sort of epilogue. So could you please put it
under another category? Related to the Silmarillion, hopefully? If not,
something more neutral would work, I guess... but definitely not this.
(It could be misleading to readers.)"

I looked at this, and see why we put it in "Eriador or Shire." Under
Story Settings Earille listed Dorthonion but also The Angle which is
part of Eriador. What this tells us (the categorizing volunteers) is
that the story could go equally okay in either place. Similarly, there
were events and characters from both the Silm and Lord of the Rings
chosen. The characters were "Characters for Readers" rather than
"Characters for Categorization," but as there were non "Chars for Cat."
selected, there was no way to know one was more important than the
other, short of reading the story. (Which unfortunately we didn't have
time to do!) So while I see while it's not really an appropriate
subcategory, we did follow the information provided by the author.

What I'm going to do is do a *conditional* move. I will move this story
into a Silmfic subcategory (Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion) - for
now. This move makes "Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire" as small as it
can be and still compete. If anyone else asks to move, if it's due to an
error on the part of the categorizers, I will have to move "Imperishable
Flame" back in with the Eriador or Shire stories. The only other option
would be to totally disband the subcategory, and I don't want to do that.

In the future, it's best to only list locations if you'd be happy for
your story to be categorized based on that. This applies to everyone,
and is not meant as a harsh criticism of this particular author, by the
way! It's an easy mistake to make, but we *do* depend on this
information, and it's not always possible to move stories around.

The affected subcategories are:

***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***

After the Fall (482): clotho123
*The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
Envy (317): Larner
Different Terms (170): Lyra
Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha

(Asterisk'd story is moved.)

Marta

Msg# 10635

move request - Crystal Green by Earille Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 17:12:22 Topic ID# 10635
Hey guys,

I'm following up on Earille's request regarding "Crystal Green":

"Like the first, it could prove misleading to readers, as it is a
crossover. Could you please put it with other crossovers? But if it
cannot be done, then I can say I am satisfied with the placement. (I
noticed the same thing with Not Quite a Maia by Kara's Aunty... but I
have no right to speak for her, nor have I gotten a permission from her
to do so. :)"

In this case I think we'll leave it where it is. This story is a WIP,
right? We try very hard to have all the WIPs compete against other WIPs,
and the only time we make an exception to that is when there aren't
enough WIPs in *any* of their category choices for them to compete
together. This year there are only three crossovers, and one of them was
a crossover between Tolkien and "real life" history. So we didn't have
enough WIP crossovers to set up a "Genres: Crossover: Incomplete"
subcategory. That's why we moved "Crystal Green" and the other stories
into their second- or third-choice category.

For the record, the affected stories are:

--- 361. Not Quite a Maia by Kara's Aunty (in Genres: HUmor: Incomplete)
--- 235. Dark Power Rising by Shemyaza1 (in Races: Cross-Cultural:
Incomplete)
--- 468. Crystal Green by Earille (in Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete)

I think the summaries of these stories all make it reasonably clear that
these are crossovers, but if any of the authors want me to change their
summaries, I can do that easily. Just let me know.

Marta

Msg# 10636

Re: Check Ballot v. 1 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 17:22:12 Topic ID# 10607
On 7/8/2010 12:13 PM, Robert Hoy wrote:
>
>
> Hi. I don't think "Not so like Luthien, after all" should be categorized as
> a Silmarillion ficlet. It is set in the Fourth Age, at the time of
> Aragorn's 200th birthday, and deals with the thoughts of Arwen, who isn't
> mentioned in the Quenta Silmarillion (for obvious reasons :) ). Maybe the
> title and her thoughts on Luthien and Beren, Idril and Tuor confused the
> matter :)
>
> As far as what category it *should* be put in, there are so many, but
> perhaps something involving Fourth Age, character studies, or cross-culture?
>
> Thanks,
> Maeglin
>

Hiya Maeglin,

Thanks for bringing this up. I'm discussing it with the other
categorizers and we'll do our best to move it for you.

If we move it, I wanted to run some suggestions by you for the new
subcategory. We need to keep it in the Ficlet main category, since
that's what you chose. The other options are Gondor, Eriador or Shire,
and General. I see it's set in Minas Tirith so, assuming we move it,
would you be okay with "Genres: Ficlets: Gondor"?

Marta

Msg# 10637

move request - Harvest Dreams by Linda Hoyland Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 17:33:58 Topic ID# 10637
Hey guys,

Over at the mefas LJ, Linda Hoyland expressed a concern about her
drabble series "Harvest Dreams." It was in Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles.
If you recall, Mixed Drabbles means it contains both drabbles and
drabble series, but usually there's a better mix than we managed to get
there. ("Harvest Dreams" was the only series along other single
drabbles.) In her third-choice category, there was a group of drabble
series, so I moved Linda's drabbles there. The affected subcategories are:


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***

To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
*Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Drabbles***
(was: Races: Men: Mixed Drabbles)

Mother Country (329): Altariel
Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
Hospitality (79): Wormwood

(The asterisk'd story was moved.)

Marta

Msg# 10638

Check Ballot, v. 2 Posted by telperion1 July 08, 2010 - 17:38:33 Topic ID# 10638
Hey guys,

Below is an updated check ballot. I have moved several stories, and
wanted to give you the most up-to-date information.

There are still a few requests pending. If I replied back saying I
needed to discuss your situation with the other volunteers, or if I
haven't replied yet, don't panic; this doesn't mean that we're saying
no. It just means a decision hasn't been reached yet.

If I have replied back saying we'll move your story, *please* check and
make sure it's actually moved below. There are a lot of requests being
made just now, and it's easy for me to agree to move something but
somehow forget to actually do that.

Marta




***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***

The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***

Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
Before the Fall (141): Elleth
To be Black (290): Encairion
The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
Choices (224): Linaewen
When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
King's Ransom (673): splix


***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***

A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
Starship (50): shirebound
Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy


***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***

Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
The Light (303): Pearl Took
In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
Broken (515): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***

Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
Walls of White (27): Elleth
Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
The Return of the King (573): Jael
A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
Rebuffed (524): MithLuin


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***

To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Dunedain***

In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
The New Queens Bounty (136): Larner
Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
Bruises (368): Soledad


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***

The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
A Copper Band (251): Himring
Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***

A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
Sisterhood (535): Marta
Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***

Innocence (662): Dwimordene
Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
Good News (392): Paranoidangel
Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
Vigilance (647): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***

What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
First Time (547): Tanaqui
Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
Calm (80): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***

Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
Flying Free (343): Keiliss
Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***

Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
Celeritas
Unravelling (142): Elleth
RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza


***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***

To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
Encore (268): Lady Roisin
To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***

Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***

Half-Brother (82): Ellie
The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
Little Bird (379): Soledad
Find Me (95): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***

Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
Weapons Forged (175): Larner
What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***

Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
Choosing (498): rhyselle
The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***

The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
The Lady (670): alex_quine
The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
Promises (81): Lialathuveril
A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***

Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
Fruition (551): Tanaqui
Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***

The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
Kin No More (516): Ellie
The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
Explaining (54): Larner
Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***

Quest (198): Cathleen
A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
Duty (674): Lindelea
The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***

Ghost (588): Aeärwen
Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***

After the Fall (482): clotho123
The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
Envy (317): Larner
Different Terms (170): Lyra
Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha


***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***

Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
Farewell (78): mirasaui
After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***

Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***

For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
Spring Dance (301): Leianora
The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***

No Regrets (483): clotho123
Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
Crude Material (608): Ygrain


***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***

Judgment (115): Aeärwen
Unrequited (163): elfscribe
Balrog (521): Phyncke
Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***

Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
Sand and Flame (250): Marta
Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***

Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
From the Ashes (185): Marta
Lessons (607): Nath
Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***

Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
Questioning (258): Larner
Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach


***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***

A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
Transformation (590): Larner
Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
Holiday (20): Nath
The Coimas War (275): Russandol
The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***

The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
A Gift (151): KyMahalei
And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***

For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
(304): Cathleen
Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***

A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
Fresh Meat (534): Marta
Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***

The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***

'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
Mightier than the Sword  Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***

Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv


***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***

Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
I Entulesse (204): MJ
Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***

A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
Yew (207): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***

A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
Into the Woods (75): Wormwood


***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***

'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
confusing (280): Darth Fingon
Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
Darth Fingon
Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
Dreamflower
Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest


***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***

A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***

Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
The Drums (430): Malicean
Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***

Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
Contrapposto (531): Marta


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***

How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
Descent (625): Lady Roisin
Forty Days (295): Marta
Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***

Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
A New Light (400): Marigold


***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***

Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
First Glance (148): Marta
The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love & (245): Súlriel
The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5


***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***

Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
When Winter Comes (138): Marta
A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad


***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***

Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Strange Land (519): Elfique
Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
Uldor (284): Himring
A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
The Courier (32): Jael
The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***

Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***

The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***

Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
Another Road (314): KyMahalei
Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***

Triptych (604): Adaneth
An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
Giants' Game (429): Larner
Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***

In Durin's Day (373): Marta
A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
Questing (117): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***

In His Eyes (92): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
Anna Wing
Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldos Guide to Coping with
Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***

Determined (426): Aeärwen
Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
More Than Memory (241): Marta
Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***

Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***

Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
Brightness (427): Faenel
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth


***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***

Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
(114): Dreamflower
One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***

Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
Marigolds Yule (306): GamgeeFest
Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***

When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
Dearest Dora (445): Larner
The Research Project (602): Larner
I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***

Memorial Day (358): Antane
Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Races: Men: General***

Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
Death and Life (511): Golden
Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
Penance (278): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Drabbles***

Mother Country (329): Altariel
Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
Hospitality (79): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***

The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***

One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
Cleansed (337): Larner
Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
The Fool (216): Marta
Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
Kinslayer (192): Russandol
Many Hands (276): Russandol
Living Jewels (182): shirebound


***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***

Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
Treed (618): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***

In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
Tutelage (230): Marta
Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***

Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
The Vessel (617): Elleth
This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***

The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***

Comfort (119): Aeärwen
In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
The Last Hero (263): Jael
Grace (558): Lanyon
For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance


***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***

Dance (672): alex_quine
A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***

Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***

Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***

Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
Passing Grace (313): Virtuella


***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***

Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***

A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
To See the Light (89): Mirach
The Awakening (203): MJ
In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***

Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***

Eradication (93): Breemon
The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
Resistance (554): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***

Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta


***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***

Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
Coda (376): Marta
Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui

Msg# 10639

Re: move request - In the House of Elrond by Aearwen Posted by Marlyn Bumpus July 08, 2010 - 19:50:32 Topic ID# 10633
Hi there!

> After conferring with the other categorizing volunteers, I decided to
> move Aearwen's story "In the House of Elrond" to Races: Cross-Cultural:
> Incomplete.

Thank you! With that, I'm fine with my subcategories. You guys rock!

Cuio mae.

Aeýrwen

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10640

Re: ADMIN - Categorization III - Check Ballots Posted by telperion1 July 09, 2010 - 5:19:13 Topic ID# 10606
Hi Arthur,

I mis-spoke (mistyped?) when I refered to Crossover: Incomplete. Of
course there's no such subcategory. What I meant was Crossover: General.

As for the WIP issue, you are correct. I have looked up the email you
sent me, and I was sure I had fixed it. But perhaps I made a mistake
somehow? Luckily this will not affect categorization. Actually, it makes
things a bit simpler, because no WIPs are running against finished
stories. :-)

Marta

On 7/8/2010 11:55 AM, elhanan_austin wrote:
>
>
> Hi Marta,
>
> I checked my stories and everything looks hunky-dory. I do find one
> thing confusing, though. You state:
>
> 'There is one exception regarding "Incompletes": we didn't have enough
> Incompletes subcategories to have one in very many main category, and
> some authors were given the choice to run against finished fic rather
> than go into a main category that didn't really fit. This affects 238. A
> Singular Honour by Shemyaza1; it is a WIP but is competing in Genres:
> Crossover: Incomplete.'
>
> This makes no sense. There is no Genres: Crossover: Incomplete. And "A
> Singular Honour is not a WIP. You have the story listed under Genres:
> Crossover: General:
> >
> > To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> > Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> > Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> > Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> > To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> > A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> > The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> > Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
> Shemyaza's other story "Dark Power Arising" is the WIP and you have it
> listed correctly under Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete.
>
> At any rate, I do recall that during the nomination period I pointed out
> to you that "A Singular Honour" was incorrectly labeled as a WIP and you
> said you would fix it. I also contacted Shemyaza about it as well and I
> believe she agreed that it wasn't a WIP. Apparently, the WIP tag was
> never removed? Just thought you should know. You might wish to contact
> Shemyaza and ask her. She's new to the MEFAs and may not be aware of
> these check ballots or their significance and so may not bother to look
> at them.
>
> Kudos to the volunteers for a great job in getting all these stories
> into categories.
>
> Fiondil
>

Msg# 10641

Re: Check Ballot, v. 2 Posted by Doc Bushwell July 09, 2010 - 11:44:26 Topic ID# 10638
I am aghast at the egregious categorization of my "Flame of the Desert" as Adventure: General when it is most accurately classified as Adventure: Wacky Elven Road Trips Across the Valinorin Desert. I mean, really, get with it, people!*



*I might just be in an incorrigibly irreverent Friday kind of mood. ;^) Seriously, all's copacetic as far as I am concerned. Thanks so much for all your hard work! *Applause for the marvelous MEFA volunteers!*

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Below is an updated check ballot. I have moved several stories, and
> wanted to give you the most up-to-date information.
>

Msg# 10642

Re: Late review replies? Posted by Doc Bushwell July 09, 2010 - 12:02:47 Topic ID# 10554
Please forgive the late and off-topic (I think) reply here, Fiondil, but in lieu of individual responses, I thanked my reviewers (including you) through a public post on my LJ:

http://pandemonium-213.livejournal.com/153548.html

I know that such a catch-all thank you is gauche, and that my mother would remind me that handwritten thank you notes on vellum are in order ;^), but there it is. My appreciation is no less heartfelt.

I have to admit that I prefer public venues for responses to reviews or if replies are private, that these are person-to-person with no third party involved.

Anyway, mea culpa if you or anyone else felt slighted by my orcish lack of manners.

--

Msg# 10643

Re: Check Ballot, v. 2 Posted by raksha022002 July 09, 2010 - 15:22:53 Topic ID# 10638
No complaints about my stories' placement. And thanks, Marta and the merry MEFA volunteers, for all your hard work!


Raksha the Demon



<<<<<<<<--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Below is an updated check ballot. I have moved several stories, and
> wanted to give you the most up-to-date information.
>
> There are still a few requests pending. If I replied back saying I
> needed to discuss your situation with the other volunteers, or if I
> haven't replied yet, don't panic; this doesn't mean that we're saying
> no. It just means a decision hasn't been reached yet.
>
> If I have replied back saying we'll move your story, *please* check and
> make sure it's actually moved below. There are a lot of requests being
> made just now, and it's easy for me to agree to move something but
> somehow forget to actually do that.
>
> Marta
>
>
>
>>
> >>>>>>>>>>>>

Msg# 10644

Re: Late review replies? Posted by elhanan\_austin July 10, 2010 - 9:00:39 Topic ID# 10554
Actually, I wasn't pointing a finger at any one person but was just wondering why after all this time these particular reviews showed up. *grin* As I generally don't do LJ I would have no means of knowing you had thanked anyone, least of all me. I did not reply to everyone's review myself as I was traveling after the New Year and just couldn't get to everyone that I wanted to, but I doubt anyone was upset that I didn't.

And since Marta was able to explain the reason why some people, including myself, suddenly got these reviews 6 months late, to me it's now a non-issue.

Fiondil

Msg# 10645

catching up on emails Posted by telperion1 July 10, 2010 - 20:02:57 Topic ID# 10645
Hey guys,

I had an internet connection problem at my apartment, and will be
getting caught up on emails tonight and possibly tomorrow as well.
(There are quite a few.) I haven't forgotten about your requests! I
appreciate your patience as I get things straightened out.

Thanks,

Marta

Msg# 10646

move request - Russandol's Kinslayer Posted by telperion1 July 10, 2010 - 21:02:16 Topic ID# 10646
Hey guys,

I've been talking with the other categorizing volunteers about
Russandol's request to have "Kinslayer" moved. We decided to move it for
the moment, so "Kinslayer" will now be competing in Genres: Humor:
Parody or Black Humor. If there are a lot of requests based on errors,
so that Kinslayer's old subcategory (Races: Other Beings: General)
becomes too small, we may have to move "Kinslayer" back. But Races:
Other Beings: General is a good size even without "Kinslayer," so I
don't think that will be a problem.

I did want to say a last word about subcategories, and how similar the
stories in them usually are. Stories in the same subcategory may not
have a whole lot in common. They will have *one* thing in common -
either be about similar characters, timelines, or be written in similar
genres, depending on the main category they end up in. With larger main
categories, we volunteers get the luxury of setting up more specific
subcategories. You will notice that in Drama and Character Study (both
of which have appr. 75 pieces each), we set up subcategories about
similar characters. Or subgenres (focusing on family, or gapfillers,
etc.). But that's usually not possible, and quite often there aren't
enough stories to divide up the main category - so that the *only*
things those stories have in common, is that they involve the same genre
or race or time period, whatever the main category is built across.

This means that in smaller main categories the pieces competing have
less in common with each other. They are still similar in that their
author chose the same main category, but we just don't have the ability
to split things up like we would in a larger category. Even in the
larger categories, some authors are in a similar situation, because
stories that don't fit into any of the more specialized subcategories
will end up in the General subcategory.

It's a fine line to walk, because we could have more large categories by
offering less category choices. That would mean we would have more
luxury to set up more subcategories (where the stories might be more
similar), but it would also put stories that write a bit off the beaten
track at a distinct disadvantage. Still, it does mean that stories in
those smaller main categories will have less in common, and I see how
that would seem like a problem for some people. That's why we decided to
move this particular story. I'm just offering fair warning that we may
not always be able to do that in the future! Some subcategories are too
small to let us move things around much. But when we can move things
without causing problems, we do try to do that.

So: the new subcategories are...


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***

Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
Kinslayer (192): Russandol
Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv

***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***

One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
Cleansed (337): Larner
Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
The Fool (216): Marta
Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
Many Hands (276): Russandol
Living Jewels (182): shirebound

Marta

Msg# 10647

move request - Not So Like Luthien, After All Posted by telperion1 July 10, 2010 - 21:56:22 Topic ID# 10647
Hey guys,

After talking it over with the other categorizing volunteers, I've
decided to move

#440 Not So Like Luthien, After All by Maeglin

from Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion to Genres: Ficlet: Gondor. The
affected subcategories are:

***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***

For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
Spring Dance (301): Leianora
The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***

No Regrets (483): clotho123
Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
Crude Material (608): Ygrain

Marta

Msg# 10648

Re: move request - Earille's "The Imperishable Flame" Posted by melissa chandra July 11, 2010 - 4:42:22 Topic ID# 10634
Profuse apologies! This is my first time at the MEFA's... So sorry... It will not repeat again, in my part, in the future. Sorry... And if anyone else would move to another subcategory other than Shire and Eriador, I would understand perfectly if you'd move "The Imperishable Flame" back to that subcategory. It was after all my fault, and you have been so kind to move it now...
 
Thanks, and again I am sorry.
 
- Rey

--- On Thu, 7/8/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:


From: telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com>
Subject: [MEFAwards] move request - Earille's "The Imperishable Flame"
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, July 8, 2010, 6:02 PM


 



Hey guys,

I'm following up on Earille's request to have her story "The
Imperishable Flame".

On Imperishable Flame, Earille said:

"It is because the Eriador/Shire part is actually not that consequencial
to the story; it is just a sort of epilogue. So could you please put it
under another category? Related to the Silmarillion, hopefully? If not,
something more neutral would work, I guess... but definitely not this.
(It could be misleading to readers.)"

I looked at this, and see why we put it in "Eriador or Shire." Under
Story Settings Earille listed Dorthonion but also The Angle which is
part of Eriador. What this tells us (the categorizing volunteers) is
that the story could go equally okay in either place. Similarly, there
were events and characters from both the Silm and Lord of the Rings
chosen. The characters were "Characters for Readers" rather than
"Characters for Categorization," but as there were non "Chars for Cat."
selected, there was no way to know one was more important than the
other, short of reading the story. (Which unfortunately we didn't have
time to do!) So while I see while it's not really an appropriate
subcategory, we did follow the information provided by the author.

What I'm going to do is do a *conditional* move. I will move this story
into a Silmfic subcategory (Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion) - for
now. This move makes "Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire" as small as it
can be and still compete. If anyone else asks to move, if it's due to an
error on the part of the categorizers, I will have to move "Imperishable
Flame" back in with the Eriador or Shire stories. The only other option
would be to totally disband the subcategory, and I don't want to do that.

In the future, it's best to only list locations if you'd be happy for
your story to be categorized based on that. This applies to everyone,
and is not meant as a harsh criticism of this particular author, by the
way! It's an easy mistake to make, but we *do* depend on this
information, and it's not always possible to move stories around.

The affected subcategories are:

***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter

***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***

After the Fall (482): clotho123
*The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
Envy (317): Larner
Different Terms (170): Lyra
Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha

(Asterisk'd story is moved.)

Marta










[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10649

Re: move request - Earille's "The Imperishable Flame" Posted by telperion1 July 11, 2010 - 6:36:52 Topic ID# 10634
Hi Rey,

It's okay. I was mainly warning other people, for the future.
Unfortunately we can't always move stories, and I don't want people to
think we will always be able to - much safer for authors to understand
how we use the forms, and fill them out the best you can. (Which only
helps for next year, of course!) That is why I explained as I did. Not
to make you or anyone else feel guilty.

And as for "first times" - we have all been there. It takes a while to
learn how the MEFAs work, and I am glad to educate you, so you can make
the best selections possible in future years .

Marta

On 7/11/2010 5:42 AM, melissa chandra wrote:
>
>
> Profuse apologies! This is my first time at the MEFA's... So sorry... It
> will not repeat again, in my part, in the future. Sorry... And if anyone
> else would move to another subcategory other than Shire and Eriador, I
> would understand perfectly if you'd move "The Imperishable Flame" back
> to that subcategory. It was after all my fault, and you have been so
> kind to move it now...
>
> Thanks, and again I am sorry.
>
> - Rey
>

Msg# 10650

receive reviews by email Posted by telperion1 July 11, 2010 - 7:07:30 Topic ID# 10650
Hey guys,

Would you like to read MEFA reviews by email? Starting on 16-July,
reviews given the status "Final" will be displayed at the MEFA website.
However, many members like to read them by email, and Annmarwalk has
generously agreed to post reviews to both LJ and Yahoo.

--- We have set up a special Yahoo group for this purpose, mefa-reviews.
You may join by visiting

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mefa-reviews

and may opt to either receive the posts by email, or to read them at
that group page.

--- Reviews will also be posted to the mefas LJ community, under the tag
"review posting 2010." You can track that tag, so you receive an email
whenever Ann posts reviews. (Or just "friend" this journal, and receive
the reviews on your LJ friends page.)

********************************************

Our reviews are also available at the MEFA webpage, and some people
prefer to read them there. But there is a real advantage to getting the
reviews by email. It reminds you that the MEFAs are going on, and lets
you see when you or friends get a new review, without having to log into
a website. One thing veteran members will tell you is that it is
entirely too easy to wait too long to get involved. So if you want to
review, getting an email each day can be a much-needed nudge toward
doing that.

(Of course the webpage has its own advantages. You are free to read at
the website if you prefer, but for some people, getting reviews by email
is the way to go.)

Go ahead and join up, either at LJ or Yahoo, so you'll be all set up for
when reviews are made public on 16-July.

P.S. - If you have entered Final reviews, 15-July is the last day you
will be able to edit them. After that, they will be displayed to
everyone. If you need to edit your reviews, make sure you have given
them the status "Hidden," which will let you edit them through the end
of the awards.

Marta

Msg# 10651

Re: move request - Not So Like Luthien, After All Posted by Robert Hoy July 12, 2010 - 12:10:59 Topic ID# 10647
Thanks, Marta! And thanks to all the volunteers :)

Maeglin

On Sat, Jul 10, 2010 at 10:56 PM, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:

>
>
> Hey guys,
>
> After talking it over with the other categorizing volunteers, I've
> decided to move
>
> #440 Not So Like Luthien, After All by Maeglin
>
> from Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion to Genres: Ficlet: Gondor. The
> affected subcategories are:
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
> Marta
> _
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10652

final check ballot Posted by telperion1 July 13, 2010 - 8:11:43 Topic ID# 10652
Hey guys,

Here is the final check ballot. Please remember, tomorrow (14-July) is
the last day to request a move.

Also, if you requested that we move your story and I agreed please check
that it appears on the check ballot below. I want to make sure I updated
the website correctly. :-)


***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***

The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
A Son of Eärendil (266): DrummerWench
Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***

Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
Before the Fall (141): Elleth
To be Black (290): Encairion
The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
Choices (224): Linaewen
When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
The Son of Glóin (622): Nieriel Raina
Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
King's Ransom (673): splix


***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***

A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
Starship (50): shirebound
Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy


***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***

Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
The Light (303): Pearl Took
In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
Broken (515): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***

Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
Walls of White (27): Elleth
Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
The Return of the King (573): Jael
A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
Rebuffed (524): MithLuin


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***

To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Dunedain***

In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
The New Queens Bounty (136): Larner
Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
Bruises (368): Soledad


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***

The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
A Copper Band (251): Himring
Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***

A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
Sisterhood (535): Marta
Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***

Innocence (662): Dwimordene
Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
Good News (392): Paranoidangel
Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
Vigilance (647): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***

What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
First Time (547): Tanaqui
Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
Calm (80): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***

Along Came A Spider (273): Aeärwen
Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
Flying Free (343): Keiliss
Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213


***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***

Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
Celeritas
Unravelling (142): Elleth
RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza


***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***

To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
Encore (268): Lady Roisin
To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***

Prodigal (589): Aeärwen
The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***

Half-Brother (82): Ellie
The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
Little Bird (379): Soledad
Find Me (95): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***

Foundlings (99): Aeärwen
The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
Weapons Forged (175): Larner
What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***

Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
Choosing (498): rhyselle
The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***

The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
The Lady (670): alex_quine
The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
Promises (81): Lialathuveril
A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***

Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
Fruition (551): Tanaqui
Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***

The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
Kin No More (516): Ellie
The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
Explaining (54): Larner
Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***

Quest (198): Cathleen
A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
Duty (674): Lindelea
The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***

Ghost (588): Aeärwen
Sacrifices (118): Aeärwen
The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***

After the Fall (482): clotho123
The Imperishable Flame (582): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
Envy (317): Larner
Different Terms (170): Lyra
Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha


***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***

Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
Farewell (78): mirasaui
After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***

Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***

For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
Spring Dance (301): Leianora
The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***

No Regrets (483): clotho123
Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
Crude Material (608): Ygrain


***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***

Judgment (115): Aeärwen
Unrequited (163): elfscribe
Balrog (521): Phyncke
Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***

Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
Sand and Flame (250): Marta
Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon


***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***

Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
From the Ashes (185): Marta
Lessons (607): Nath
Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***

Spoils of War (116): Aeärwen
The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
Questioning (258): Larner
Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach


***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***

A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
Transformation (590): Larner
Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
Holiday (20): Nath
The Coimas War (275): Russandol
The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***

The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
A Gift (151): KyMahalei
And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***

For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
(304): Cathleen
Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***

A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
Fresh Meat (534): Marta
Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***

The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***

'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
Mightier than the Sword  Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
The Greeting Song (671): Súlriel


***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***

Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
Kinslayer (192): Russandol
Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv


***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***

Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
The Findaráto Diaries (41): Fiondil
The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
I Entulesse (204): MJ
Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella


***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***

A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
Yew (207): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***

A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
Olórë Malë (587): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
Into the Woods (75): Wormwood


***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***

'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
confusing (280): Darth Fingon
Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
Darth Fingon
Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
Dreamflower
Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest


***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***

A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella


***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***

Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
The Drums (430): Malicean
Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***

Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
Contrapposto (531): Marta


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***

How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
Descent (625): Lady Roisin
Forty Days (295): Marta
Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick


***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***

Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
A New Light (400): Marigold


***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***

Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
The Abduction of Éomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
First Glance (148): Marta
The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love & (245): Súlriel
The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5


***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***

Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
When Winter Comes (138): Marta
A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad


***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***

Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
We Speak Through Music (419): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Strange Land (519): Elfique
Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
Uldor (284): Himring
A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
The Courier (32): Jael
The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***

Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***

The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***

Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
In The House of Elrond (123): Aeärwen
Crystal Green (468): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
Another Road (314): KyMahalei
Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1


***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***

Triptych (604): Adaneth
An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
Giants' Game (429): Larner
Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***

In Durin's Day (373): Marta
A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
Questing (117): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***

In His Eyes (92): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
Anna Wing
Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
Tales from Vairë's Loom: The Exilic Noldos Guide to Coping with
Post-Helcaraxë Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***

Determined (426): Aeärwen
Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
More Than Memory (241): Marta
Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***

Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh


***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***

Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
Brightness (427): Faenel
Tales from Vairë's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth


***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***

Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
(114): Dreamflower
One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***

Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
Marigolds Yule (306): GamgeeFest
Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***

When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
Dearest Dora (445): Larner
The Research Project (602): Larner
I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***

Memorial Day (358): Antane
Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took


***SubCategory Races: Men: General***

Tales from Vairë's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
Death and Life (511): Golden
Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
Penance (278): SurgicalSteel


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Drabbles***

Mother Country (329): Altariel
Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
Hospitality (79): Wormwood


***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***

The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter


***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***

One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
Cleansed (337): Larner
Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
The Fool (216): Marta
Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
Many Hands (276): Russandol
Living Jewels (182): shirebound


***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***

Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
Treed (618): The Lauderdale


***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***

In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
Lúthien's Tale (458): clotho123
Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
Tutelage (230): Marta
Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***

Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
The Vessel (617): Elleth
This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong


***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***

The Journal of Alatáriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***

Comfort (119): Aeärwen
In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeärwen
Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
The Last Hero (263): Jael
Grace (558): Lanyon
For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance


***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***

Dance (672): alex_quine
A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
Conquering the Helcaraxë (16): Raksha the Demon
Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***

Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
Hearts of Home (1): Súlriel
Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***

Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui


***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***

Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
Passing Grace (313): Virtuella


***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***

Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger


***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***

A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
To See the Light (89): Mirach
The Awakening (203): MJ
In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***

Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
Sacrifices (83): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf


***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***

Eradication (93): Breemon
The Last Resort (568): Eärillë (AiedailWing)
Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
Resistance (554): Tanaqui


***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***

Anadûnai (233): Darth Fingon
Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta


***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***

Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
Coda (376): Marta
Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui

Marta

Msg# 10653

Possible move request. Posted by nierielraina July 13, 2010 - 11:25:41 Topic ID# 10653
I'm sorry I have not had a chance to speak up sooner. RL is a bit chaotic ATM.

I am satisfied with all my story placements except one. I am really not happy with the placement of my story The Last Gift. The story, while including many characters from Rivendell, is NOT set there entirely, in fact, it's set in Gondor right before Aragorn's wedding as he thinks back on the gifts Elrond has given him over the years. This is why I purposely DID NOT choose a location for this story and was advised by my liaison also not to put one in, because I did NOT want it classified by location as that doesn't really work for this story.

As is stands, only one story in this category also includes Aragorn and it seems to be about Aragorn with the Dúnedain. The others are about Hobbits. My story is really out of place there. Can you please move it to a more appropriate category?

Thank you,

Nieriel Raina


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter

Msg# 10654

Re: final check ballot Posted by Anna S. July 13, 2010 - 13:00:46 Topic ID# 10652
Hello,



I had previously made a request to move my story "Uninvited" to the subcategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire, instead of the Silmarillion once, since the action takes place on the borders of Rivendell. I have received no reply, so I'm writing again with the same request - if you sent an email and I missed it, I apologize for the inconvenience. But if there are other reasons to keep my story at its current place, thanks in advance for telling me.



Windsurfbabe





> To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
> From: marta.fandom@gmail.com
> Date: Tue, 13 Jul 2010 09:11:39 -0400
> Subject: [MEFAwards] final check ballot
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the final check ballot. Please remember, tomorrow (14-July) is
> the last day to request a move.
>
> Also, if you requested that we move your story and I agreed please check
> that it appears on the check ballot below. I want to make sure I updated
> the website correctly. :-)
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Adventure: General***
>
> The Ranger and the Hobbit (42): Cairistiona
> A Son of Eýrendil (266): DrummerWench
> Wicked Thieving Elf! (525): Ellie
> Blackbow (206): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Blue Boar (493): Minniemoggie
> Little Tolkien (232): Mortizya
> Flame of the Desert (158): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Alternate Universe: General***
>
> Five Things That Never Happened To Bilbo Baggins (58): Dreamflower
> Before the Fall (141): Elleth
> To be Black (290): Encairion
> The Tinker's Tale (495): Levade
> Choices (224): Linaewen
> When I Said I Would Die A Bachelor (471): Nancy Brooke
> The Son of Glýin (622): Nieriel Raina
> Gilraen the Living Dead (513): Sivan Shemesh
> The Joys of a Beard (370): Soledad
> King's Ransom (673): splix
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Alternate Universe: Incomplete***
>
> A Bit of Rope (197): Aiwendiel
> You Live Your Life in the Shadow of the Mountain (177): Darth Fingon
> Mountain Guards (391): Malicean
> Starship (50): shirebound
> Fear, Elrond, Fear! (512): Sivan Shemesh
> Sylvanlight, Book I (312): slflew
> Sons of Thunder (387): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Character Study: General***
>
> Lessons Learned (654): Anna Wing
> In the Cards (470): Dwimordene
> To the Crossroads (592): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Turn Down an Empty Glass (344): Keiliss
> Warm Bread (415): KyMahalei
> The Light (303): Pearl Took
> In the deep places of the world (396): Tanaqui
> Broken (515): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Angst***
>
> Lonely Watches (46): Canafinwe
> No One Rembers (130): Canafinwe
> Walls of White (27): Elleth
> Seeds in Dark Earth (643): Ilthit
> The Return of the King (573): Jael
> A King in Winter (637): Jedi Sapphire
> Rebuffed (524): MithLuin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Drabble Series***
>
> To look out upon life (439): Cairistiona
> Warping Arda: Spectrum (285): Clodia
> A Decent and Respectable Hobbit (460): Dreamflower
> Midsummer's Eve (627): Dwimordene
> Misericordia (173): Dwimordene
> Harvest Dreams (500): Linda Hoyland
> Seasons of Gladness (60): Raksha the Demon
> Arrival in Avallone (561): rhyselle
> Not In Our Stars (397): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Dunedain***
>
> In Which Comes Sorrow Long Expected (655): Anna Wing
> Beneath the Surface (19): Canafinwe
> Pale faced Tark (452): Canafinwe
> The New Queenýs Bounty (136): Larner
> Darkest Before the Dawn (555): Leianora
> The Gift of Foresight (342): Linda Hoyland
> Bruises (368): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Family***
>
> The Apology of Elrond (453): Canafinwe
> Old Horses (218): Crantz/Snacky CoAuthors
> A Copper Band (251): Himring
> Self-Defense (26): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Reflections (174): Perkyandproud
> Cold Comfort (369): Soledad
> The Greatest Warrior (537): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gapfiller***
>
> A Meal Fit for a King (234): Aranel Took
> Overheard in the Dark (57): Dreamflower
> Moments (414): Gandalf 3213
> Sisterhood (535): Marta
> Tie Me to This Our Ancient Earth (259): Mercurie
> Fourteen Days (510): Rabidsamfan
> Elusive Scents in Wartime (404): Thevina Finduilas
> Darkness Creeping (459): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: General Drabbles***
>
> Innocence (662): Dwimordene
> Following the Star (584): Linda Hoyland
> The Ranger's Respite (487): Linda Hoyland
> Good News (392): Paranoidangel
> Fired Up (553): Tanaqui
> Vigilance (647): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Gondor Drabbles***
>
> What The Lightning Said: 20th June 3018, Minas Tirith (435): Azalais
> The Long and Winding Road (28): Linda Hoyland
> Tree of Life and Death (255): Linda Hoyland
> A Steward's Dreams (229): Marta
> First Time (547): Tanaqui
> Stalk like a Snow-troll (646): Tanaqui
> Calm (80): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: The Silmarillion***
>
> Along Came A Spider (273): Aeýrwen
> Vignettes of Beleriand - The Giant Vampire Bat Problem (657): Anna Wing
> Goldilocks and the Three Balrogs (76): Clodia
> The Death of a Star (244): Encairion
> Flying Free (343): Keiliss
> Even Roses Have Thorns (274): Lady Roisin
> Into This Wild Abyss (61): pandemonium_213
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Character Study: Vignettes***
>
> Seasons of Rivendell (650): Anna Wing
> Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 (45):
> Celeritas
> Unravelling (142): Elleth
> RECONCILIATION: Ascent (556): Fiondil
> Five Kisses for Rosie Cotton (641): Ilthit
> The Passing of Fire (461): Primsong
> Knife's Edge (454): Rumpleteasza
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Crossover: General***
>
> To Represent the Wizzards (63): aotearoan
> Return of The Key. (422): curiouswombat
> Tempered Rain (311): Ilada'Jefiv
> Encore (268): Lady Roisin
> To Face the Wolf (465): Maglor's finch
> A Singular Honour (238): Shemyaza1
> The Devil Is In The Detail (609): Tanaqui
> Dwarf Fashions (411): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Drama: General***
>
> Prodigal (589): Aeýrwen
> The Song of a Friend (676): KyMahalei
> At the Edge of the World (146): Lady Roisin
> Of Cabbages and Kings (122): Lamiel
> When the Stars do not Shine (91): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea (663): Mithadan
> Caught Between (658): Mysterious Jedi
> Hostage (277): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire***
>
> A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
> The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
> Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
> Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
> The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
> All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Family or Children***
>
> Half-Brother (82): Ellie
> The Last Gift (10): Ellynn
> King of Shadowed Halls (121): Jael
> Silver Bells (153): Nieriel Raina
> Little Bird (379): Soledad
> Find Me (95): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gapfiller***
>
> Foundlings (99): Aeýrwen
> The Most Timid Hobbit (321): Antane
> Gentlemen's Agreement (261): khazar_khum
> Weapons Forged (175): Larner
> What Becomes of Snow? (221): RadcliffePotter
> Who Shall Be the Bearer? (220): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: General Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Before the Black Gate, Second Age 3434 (479): Azalais
> Enlightenment (464): Mercurie
> BONES FOUND ON POSH ESTATE (437): MrKinch
> Choosing (498): rhyselle
> The Insolence of the Corsairs (599): Tanaqui
> The Last (un)Homely House (549): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> The Fourth of July (214): agape4gondor
> The Lady (670): alex_quine
> The Moon Has Waned (503): Erfan Starled
> Promises (81): Lialathuveril
> A Sting in the Tale (335): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts in Stone (8): Raksha the Demon
> Ice Sculptures (59): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Gondor or Rohan Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Imminent Defeat (55): Nieriel Raina
> Peace Denied (39): Nieriel Raina
> A Question of Character (648): Tanaqui
> Fruition (551): Tanaqui
> Quarantine (552): Tanaqui
> In the Uncertain Hour Before Morning (390): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Hurt/Comfort***
>
> The Riddle of Strider (208): Cairistiona
> Kin No More (516): Ellie
> The House of Uial and the Tale of The Last son (195): Elvenson
> A Forgotten Song (341): KyMahalei
> Explaining (54): Larner
> Returning to Cirith Thoronath (90): Mirach
> Tales from Tol Eressea: Conversations in Avallone (664): Mithadan
> Sing and Be Glad, All Ye Children of the West (222): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Incomplete***
>
> Quest (198): Cathleen
> A Beleriand Treasury of Childish Tales (365): Clodia
> To Everything ... Time (202): Estelyn Telcontar
> The Cusp of Victory (382): Kara's Aunty
> Oh, Mercy (560): Lanyon
> Duty (674): Lindelea
> The Tempered Steel (616): Lyra
> Tablut (127): NeumeIndil
> And The Woods Responded (364): Windsurfbabe
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Later Age Elves***
>
> Ghost (588): Aeýrwen
> Sacrifices (118): Aeýrwen
> The Valley is Jolly (44): Canafinwe
> The Light Returned (52): Ellynn
> Never Look Back (155): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Gil-Estel (128): Mirach
> Reach for the Stars (38): Raksha the Demon
> Starlit Shadows (385): StarSpray
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Quenta Silmarillion***
>
> After the Fall (482): clotho123
> The Imperishable Flame (582): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> Blessed by Fortune (578): Ellie
> A Part in Great Deeds (417): Hallbera
> A Long Time Falling (249): Himring
> Envy (317): Larner
> Different Terms (170): Lyra
> Within a Dark Wood (386): Marchwriter
> The World That Ends With You (179): Minviendha
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Ficlet: General***
>
> Each Familiar Bough (262): aranelgoldenflower
> Fifteen Hot Haradrim (591): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Not All Who Wander Are Lost (240): Kaylee Arafinwiel
> A Deck of Heroes (595): Larner
> Farewell (78): mirasaui
> After the Hour of Doom (345): Raksha the Demon
> The Tower (96): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire***
>
> Heirs of Gondor (502): Ainu Laire
> In the Corner (267): DrummerWench
> Paradise Lost (25): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The First One (292): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Birthday Guest (73): Primsong
> Meeting of Quiet Minds (70): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: Gondor***
>
> For This Relief Much Thanks (576): Azalais
> The Archivist (6): foxrafer (csevans8)
> Design Flaw (169): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Spring Dance (301): Leianora
> The Silver Tree (583): Linda Hoyland
> Not so like Luthien, After All (440): Maeglin
> In the King's Shadow (287): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Ficlet: The Silmarillion***
>
> No Regrets (483): clotho123
> Roads Not Taken (450): clotho123
> Till my Last Breath (108): Ellynn
> The Morning Fog (638): Phyncke
> The Eye of the Beholder (581): Raksha the Demon
> Uninvited (473): Windsurfbabe
> Crude Material (608): Ygrain
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: General***
>
> Judgment (115): Aeýrwen
> Unrequited (163): elfscribe
> Balrog (521): Phyncke
> Pilgrimage (517): Raksha the Demon
> Riding the Fire (62): Raksha the Demon
> A Question of Dialect (603): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Chilren or Family***
>
> Kinsmen (328): Isabeau of Greenlea
> The Hope of Spring (215): Linda Hoyland
> A Rose By Any Other Name (533): Marta
> Sand and Flame (250): Marta
> Expectations (360): Raksha the Demon
> Fosterage (659): Raksha the Demon
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Fixed-Length Ficlet: Gondor or Rohan***
>
> Harbinger (580): Linda Hoyland
> From the Ashes (185): Marta
> Lessons (607): Nath
> Filling the Breach (499): Raksha the Demon
> Ranger's Dawn (333): Raksha the Demon
> Some Like It Hot - But Maybe Not Quite That Hot (34): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Horror: General***
>
> Spoils of War (116): Aeýrwen
> The Tower at Dol Amroth (191): agape4gondor
> Hastaina (144): Dawn Felagund
> Tales from Vairý's Loom: Beyond The Galvorn Door (159): Fiondil
> Under the Forest Eaves (120): Jael
> Questioning (258): Larner
> Crossroads of Light and Shadow (104): Mirach
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Humor: General***
>
> A Lesson Learned (331): agape4gondor
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Caranthir in Lorien (651): Anna Wing
> More Than Meets The Eye (425): Ignoble Bard
> Transformation (590): Larner
> Pillow Talk (172): Lyra
> In Vino Veritas (612): Marta
> Holiday (20): Nath
> The Coimas War (275): Russandol
> The Ladies' Guide To Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors (399): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Comedy/Drama***
>
> The Noldo is IN (433): Beruthiel's Cat
> Lover's Leap (526): Ellie
> O Misfortune! (260): Hallbera
> A Gift (151): KyMahalei
> And Just Whose Wedding Is This? (297): Larner
> Some Things Never Change (239): Nieriel Raina
> This Side of Paradise (134): Nieriel Raina
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Eriador or Shire***
>
> For Better, or For Worse (196): Cathleen
> Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle, the Goat Jumped Over the Moon
> (304): Cathleen
> Undue Patience (667): Celeritas
> The Wizard and the Ranger (380): Gandalfs apprentice
> The Christmas Closet (579): Geale
> A Pretense at Civility (666): Larner
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Gondor***
>
> A Cold Night in June (112): agape4gondor
> A Day In The Life Of The Royal Gondorian Aerial Corps (652): Anna Wing
> Refuge (490): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Unripened Fruit (520): Gwynnyd
> Eomer goes Fishing (107): Lady Bluejay
> Fresh Meat (534): Marta
> Brink of the Sea (65): Nieriel Raina
> Wedding Traditions (412): Vilwarin
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Incomplete***
>
> The Silmarillion Gospel (315): Araloth the Random
> Bringing Trouble to Barad-dur (522): Chisscientist
> Tales of Older Days (381): Clodia
> Hobbit Stew (441): Kara's Aunty
> Not Quite A Maia (361): Kara's Aunty
> Oh No! Another Lord of the Rings Parody (455): Kitt Otter
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> 'A' is for 'Apple'. (457): curiouswombat
> The Love of Learning (601): Jay of Lasgalen
> Mightier than the Sword ý Indigo (49): Linda Hoyland
> Barreling Out of Mirkwood (621): Nieriel Raina
> Master of Imladris (56): Nieriel Raina
> The Greeting Song (671): Sýlriel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Humor: Parody or Black Humor***
>
> Tears on the Battlefield (310): Alassante
> Fair Wanderer, Thou Makest Me Sick (271): Araloth the Random
> The Fanfiction Testament (272): Araloth the Random
> By The Book (423): Ignoble Bard
> Fighting Enemies (33): Larner
> Monty Python's 'Fellowship of the Ring' (64): Morthoron
> Legolas the Bane of My Existence (288): rosethorn59
> Kinslayer (192): Russandol
> Orcs at School (9): Virtuella
> Lord of the Glittering Harem (293): viv
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Longer Works: General***
>
> Ten Thousand Years Will Not Suffice (631): agape4gondor
> Typically Atypical Book I (355): Elaura
> Interrupted Journeys: Journeys Out of Grief (247): elliska
> The Findarýto Diaries (41): Fiondil
> The Sword of Elendil (443): Gandalfs apprentice
> Swan Song (147): Ithilwen
> The Queen's Orc (626): jodancingtree
> I Entulesse (204): MJ
> Truth Be Told (40): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Longer Works: Incomplete***
>
> A Long and Weary Way (131): Canafinwe
> Tainted Light (243): Eldalie
> The Price of Duty (66): Encairion
> The Sell-Sword and the Prince (98): Lady Bluejay
> Or Perchance, When the Last Little Star (600): Larner
> The Embalmer's Apprentice (156): Lyra
> Yew (207): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Mystery: General***
>
> A Light in May (446): Antigone Q
> Olýrý Malý (587): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> A Slaying in Scarlet (405): Gloromeien
> A Disgrace to Gondor (47): Linda Hoyland
> Looking For Boromir (13): Valente
> Into the Woods (75): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Non-Fiction: General***
>
> 'Sindarin' is a Quenya Word: how the clan names make Elvish more
> confusing (280): Darth Fingon
> Elvish Fanons and Canon Contradictions (Or, how to get those canatics
> off your case for stuff you were right about in the first place) (279):
> Darth Fingon
> Are you on the outside looking in, or the inside looking out? (265):
> Dreamflower
> Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions (217): Dreamflower
> Tolkien in Love (478): Eldalie
> Ring-bearers, Aging, and Life in Aman (176): GamgeeFest
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Non-Fiction: Character Essays***
>
> A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor (354): Antane
> Frodo and Grace (347): Baillie from Bree
> Take Pity upon Him: Did Maedhros Really Threaten to Kill Elrond and
> Elros at the Third Kinslaying? (570): Dawn Felagund
> An Essay on Frodo Baggins (349): Margaret Watkins
> Celebrimbor (190): Oshun
> Aragorn - a feminist's nightmare? (489): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Poetry: General***
>
> Obsession (338): Calenlass Greenleaf
> The OTHER Lays of Beleriand (624): Chisscientist
> Not So Easily Mended (352): jan-u-wine
> The Drums (430): Malicean
> Gilraen's Lullaby (518): Mirach
> The Pathway of Dreams II (442): Nerdanel
> A Mighty Bridge Invisible (614): Noliel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Character Study***
>
> Addiction (340): Calenlass Greenleaf
> Corruption (339): Calenlass Greenleaf
> What do you fear milady? (543): elfenears
> Harthad (353): jan-u-wine
> Unbroken (384): jan-u-wine
> A Friend in Need (327): Kara's Aunty
> Contrapposto (531): Marta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Drama***
>
> How I Wish (109): Dawn Felagund
> And Come What Sorrow Can (496): jan-u-wine
> Anniversary (March 13, 1420 S.R.) (497): jan-u-wine
> Descent (625): Lady Roisin
> Forty Days (295): Marta
> Tears for the Fallen (316): pandemonium_213
> End of Days (71): Shipwright's Trick
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Poetry: Hobbits***
>
> Frodo of the Shire (476): Baillie from Bree
> Minas Morgul (475): Baillie from Bree
> Across So Wide a Sea (351): jan-u-wine
> And I Don't Mean To (350): jan-u-wine
> Shall I Sing? (336): Larner
> Sunlight (348): Margaret Watkins
> A New Light (400): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory Genres: Romance: General***
>
> Through a Glass, Darkly (254): Beruthiel's Cat
> Scattered Leaves (256): Eldalie
> Looking at the Stars and Counting the Hours (283): Himring
> Chasing Waterfalls (424): Ignoble Bard
> Perfect Happiness (613): Jedi Sapphire
> The Abduction of ýomer, King of Rohan (3): Lialathuveril
> First Glance (148): Marta
> The Prince and the Shepherdess (154): Nieriel Raina
> A Little Closer to the Edge, My Love ý (245): Sýlriel
> The Fabled Courtship of Elanor the Fair (318): the_arc5
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Genres: Romance: Dunedain***
>
> Love Began Here (231): Adonnen Estenniel
> Pure Morning (286): curiouswombat
> Gilraen, the Fair (106): Gwynnyd
> A Seal upon thine Heart (193): Linda Hoyland
> When Winter Comes (138): Marta
> A Blossom of Marble (325): NeumeIndil
> Shieldbrothers (371): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Cross-Cultural: General***
>
> Beneath Golden Leaves (488): Avon
> Hyarmendil (665): Dwimordene
> We Speak Through Music (419): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> Strange Land (519): Elfique
> Once Upon a Blizzard (630): Fiondil
> Uldor (284): Himring
> A Dangerous Hunger (466): Ignoble Bard
> The Courier (32): Jael
> The Battle of the Kitchen (102): Raksha the Demon
> Orcs in Hobbiton (447): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Friendship***
>
> Surprises of Yule (606): Ainu Laire
> Size Isn't Everything (571): Bodkin
> The Longest Night (145): Dawn Felagund
> Friends in Need (308): Dreamflower
> Witness to a Crime (186): Dreamflower
> Dol Amroth Dip-tych (189): Dwimordene
> Dance in the Moonlight (538): KyMahalei
> Only the Owl Saw it All (494): Levade
> The Trees Were Burning (36): Nieriel Raina
> Lord of Gifts (84): shirebound
> Felagund and the Noegyth Nibin (378): Soledad
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Gapfiller***
>
> The Road to Edoras (326): Dreamflower
> To Lead His People (636): Dreamflower
> Of Wine and Song (527): Ellie
> Tales from Vairý's Loom: Sun-in-Eclipse (562): Fiondil
> A Choice of Life or Death (585): Larner
> Stranger at the Gates (24): Linda Hoyland
> At the Last It Biteth (323): Mercurie
> The Man Who Grew Tomatoes (125): pandemonium_213
> Praiseworthy (536): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Incomplete***
>
> Hand to Hand (167): Adaneth
> In The House of Elrond (123): Aeýrwen
> Crystal Green (468): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> 'Til Death Do Us Part (164): Haleth
> Murder in the White City (611): Jedi Sapphire
> Another Road (314): KyMahalei
> Hope of a Star (129): Mirach
> Dark Power Arising (235): Shemyaza1
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Cross-Cultural: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Triptych (604): Adaneth
> An Autumn Journey (212): Jay of Lasgalen
> Giants' Game (429): Larner
> Two Copper Pennies (656): Mysterious Jedi
> Unbearable Parting (48): Nieriel Raina
> Translations from the Elvish (645): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Dwarves: General***
>
> In Durin's Day (373): Marta
> A Dwarven Yuletide (367): Soledad
> In the Shelter of Destroyed Dreams (402): Thevina Finduilas
> Unanswerable Questions (403): Thevina Finduilas
> Mazarbul (72): Thundera Tiger
> Questing (117): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Elves: General***
>
> In His Eyes (92): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Everyday Life In Tol Eressea (653):
> Anna Wing
> Blood and Fire (187): Clodia
> Bee-Elves (178): Darth Fingon
> Tales from Vairý's Loom: The Exilic Noldoýs Guide to Coping with
> Post-Helcaraxý Stress Syndrome (or PHSS) (566): Fiondil
> A Bit of a Bore (248): Himring
> Avar and Away (227): Ignoble Bard
> Pity Us Not (563): j_dav (JDE)
> The Day of the Dragon (184): Keiliss
> The Dance of Flute and Harp (253): Lintalome (Amaranth)
> Elves Don't Celebrate Yule (87): rhyselle
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Drabbles***
>
> Determined (426): Aeýrwen
> Always Something There to Remind Me (480): curiouswombat
> First Snowfall (5): curiouswombat
> Ash to Ash (171): Dawn Felagund
> More Than Memory (241): Marta
> Seeking Perfection (545): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Mirkwood Elves***
>
> Through The Mirror of Fire (94): Esteliel
> A Tale from the Wilderland (675): KyMahalei
> Alone at Yule (504): laichiril
> Forest Assault (620): Nieriel Raina
> The Little Prince (434): ningloreth
> The End? (619): Sivan Shemesh
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Elves: Noldorin Elves***
>
> Half-brother in Blood, Full Brother in Heart (133): Alassante
> Vignettes of the Blessed Realm - Celebrimbor in Mandos (649): Anna Wing
> Brightness (427): Faenel
> Tales from Vairý's Loom: Tenn' Ambar-Metta (201): Fiondil
> Eminently Unsuitable (252): Himring
> By the Grey Light of Dawn (406): Nieriel Raina
> No Justice to Yourself (281): Oshun
> Resist Not Evil (188): Perelleth
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Hobbits: General***
>
> Go Not to Aunt Dora for Advice, for She Will Give It at Great Length
> (114): Dreamflower
> One Fine Autumn Day (635): Dreamflower
> Roast Mutton (296): Gandalfs apprentice
> A Pirate's Life (640): Ilthit
> Before Luck Runs Out (401): Marigold
> Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane (322): Pearl Took
> A Very Warm Yule (307): pippinfan88
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Family***
>
> Sometimes a Cake is Just a Cake (410): Cathleen
> To Absent Friends (569): Celeritas
> A Not-So-Simple Misunderstanding (31):
> Celeritas/Dreamflower/Larner/Pearl Took CoAuthors
> September Days Across the Brandywine (302): Dreamflower
> Marigoldýs Yule (306): GamgeeFest
> Worthy of the Name (298): Marigold
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> When the Storms of Life are Raging (Stand By Me) (505): Dreamflower
> Dearest Dora (445): Larner
> The Research Project (602): Larner
> I will take the Ring, though I do not know the way (264): Lindelea
> For All Things, A Time (299): Marta
> Learning His Letters (644): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Hobbits: Post-Quest***
>
> Memorial Day (358): Antane
> Sharing Sam (668): Celeritas
> Sunlight on Ash (484): Ilthit
> The One Left Out of the Conspiracy (320): Larner
> Behind Blue Eyes (610): Marta
> Concerning the Matter of Tom Took (181): Pearl Took
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Men: General***
>
> Tales from Vairý's Loom: To Stand Fast Against the Night (632): Fiondil
> Death and Life (511): Golden
> Doggerel (168): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Firebug (593): Isabeau of Greenlea
> Libation (332): Raksha the Demon
> Penance (278): SurgicalSteel
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Drabbles***
>
> Mother Country (329): Altariel
> Threshing Songs (481): curiouswombat
> Evergreen (451): Linda Hoyland
> A price worth paying (550): Tanaqui
> Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies. (544): Tanaqui
> Dreams of Trees (389): Wormwood
> Hospitality (79): Wormwood
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Races: Men: Featuring Aragorn***
>
> The Bitter and the Sweet (110): Cairistiona
> Contrapunto (291): Gandalfs apprentice
> Love Unrequited (100): Inzilbeth
> The Fifteenth Fosterling (14): Inzilbeth
> Freedom Is Never Free (132): Nieriel Raina
> Rallying Before the Darkness (219): RadcliffePotter
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Other Beings: General***
>
> One Breath of Air (257): Celeritas
> Cleansed (337): Larner
> Lost and Found (225): Linaewen
> The Fool (216): Marta
> Shades of Black and Grey (97): Minviendha
> A Dragon Tale (51): Pearl Took
> Looking For Dragons (237): Raksha the Demon
> Many Hands (276): Russandol
> Living Jewels (182): shirebound
>
>
> ***SubCategory Races: Villains: General***
>
> Unrest: What Evil Fears (477): Eonwe
> I Shall Not Call the Sunbeam Bright (228): j_dav (JDE)
> The Wrath of Light (362): Kara's Aunty
> How the East Was Won (124): pandemonium_213
> Sacrifice (194): SurgicalSteel
> Treed (618): The Lauderdale
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: First Age and Prior: General***
>
> In Bitterness and Loss (572): Bodkin
> Lýthien's Tale (458): clotho123
> Encounter in the Forest (472): Ellynn
> Lover of Fire (269): Encairion
> The Choices of the Peredhil (408): Inzilbeth
> The Havens of Sirion (152): Inzilbeth
> Necessary Sacrifices (431): Ithilwen
> Tutelage (230): Marta
> Follow Thy Fair Sun, Unhappy Shadow (393): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Dawn & Dusk (160): Clodia
> Once Upon a Twilit Time (444): Clodia
> Seasons (300): Dawn Felagund
> Five Things That Never Happened to Maglor Feanorion (140): Elleth
> The Vessel (617): Elleth
> This Shining Ember Burns my Hand (113): Primsong
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: First Age and Prior: Noldorin Elves***
>
> The Journal of Alatýriel, Missionary (77): Clodia
> A Time to Heal (448): clotho123
> The Military Relevance of Sewage (628): Himring
> Geography Lessons (282): Ithilwen
> Morning Yearning (289): Liadan
> Unrepentant Lovers (68): Oshun
> Unravelling the Past (30): rhyselle
> A Dangerous Guide (394): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Modern Times: General***
>
> Comfort (119): Aeýrwen
> In the Hidden Valley (101): Aeýrwen
> Elf Academy (29): Fiondil
> The Last Hero (263): Jael
> Grace (558): Lanyon
> For Every Evil (456): Mirrordance
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: General***
>
> Dance (672): alex_quine
> A Time to Reap (506): Cathleen
> The Jewel of the Shire (346): Kara's Aunty
> Threnody for the Dispossessed (67): Kenaz
> Lasciate Ogne Speranza? (501): Maglor's finch
> Conquering the Helcaraxý (16): Raksha the Demon
> Fifteen Years (436): Red Lasbelin
> Sword and Bow (634): StarLight9
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Drabbles***
>
> Scion (4): Branwyn (Lady Branwyn)
> Reaping the Reward (18): curiouswombat
> Only Sleeping (597): Linda Hoyland
> Time's Out of Joint (334): Linda Hoyland
> Hearts of Home (1): Sýlriel
> Home Comforts (546): Tanaqui
> In his father's footsteps (548): Tanaqui
> Jurisdiction (542): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Gondor***
>
> Winters of Yesterday (407): Golden
> Passover and Pilgrimage (53): Larner
> The Ring- Day Fete (37): Larner
> Of Mice and Men... and Elves... and Dwarves (139): Marethiel
> Women Of Heart And Mind (469): Nancy Brooke
> Good Intentions (395): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Post-Ring War and Beyond: Vignettes***
>
> Reckoning (623): Dwimordene
> Pride and Prejudice (398): Marta
> Secrets We Dare Not Tell (374): Marta
> Remembrance in Leather (372): Raederle
> Small Victories (594): Raksha the Demon
> Passing Grace (313): Virtuella
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Pre-Ring War: General***
>
> Memory of Faery (86): Ellie
> Small Tokens (669): Galadriel
> Midwinter Forfeit (574): Gwynnyd
> The Call of Duty: Legolas at Erebor (246): Jael
> A Mother's Hope (541): Linda Hoyland
> A Last Remaining Hope (661): Rai
> A Brotherly Gift (377): Soledad
> Escaping By The Dozen (319): Thundera Tiger
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Ring War: General***
>
> A Yule to Remember (575): Cathleen
> Beyond the Pale (35): Dwimordene
> Close Enough to Touch (242): ErinRua
> No Reason To Celebrate (88): Linaewen
> The Old That Is Strong (486): Linda Hoyland
> To See the Light (89): Mirach
> The Awakening (203): MJ
> In Darkness, Light (183): Nath
> Deeper than Breathing (388): ziggy
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Gapfiller***
>
> Berilac's Errand (23): Dreamflower
> Sacrifices (83): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> On The Eve Of Battle (213): Jay of Lasgalen
> On the Turning Away (294): NeumeIndil
> The Counsels of Men (103): Thundera Tiger
> The World Below the Mists (43): Thundera Tiger
> Enduring Moria (639): White Wolf
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Ring War: Mixed Drabbles***
>
> Eradication (93): Breemon
> The Last Resort (568): Eýrillý (AiedailWing)
> Rainbow Drabbles (105): Jay of Lasgalen
> Under a Silent Sky (530): Marta
> Light of the Evenstar (12): Nieriel Raina
> Resistance (554): Tanaqui
>
>
> ***SubCategory Times: Second and Early Third Age: General***
>
> Anadýnai (233): Darth Fingon
> Burden to Bear (85): Ellie
> How Fleeting These Moments (135): Lady Roisin
> Final Voyage (523): MithLuin
> All alone in the Night (366): Soledad
> Mallorn Torment (205): Tehta
>
>
> ***SubCategory: Times: Second and Early Third Age: Fall of Numenor***
>
> Touch of a Vanished Hand (150): elfscribe
> Every Wish (166): Independence1776 (Crystal113)
> Lambe, Ando, Lambe (642): Lady Roisin
> Coda (376): Marta
> Woolgathering (577): pandemonium_213
> All the Days of Their Grace (7): Tanaqui
>
> Marta
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>

_________________________________________________________________
Excluý: Týlýchargez la nouvelle version de Messenger !
http://clk.atdmt.com/FRM/go/244627952/direct/01/

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10655

Re: final check ballot Posted by telperion1 July 14, 2010 - 11:46:32 Topic ID# 10652
On 7/13/2010 1:31 PM, Anna S. wrote:
>
> Hello,
>
>
>
> I had previously made a request to move my story "Uninvited" to the subcategory: Genres: Ficlet: Eriador or Shire, instead of the Silmarillion once, since the action takes place on the borders of Rivendell. I have received no reply, so I'm writing again with the same request - if you sent an email and I missed it, I apologize for the inconvenience. But if there are other reasons to keep my story at its current place, thanks in advance for telling me.
>
>
>
> Windsurfbabe
>
>

Hi Windsurfbabe,

I remember your request, and thought I had moved it as you suggested -
but it obviously *wasn't* moved, and I can't find where I replied back
to you. You may remember that I had internet connection issues earlier
this week, and said I had a lot of emails to sort through. What I think
happened is, in that rush I overlooked your email. Very sorry about that.

On 16-July the categories will show up on our web page. Just

--- log in to www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/
--- click on "Stories" at the top of the page, and
--- find your story, e.g. by searching for "uninvited"

Where the website now shows your first, second, and third choice
categories, it will then show the subcategory you're actually in. It
wouldn't be a bad idea to double-check, that your story is in the
"Eriador or Shire" subcategory. If it isn't, email me at
mefasupportATgmailDOTcom, and I'll get things straightened out for me.
But I don't expect any problems; I just want you to double-check to be
sure. :-)

Marta

Msg# 10656

Re: Possible move request. Posted by telperion1 July 14, 2010 - 12:55:09 Topic ID# 10653
Hi NiRi,

Thanks for the request. I've emailed you privately about a suggestion I
have about how to handle this problem; please reply to me privately and
we'll discuss it more.

Marta

Thanks for the request.On 7/13/2010 12:20 PM, nierielraina wrote:
>
>
> I'm sorry I have not had a chance to speak up sooner. RL is a bit
> chaotic ATM.
>
> I am satisfied with all my story placements except one. I am really not
> happy with the placement of my story The Last Gift. The story, while
> including many characters from Rivendell, is NOT set there entirely, in
> fact, it's set in Gondor right before Aragorn's wedding as he thinks
> back on the gifts Elrond has given him over the years. This is why I
> purposely DID NOT choose a location for this story and was advised by my
> liaison also not to put one in, because I did NOT want it classified by
> location as that doesn't really work for this story.
>
> As is stands, only one story in this category also includes Aragorn and
> it seems to be about Aragorn with the Dúnedain. The others are about
> Hobbits. My story is really out of place there. Can you please move it
> to a more appropriate category?
>
> Thank you,
>
> Nieriel Raina
>

Msg# 10657

Reviewer Target Posted by mvoltfan July 14, 2010 - 13:03:33 Topic ID# 10657
Hi - late question - is it still possible to set a reviewer target? I found the info on this page (http://mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQreviewergoal#jun_3):

"You can set a reviewer target during the four weeks after categorisation ends. When you log into MEFA2010 during this period you will see a new option inviting you to enter or change your reviewing target."

I don't see this option when I log in. That's because the four weeks is up, isn't it? If so, that's my own fault for being late, but if it is still possible for me to set a target please let me know!

Msg# 10658

Re: Reviewer Target Posted by linaewen0 July 14, 2010 - 13:48:36 Topic ID# 10657
Actually, I don't think that the categorization period has ended yet, as they are still finalizing the categories in which our tales will appear. So you haven't missed setting your target yet -- the time for that should be coming soon, if I have my dates right!

Lin

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, "mvoltfan" <cartoon6@...> wrote:
>
> Hi - late question - is it still possible to set a reviewer target? I found the info on this page (http://mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQreviewergoal#jun_3):
>
> "You can set a reviewer target during the four weeks after categorisation ends. When you log into MEFA2010 during this period you will see a new option inviting you to enter or change your reviewing target."
>
> I don't see this option when I log in. That's because the four weeks is up, isn't it? If so, that's my own fault for being late, but if it is still possible for me to set a target please let me know!
>

Msg# 10659

Re: Reviewer Target Posted by telperion1 July 14, 2010 - 14:37:57 Topic ID# 10657
Hiya mvoltfan,

Linaewen is right. You should see the link described starting 16-July,
which is also the date when reviews will first show up and the day
*after* categorizations are "set." 14-July (today) is the last day to
request your story be moved, but that's only so the volunteers and I
will have a chance to make a decision before the end of categorizing season.

So you haven't missed anything. I'm actually going to be making this
week's educational post about reviewing goals, though I may not get that
posted until tomorrow.

Marta

On 7/14/2010 1:39 PM, mvoltfan wrote:
>
>
> Hi - late question - is it still possible to set a reviewer target? I
> found the info on this page
> (http://mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQreviewergoal#jun_3):
>
> "You can set a reviewer target during the four weeks after
> categorisation ends. When you log into MEFA2010 during this period you
> will see a new option inviting you to enter or change your reviewing
> target."
>
> I don't see this option when I log in. That's because the four weeks is
> up, isn't it? If so, that's my own fault for being late, but if it is
> still possible for me to set a target please let me know!
>

Msg# 10660

Re: Reviewer Target Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 14, 2010 - 16:50:48 Topic ID# 10657
Are the reviews we've made so fare also counted in the review goal, or the counting starts from zero after setting a goal? *unsure*
 
Ellynn
 


--- On Wed, 7/14/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:


From: telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] Reviewer Target
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Cc: "mvoltfan" <cartoon6@hotmail.com>
Date: Wednesday, July 14, 2010, 12:37 PM


 



Hiya mvoltfan,

Linaewen is right. You should see the link described starting 16-July,
which is also the date when reviews will first show up and the day
*after* categorizations are "set." 14-July (today) is the last day to
request your story be moved, but that's only so the volunteers and I
will have a chance to make a decision before the end of categorizing season.

So you haven't missed anything. I'm actually going to be making this
week's educational post about reviewing goals, though I may not get that
posted until tomorrow.

Marta




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10661

Re: final check ballot Posted by mvoltfan July 14, 2010 - 18:15:58 Topic ID# 10652
...I just finished running my eyes down the ballot for all of the categories that my stories could fall into, and then compared with the categories to which they'd been assigned. What I found was that every story had three or more categories it could fall into. I could go crazy and try moving them around but honestly, I like where they ended up.

I don't think I *really* realized before just how amazing and complicated the MEFAs are. I've been a pretty sorry participant in previous years but I'm trying to be more active and involved in MEFA2010, and I feel like I'm developing a much better sense of the whole thing as a result. Right now I'm just feeling really blown away by all the work that goes into it.

You folks are phenomenal!

~ Lauderdale



--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, telperion1 <marta.fandom@...> wrote:
>
> Hey guys,
>
> Here is the final check ballot. Please remember, tomorrow (14-July) is
> the last day to request a move.
>
> Also, if you requested that we move your story and I agreed please check
> that it appears on the check ballot below. I want to make sure I updated
> the website correctly. :-)

Msg# 10662

problems with MEFA/HASA links? Posted by raksha022002 July 14, 2010 - 18:36:19 Topic ID# 10662
Is it just me?

When I try to access my MEFA-nominated stories that are at HASA, I get a blank screen with '<.'. Same thing occurs when I click on the HASA urls of some of the stories by others who I have nominated to MEFA, via the MEFA site of course. And the same thing occurs when I go outside MEFA to access HASA through my bookmarks.

Is anyone else having this problem? It happened once before to me, several days ago, and not through MEFA, and seemed to be resolved an hour or so later.

I was alerted tonight to the problem by a MEFA participant who was trying to read one of my pieces at HASA; otherwise I would not have been aware of the problem. I am now contemplating asking to switch all my HASA URLS in my MEFA sites to alternate URLS (which is a pain, but I think I included some alternate URLs on at least some of my MEFA nomination forms); and I advise others with MEFA-nominated stories to check on their links.


Raksha the Demon

Msg# 10663

Re: problems with MEFA/HASA links? Posted by linaewen0 July 14, 2010 - 19:35:43 Topic ID# 10662
It may have been a temporary glitch -- I had no problems just now accessing my HASA-linked tales from the MEFA site, and I also was able to access HASA outside of the MEFA form.

Lin

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, "raksha022002" <PGail99@...> wrote:
>
> Is it just me?
>
> When I try to access my MEFA-nominated stories that are at HASA, I get a blank screen with '<.'. Same thing occurs when I click on the HASA urls of some of the stories by others who I have nominated to MEFA, via the MEFA site of course. And the same thing occurs when I go outside MEFA to access HASA through my bookmarks.
>
> Is anyone else having this problem? It happened once before to me, several days ago, and not through MEFA, and seemed to be resolved an hour or so later.
>
> I was alerted tonight to the problem by a MEFA participant who was trying to read one of my pieces at HASA; otherwise I would not have been aware of the problem. I am now contemplating asking to switch all my HASA URLS in my MEFA sites to alternate URLS (which is a pain, but I think I included some alternate URLs on at least some of my MEFA nomination forms); and I advise others with MEFA-nominated stories to check on their links.
>
>
> Raksha the Demon
>

Msg# 10664

Re: problems with MEFA/HASA links? Posted by Elena Tiriel July 14, 2010 - 19:37:57 Topic ID# 10662
Hi Raksha,

Just looked at your noms and clicked on a bunch that were at HASA, and had
no problems whatsoever accessing them.

Hope this helps!

- Barbara


On Wed, Jul 14, 2010 at 4:35 PM, raksha022002 <PGail99@aol.com> wrote:

>
>
> Is it just me?
>
> When I try to access my MEFA-nominated stories that are at HASA, I get a
> blank screen with '<.'. Same thing occurs when I click on the HASA urls of
> some of the stories by others who I have nominated to MEFA, via the MEFA
> site of course. And the same thing occurs when I go outside MEFA to access
> HASA through my bookmarks.
>
> Is anyone else having this problem? It happened once before to me, several
> days ago, and not through MEFA, and seemed to be resolved an hour or so
> later.
>
> I was alerted tonight to the problem by a MEFA participant who was trying
> to read one of my pieces at HASA; otherwise I would not have been aware of
> the problem. I am now contemplating asking to switch all my HASA URLS in my
> MEFA sites to alternate URLS (which is a pain, but I think I included some
> alternate URLs on at least some of my MEFA nomination forms); and I advise
> others with MEFA-nominated stories to check on their links.
>
> Raksha the Demon
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10665

Re: problems with MEFA/HASA links? Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 4:08:50 Topic ID# 10662
Hi Raksha,

I haven't had the problem either. I don't know that it's "just you,"
though - it may be a problem on HASA's end, or a larger internet problem
beyond just you that only affects some people. Since you get a screen at
all when clicking a link, I don't think it's a problem on our end.

If this is a persistent (or even recurring) problem, I suspect the HASA
volunteers would like to know about it. You can reach them using their
contact form:

http://henneth-annun.net/contact.cfm?from=/about/index.cfm?

Marta

On 7/14/2010 7:35 PM, raksha022002 wrote:
>
>
> Is it just me?
>
> When I try to access my MEFA-nominated stories that are at HASA, I get a
> blank screen with '<.'. Same thing occurs when I click on the HASA urls
> of some of the stories by others who I have nominated to MEFA, via the
> MEFA site of course. And the same thing occurs when I go outside MEFA to
> access HASA through my bookmarks.
>
> Is anyone else having this problem? It happened once before to me,
> several days ago, and not through MEFA, and seemed to be resolved an
> hour or so later.
>
> I was alerted tonight to the problem by a MEFA participant who was
> trying to read one of my pieces at HASA; otherwise I would not have been
> aware of the problem. I am now contemplating asking to switch all my
> HASA URLS in my MEFA sites to alternate URLS (which is a pain, but I
> think I included some alternate URLs on at least some of my MEFA
> nomination forms); and I advise others with MEFA-nominated stories to
> check on their links.
>
> Raksha the Demon
>

Msg# 10666

move request - The Last Gift by Nieriel Raina Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 4:36:30 Topic ID# 10666
Hey guys,

After talking with the other categorizing volunteers and with Nieriel
Raina, I've decided to leave this story where it is. Instead, we're
renaming the subcategory to be a bit more inclusive. What was previously
"Genres: Drama: Eriador or Shire" will now be "Genres: Drama: Aragorn or
Hobbits." All of the stories there, including "The Last Gift," involve
Aragorn, the hobbits, or some combination of the two. (In fact, most are
cross-cultural.) Most are also set in Eriador or the Shire, with the
exception of "The Last Gift."

The affected subcategory is:


***SubCategory: Genres: Drama: Aragorn or Hobbits***

A Star in Midwinter (11): Cairistiona
The Fairy Wife (200): Daffodil Furrow
Hobbit Aid (633): Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift (22): Linda Hoyland
The Last Gift (449): Nieriel Raina
All Was Safe With the Sea (223): RadcliffePotter

Marta

Msg# 10667

ADMIN - review goals Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 7:14:45 Topic ID# 10667
Hey guys,

This week I want to talk about review goals. Some people at MEFAwards
have asked about that already, so some people may be wondering what that
is all about. The basic idea is that some reviewers want to set a
"target" to the number of reviews they will write. We then recognize
them, both at the MEFA site themselves and by giving them a graphic they
can display wherever they like.

But before we bet started:

**********************************************

REMINDER - RECEIVING REVIEWS BY EMAIL

Starting on 16-July, "final" reviews will be shown on the MEFA website.
Annmarwalk will also be posting the reviews to two other sites: the
[mefas] LJ community and the [mefa-reviews] Yahoo group. Sign up for
either one to read reviews by email or on your LJ friends page.

Reviews will *NOT* be posted to the MEFAwards Yahoo group. You need to
sign up for mefa-reviews if you want to have them emailed to you.

**********************************************

SETTING A REVIEW GOAL - THE MECHANICS

Review goals can be set July 16-August 15. You do this by editing your
profile (the same page where you can change your password or contact
email). When you log in to our website, one of the first things you see
is a line like

"You are logged in as user aure_enteluva. Your email address is
marta.fandom@gmail.com. If this information is incorrect, please update
your profile here."

and clicking on "here" takes you to the page where you can edit your
profile. You can also reach this page by clicking the link under
"Reviewing" to set your reviewing goal, or by clicking "Name/Password"
further down the page. These links all take you to the same page. Once
there, you will see a place to enter the Target number of reviews. Just
enter the number of reviews you want to have as your target, and click
the "Save" button at the bottom of the page. You know your goal has been
set when you are taken back to the main page, with the notice that "The
user data modifications were saved successfully" at the top of the page.

You can change your goal until August 15, by doing the same thing. After
then, your goal can't be changed.

********************************************

CHOOSING A REVIEW GOAL

What your goal is, is largely a personal question. Each person reviews
differently. If you like to read longer stories, if you are newer to the
awards, or if you will have less time to devote to the MEFAs because of
offline/other fannish obligations, you may want to set a lower goal. In
general I encourage people to choose a goal that will stretch them but
not be impossible to reach. What exactly that means will depend on the
person in question.

Here are some different approaches different people take:

==> Skim the whole list of stories, and add the stories they definitely
want to read to their wish list. (Just click the Wish link on the right
part of the screen.) Then make your reviewing goal the same as the
number of stories on your wish list.

==> Decide based on past experience on a percentage of stories you want
to review. For instance, if in past years you have read about a quarter
of the stories nominated, and that you liked about half of *those* well
enough to review hem, do the math and figure out how many stories you
expect to review. 1/4 * 1/2 = 1/8 of all the stories. Since there are
606 stories in this year's competition, that works out to a review goal
of about 75 stories.

(Or, adapt this method if you want to only review a certain type of
story, or only some categories. For instance, if you only want to read
stories that selected "Elves" as one of their main category choices,
that's 144 stories. If you thought you would read a quarter of those
stories and reviewed half of what you read, your review goal would be 18.)

==> Take a review goal from a previous year, and increase it a bit. If
you did 50 last year, you might try for 60, or 75. (Keep in mind, we
have roughly 10% fewer stories this year than last year; you may want to
adjust for that.)

Of course I did a math degree so percentages and so on make sense to me.
If words like "denominator" and "transitivity" scare you more than a
raiding band of uruks, some of these approaches won't work for you.
That's okay; don't overthink this. Just set a goal that you think is
reasonable and go for it. If it was too high or too low, you can always
adjust it for future years. And there's no shame in not meeting a review
goal if you set one. The only real *rule* here is that your review goal
has to be at least 10. After that, whatever you choose is up to you.

************************************

WHAT REVIEWS COUNT?

Basically, the website counts the number of reviews wrote that will
actually be displayed and counted for the awards. That's reviews with
the status "hidden" and "final." When this count meets your review goal,
you've met your goal. Congratulations! I'll talk about what happens with
that, in the next section.

Draft reviews do *not* count for this, unless you switch them to final
or hidden by the end of the awards.

Things get a bit more complicated if you reviewed a story that didn't
compete. If you reviewed a story (status hidden or final) and that story
didn't compete at all, those reviews still counts toward your review
goals. These reviews won't be displayed or counted, but we want to
reward you for the effort anyway. It's not your fault the story didn't
compete. If the story was just nominated twice and you reviewed the
version that we withdrew, Tanaqui copied your review over to the
competing version. (From the website's perspective, each nomination is
distinct, even if it's for the same story.)

Like I said, that's complicated. I emailed the affected members a while
back, but if you have questions you can always email me.

The main point is: the website looks at *all* the reviews you've
written, from the beginning of competition until now. So if you want to
review fifty more stories, you should add this to the number you've
already reviewed, and *that* should be your review goal.

******************************

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU MEET YOUR GOAL?

When you meet your review goal, you will be sent an email from the site
congratulating you. It will also describe what happens next. Basically:

==> you can choose a banner for those members who have met their review
goals. (Link in the FAQ and in the email.) Display it wherever you are
allowed to show graphics, like at LJ or other blog sites.

==> you will be listed in a list of reviewers who met their goals, along
with the goal you set. This list is in the FAQs, and will be linked from
the website of story winners posted at the end of the awards.

==> in the list of site users, there will be a blue ribbon by your name
to recognize your reaching your goal.

All of this will happen as soon as you meet your goal.

The one thing that *doesn't* happen: you don't have to stop reviewing.
If your goal was 75 and you reach that mid-October, more power to you.
You can keep reviewing as much as you like. In fact, I encourage it! The
review goal is just a way to motivate you to review, and to recognize
those people who make reviewing a priority.

*****************************************

DO YOU HAVE TO SET A GOAL?

Nope! Some people like the challenge of meeting a goal, and for them the
review goal can help motivate them. But other people just want to keep
up a steady reviewing pace and review as many stories as they can.
Others find it hard to predict how many stories they will actually like,
and don't want to pressure themselves into reviewing stories just to
meet some goal. If the review goal won't help you, you can ignore it.

We won't be able to officially recognize your work as a reviewer (one of
the most important ways you can get involved with the awards IMO). But
if you're okay with that, and f the review goals won't help you, then it
really is okay not to set a goal. Review whatever way works best for you.

*****************************************

For more information on review goals, see:

http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQreviewergoal

To set your reviewing goal, log in and go to

http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=editPerson

*****************************************

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10668

Re: Reviewer Target Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 10:36:13 Topic ID# 10657
On 7/14/2010 5:50 PM, Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
>
> Are the reviews we've made so fare also counted in the review goal, or
> the counting starts from zero after setting a goal? *unsure*
>
> Ellynn
>
>

Hi Ellynn,

The website adds up all your hidden and final reviews, and then compares
that to your goal. As soon as the two numbers are equal, your goal is
met from the website's point of view. It doesn't look at when you wrote
the reviews at all.

The only thing that doesn't count are draft reviews. Those are the ones
that are never displayed and don't give the author any points.

Marta

Msg# 10669

Re: Reviewer Target Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 15, 2010 - 11:17:37 Topic ID# 10657
Thanks for the answer, Marta. But you didn't have to trouble yourself answering my question twice, as you wrote all that (and even more detailed) in your admin-message. Thanks a lot!
 
Ellynn


> On Thu, 7/15/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:
 
> Hi Ellynn,

> The website adds up all your hidden and final reviews, and then compares
that to your goal. As soon as the two numbers are equal, your goal is
met from the website's point of view. It doesn't look at when you wrote
the reviews at all.

> The only thing that doesn't count are draft reviews. Those are the ones
that are never displayed and don't give the author any points.

Marta




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10670

problems with MEFA/HASA links? Posted by Voirrey July 15, 2010 - 11:39:58 Topic ID# 10662
Hi,

I have had exactly the same thing twice in the past week when going direct to HASA - but each time it's been fine if I've gone back an hour or two later. But is definitely not the MEFA/HASA links.

Don't know if this helps or not....

Wombat.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10671

Re: final check ballot Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 16:11:28 Topic ID# 10652
Hi Lauderdale,

Thanks so much for the complement. Categorization can be rather
complicated, and I'm glad you think we did a good job.

But please, no "sorry participants"! No such thing in my opinion. The
important thing is to do better in the future. Good luck with that this
year.

Marta

On 7/14/2010 7:15 PM, mvoltfan wrote:
>
>
> ...I just finished running my eyes down the ballot for all of the
> categories that my stories could fall into, and then compared with the
> categories to which they'd been assigned. What I found was that every
> story had three or more categories it could fall into. I could go crazy
> and try moving them around but honestly, I like where they ended up.
>
> I don't think I *really* realized before just how amazing and
> complicated the MEFAs are. I've been a pretty sorry participant in
> previous years but I'm trying to be more active and involved in
> MEFA2010, and I feel like I'm developing a much better sense of the
> whole thing as a result. Right now I'm just feeling really blown away by
> all the work that goes into it.
>
> You folks are phenomenal!
>
> ~ Lauderdale
>

Msg# 10672

finalized check ballot in files section Posted by telperion1 July 15, 2010 - 16:36:24 Topic ID# 10672
Hey guys,

One member asked me to put the check ballot in a place she could find it
throughout the year. So I have one this. If you go to the MEFAwards
group, then click "Files," you will see a "2010 Categorization.txt"
file. If you open this you will find the checkballot, with the last
changes made in the next day or so.

The checkballot is a great way to get an overview of the awards. It
lists the barebones info on each story competing (name, author, and ID
#). The ID # can than be used to look up more story information at our
website. Just

1. Log in to www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/
2. Click the stories link at the top of the page.
3. Do a search for the ID number, followed by the # sign. For instance
doing a search for "290#" would bring up

To be Black (290): Encairion

Obviously you'll need the website to read the story, vote for it, even
find out more information about it. And some people may not see a need
to use this check-ballot at all. That's okay. But if you'd like to use
it, it's there.

Marta

Msg# 10673

Re: finalized check ballot in files section Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 16, 2010 - 2:38:55 Topic ID# 10672
> On Thu, 7/15/10, telperion1 <marta.fandom@gmail.com> wrote:
> If you go to the MEFAwards group, then click "Files," you will see a "2010 Categorization.txt" file. If you open this you will find the checkballot, with the last changes made in the next day or so.

Great! :) OK, I'll start making banners according to this final list. ;)

Ellynn





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10674

Technical problems HASA Posted by nath kuijpers July 18, 2010 - 6:28:37 Topic ID# 10672
For everyone that's experienced problems accessing stories at HASA in the last week or so, I can pass on the message that I also posted in the HASA news:
*-*
HASA has been unstable the last few days. Tech support has been unable to identify the root cause so far, but is continuing to investigate. Until the cause can be uncovered and corrected, the site will need manual restarts after it hangs. We apologize for the inconvenience.
*-*

I don't think the problem is currently serious enough for MEFA stories that are hosted on HASA to switch to back-up URLs, since the problem is intermittent. If there's any change (for better or worse) I will of course follow up on this announcement.


Nath

.............................................~o^=o>
.....................................~o^=o>
..............................~o^=o>
........................~o^=o>

Msg# 10675

Re: Technical problems HASA Posted by telperion1 July 18, 2010 - 8:42:24 Topic ID# 10672
Hi Nath,

Thanks so much for the update! I agree, this isn't a severe enough
problem for the MEFAs to change everyone's URL without their asking for
it. Though I'll repeat my offer to Raksha: if anyone does want me to
change out your URL to a different one, send me an email at
mefasupportATgmailDOTcom, and I'll gladly do it.

In the mean time, if HASA or any other site is temporarily down, I
encourage people to make use of the wish list. Just click the "Wish"
link on the right side of the page, and the MEFA site will keep track of
it for you, so you can come back to it later. I'll actually be doing
this week's educational post on Wish and Skip lists, so will talk more
about that in a few days.

Marta

On 7/18/2010 7:28 AM, nath kuijpers wrote:
>
>
> For everyone that's experienced problems accessing stories at HASA in
> the last week or so, I can pass on the message that I also posted in the
> HASA news:
> *-*
> HASA has been unstable the last few days. Tech support has been unable
> to identify the root cause so far, but is continuing to investigate.
> Until the cause can be uncovered and corrected, the site will need
> manual restarts after it hangs. We apologize for the inconvenience.
> *-*
>
> I don't think the problem is currently serious enough for MEFA stories
> that are hosted on HASA to switch to back-up URLs, since the problem is
> intermittent. If there's any change (for better or worse) I will of
> course follow up on this announcement.
>

Msg# 10676

ADMIN - Wish + Skip Lists Posted by telperion1 July 21, 2010 - 16:17:14 Topic ID# 10676
Hey guys,

This week I wanted to talk about three things our website does, that
helps you manage the lists of reviews and nominations. But first, two
quick reminders:

1. You can read reviews posted to our website by email if you prefer.
Annmarwalk posts them to the Yahoo group [mefa-discussion] and the LJ
community [mefas]. Join either group if you want to read reviews by
email or on your LJ friends list.

2. You can set a reviewing target if you like by visiting our website.
Make sure you enter your goal by August 15 if you plan on using this
feature.

Now, on to keeping rack of nominations and reviews. There are currently
606 nominations in the awards, and 844 reviews that are currently
visible. That can seem overwhelming if you want to read either all the
stories or all the reviews. And it *is* a bit overwhelming - so much so
that you could not get involved at all because you don't know where to
start. The MEFA site offers three tools to help you deal with this.

*****************************

WISH AND SKIP LISTS FOR NOMINATIONS

You can add stories to your wish and skip lists easily enough. Just

--- Log in to www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/
--- Click on the "Stories" link at the top of the page.
--- Find the story you want to add to your wish or skip.
--- Click the "Wish" or "Skip" link on the right side of the page.

Stories on your skip list are not shown to you again, unless you ask the
website specifically to see skipped stories. (See below.) "Wish list"
stories show up with all the other stories, but you can also tell the
website to display your wish or skip list specifically. This is a great
way to keep track of stories you want to read, but that you don't have
time to read at the moment. (It an also be used if the site where a
story is hosted is down temporarily.)

******************************

PULLING UP YOUR WISH/SKIP LIST

If you want to see the stories you have added to your skip lists, then

--- Log in to www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/
--- Click on the "Stories" link at the top of the page.
--- Click the "Show Filter" link.
--- Make sure none of the filters have anything selected. Click "Clear
All Filters" if necessary."[*]
--- Select "Skip" from the "Review Status" option.
--- Click "Display selected nominations."

This will bring up those stories previously put on your "Skip" list. You
can bring up your "Wish" list the same way, by selecting "Wish" instead
of "Skip" on the next-to-last step.

([*] This step is important whenever using the filters. If you select
options from more than one filter, the website only shows you stories
that meet both criteria. It also "remembers" your choices since you've
been logged in. To make sure you are seeing all pertinent nominations, I
recommend you click the "Clear All Filters" button if you have used the
filters before since logging in to the website.)

*******************************

REMOVING A NOMINATION FROM YOUR SKIP/WISH LIST

When you enter a review, it automatically removes a story from your skip
list. However, you may decide you want to read a story after all, or
that you don't want it showing up on your wish list. If so, just pull up
the wish or skip list as described above. Once that's pulled up, click
the link on the "Remove from Skip/Wish List" on the far right side of
the page. This will make it like you had never clicked "Sip" or "Wish"
in the first place.

Don't worry - your wish and skip lists are only visible to yourself and
other top-level volunteers like myself. And we won't look at them
without a good reason. So you can add a story to your wish or skip list
without worry of offending the authors.

********************************

MANAGING REVIEWS - THE MARKING FEATURE

The wish and skip lists help you find nominations you want to read (or
don't want to read). But what about reviews. There are 800+ reviews now,
and that number will be growing. And the website displays the oldest
reviews last. Luckily, there are ways to help you find your unread
reviews more easily.

The most useful of these is the "Marking" feature. Reviews are displayed
twenty-five to a page. At the bottom of each page, you will see a link
to "Mark these reviews as read and load the next page." If you click
that, the website will "Mark" those reviews for you. Then the next time
you come to the webpage, the first reviews you see will be the oldest
ones *you haven't marked*.

********************************

READING MARKED REVIEWS

Did you mark some reviews that you now want to see again? The marking
feature works kind of like the "skip" feature for reviews: they aren't
shown to you when the website first loads, but they are still there so
you can pull them up if you want to. To do this, go to the reviews
section of the website and click the "Show Marked Reviews" link. This
will show all the reviews, oldlest first, whether they are marked or
not. Marked reviews will be on a pinkish/reddish background, while
unmarked reviews will have a blue background.

*********************************

P.S. - New this year, you can add stories to your wish or skip list
directly from the reviews section. If you're reading reviews and
someone's review intrigues you, so you want to read the nomination and
maybe vote for it yourself, just click the "Add to Wish List" or "Skip"
link into the review header. You will then find them by using your wish
or skip list in the Stories section.

*********************************

Read more:

--- How do I find a story to vote for?
http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQvoting#vot_15

**********************************

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10677

Re: ADMIN - Wish + Skip Lists - CORRECTION Posted by telperion1 July 21, 2010 - 16:23:52 Topic ID# 10676
Hey guys,

*blushes*

> 1. You can read reviews posted to our website by email if you prefer.
> Annmarwalk posts them to the Yahoo group [mefa-discussion] and the LJ
> community [mefas]. Join either group if you want to read reviews by
> email or on your LJ friends list.
>

I mean the Yahoo group mefa-reviews, not mefa-discussion. The respective
groups can be found at

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mefa-reviews/
http://mefas.livejournal.com/

Marta

Msg# 10678

SoA is down. Posted by Barbara Rich July 22, 2010 - 12:37:24 Topic ID# 10678
It seems as if Stories of Arda is down today. I don't know why, but it
might be a problem if it can't be fixed soon.

Dreamflower


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10679

Re: SoA is down. Posted by Elizabeth Nield July 22, 2010 - 12:53:41 Topic ID# 10678
Does anyone know how to find out why SoA is down??

:(

A very worried Kaylee

----- Original Message -----
From: Barbara Rich
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 10:37 AM
Subject: [MEFAwards] SoA is down.



It seems as if Stories of Arda is down today. I don't know why, but it
might be a problem if it can't be fixed soon.

Dreamflower

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10680

Re: SoA is down. Posted by Bonnie L. Sherrell July 22, 2010 - 13:27:45 Topic ID# 10678
One of the mods there has explained that the host just upgraded some equipment
and it's hiccuping. They are working on it now.
Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

Msg# 10681

Re: SoA is down. Posted by telperion1 July 22, 2010 - 14:22:32 Topic ID# 10678
On 7/22/2010 1:37 PM, Barbara Rich wrote:
> It seems as if Stories of Arda is down today. I don't know why, but it
> might be a problem if it can't be fixed soon.

Hi Dreamflower and all,

Thanks for letting me know about this. I'm inclined to give them a day,
since we're so far away from the deadline. However I will check
tomorrow, and if it isn't fixed by then I'll look at swapping out URLs.
I'm not a member of the SOA listserv - can you or someone else let us
know if they say they got it fixed?

Marta

Msg# 10682

story completed - The Sell-Sword and the Princess by Lady Bluejay Posted by telperion1 July 22, 2010 - 14:31:54 Topic ID# 10682
Hey guys,

Congrats to Lady Bluejay! She has finished her WIP story #98 "The
Sell-Sword and the Princess." That means it will no longer be competing
against WIPs but will instead run against finished fic.

I have updated that story's information on our website. You can now find
this story under Genres: Longer Works: General.

Marta

Msg# 10683

Re: SoA is down. Posted by Elizabeth Nield July 22, 2010 - 20:46:18 Topic ID# 10678
SOA's back up! But...it looks like everything posted after the beginning of March is GONE!!! :(

Kaylee

*biting nails worriedly*

----- Original Message -----
From: telperion1
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Cc: Barbara Rich
Sent: Thursday, July 22, 2010 12:18 PM
Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] SoA is down.



On 7/22/2010 1:37 PM, Barbara Rich wrote:
> It seems as if Stories of Arda is down today. I don't know why, but it
> might be a problem if it can't be fixed soon.

Hi Dreamflower and all,

Thanks for letting me know about this. I'm inclined to give them a day,
since we're so far away from the deadline. However I will check
tomorrow, and if it isn't fixed by then I'll look at swapping out URLs.
I'm not a member of the SOA listserv - can you or someone else let us
know if they say they got it fixed?

Marta




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10684

Re: SoA is down. Posted by Bonnie L. Sherrell July 22, 2010 - 21:31:21 Topic ID# 10678
As of this time it is apparently back down once more. They are probably working
on reconstructing it once more, remembering the time of the great hacking.

Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

Msg# 10685

update recent technical problems HASA Posted by nath kuijpers July 22, 2010 - 22:01:42 Topic ID# 10672
Don't panic if you find you can't access HASA this Friday!

"As part of the ongoing investigation into recent server instability, HASA will be offline several times on Friday, July 23rd, to allow tests to be conducted on the ColdFusion server and the MS SQL server."

Apologies to anyone who runs into problems trying to read stories, but we shouldn't be offline for too long, so if you can't get there, try again an hour or so later on Friday...

Msg# 10686

Re: SoA is down. Posted by linaewen0 July 23, 2010 - 9:18:13 Topic ID# 10678
There is an explanation over at LOTR_Community_GFIC about why SoA is currently down -- the short version of it is that they are working to restore the missing data and have turned things off so that any new additions don't get lost in the shuffle. Something like that! They hope to be back up today sometime.

Lin

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, "Bonnie L. Sherrell" <blslarner@...> wrote:
>
> As of this time it is apparently back down once more. They are probably working
> on reconstructing it once more, remembering the time of the great hacking.
>
> Bonnie L. Sherrell
> Teacher at Large
>
> "Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR
>
> "Don't go where I can't follow."
>

Msg# 10687

Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 23, 2010 - 10:21:28 Topic ID# 10672
Hello!
 
I started making winner-banners. So, a few notes about that. ;)
 
As for tags, I will tag the banners with the full name of the category (example: Genres_Fixed-Length_Ficlet_Gondor_or_Rohan) and the size. I will not add places; once you find your category, it is easy to find the place you need, just browse banners.
 
Size. Well, here I feel sort of troubled. For now, I am making only 290x150 banners, and it will stay like that (for most of the time). It is a little bit difficult for me to put all the text needed on smaller banners, and it would take me a lot of time. Besides, I am not a fan of small pictures with a lot of text on it. So, I will make banners of other sizes only by request, and not in "serial production", so to say. ;)
 
Background pictures. For as many categories as possible, I will try to make at least two banners, with background that is related to name of the category. Of course, there will be those for which it won't be possible, so I'll make such banners with more general background.
There are some categories that have some things in common, for example, Gondor and/or Rohan are mentioned in the several categories (they differ in other things, like length, genre etc.). For all of them, some Gondor/Rohan theme will be in the background. Now, I can't make *all* banners with *all* backgrounds, it would take me too much time. :(
But! :) As I have already mentioned in some other message, I keep all my banners in layered version. :) So, if you see some picture you like, but it is in some other category, and you would like that particular picture with the text of your category, don't hesitate to ask me. ;)
 
That's it for now. See you around on MEFA site, bye everyone!
 
Ellynn




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10688

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Aranel Took July 23, 2010 - 10:42:01 Topic ID# 10672
Hi Ellyn,

Your banners look great! But may I suggest that you not post every place?
Just post one of each design in one of the placings to show what they look
like. Some people are stuck on low-bandwidth connections or older computers,
so loading 4x as many banners as necessary is a real problem. It will also
make it easier for everyone to search through the banners when more are
submitted.

Aranel

On Fri, Jul 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Ellin Ithilwen
<ellin_revenger@yahoo.com>wrote:

> Hello!
>
> I started making winner-banners. So, a few notes about that. ;)
>
> As for tags, I will tag the banners with the full name of the category
> (example: Genres_Fixed-Length_Ficlet_Gondor_or_Rohan) and the size. I will
> not add places; once you find your category, it is easy to find the place
> you need, just browse banners.
>
> Size. Well, here I feel sort of troubled. For now, I am making only 290x150
> banners, and it will stay like that (for most of the time). It is a little
> bit difficult for me to put all the text needed on smaller banners, and it
> would take me a lot of time. Besides, I am not a fan of small pictures with
> a lot of text on it. So, I will make banners of other sizes only by request,
> and not in "serial production", so to say. ;)
>
> Background pictures. For as many categories as possible, I will try to make
> at least two banners, with background that is related to name of the
> category. Of course, there will be those for which it won't be possible, so
> I'll make such banners with more general background.
> There are some categories that have some things in common, for example,
> Gondor and/or Rohan are mentioned in the several categories (they differ in
> other things, like length, genre etc.). For all of them, some Gondor/Rohan
> theme will be in the background. Now, I can't make *all* banners with *all*
> backgrounds, it would take me too much time. :(
> But! :) As I have already mentioned in some other message, I keep all my
> banners in layered version. :) So, if you see some picture you like, but it
> is in some other category, and you would like that particular picture with
> the text of your category, don't hesitate to ask me. ;)
>
> That's it for now. See you around on MEFA site, bye everyone!
>
> Ellynn
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10689

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 23, 2010 - 10:46:39 Topic ID# 10672
> On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:

>Your banners look great! But may I suggest that you not post every place?
Just post one of each design in one of the placings to show what they look
like.
 
Thank you! :)))
Well, no problem about your request, but when the time comes, how will the authors take their banners? Should I send them by e-mail? Or, when the time comes, do I upload others too, so that they are all available after the results are announced? *unsure*




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10690

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Aranel Took July 23, 2010 - 11:12:50 Topic ID# 10672
Hi Ellin,

Previously, the banners were displayed without any award category or place,
so it was wide open which ones could be used. There's nothing wrong with
displaying categories and places on the banners (I think it's a good idea to
show how text will look on them), but, as you mentioned in your post, an
author may want a different background for an award category.

I'm not really sure of distribution, as I've always customized my own
banners, but I just went and took a peek at last year's banners, and it
looks like customized banners were uploaded to a Photobucket group (
http://www.photobucket.com/mefa09w, password "aelfwine", if you want to take
a look). So I imagine a "Customized" Album would be created, customized
banners uploaded there, and then the author is sent the direct links to
their customized banners.

Is the procedure for banners different this year, where the banner maker's
are creating banners for particular categories?

Aranel

On Fri, Jul 23, 2010 at 10:46 AM, Ellin Ithilwen
<ellin_revenger@yahoo.com>wrote:

> > On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> >Your banners look great! But may I suggest that you not post every place?
> Just post one of each design in one of the placings to show what they look
> like.
>
> Thank you! :)))
> Well, no problem about your request, but when the time comes, how will the
> authors take their banners? Should I send them by e-mail? Or, when the time
> comes, do I upload others too, so that they are all available after the
> results are announced? *unsure*
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10691

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 23, 2010 - 11:34:15 Topic ID# 10672
Uhm, when I try to click on last year's banners, it says "page not found".
 
This is only my second year on MEFA, so I didn't know how it all worked for banners last year. From what you say, it seems that only plain pictures were posted, and then each author made his own banners?
I had one story last year, and I made a banner for myself; I didn't use any of the offered pictures, but I made completely new banner (that is, 1st, 2nd, 3rd and HM for that category), and sent it to NiRi who had been coordinator.
I know there are many people who don't have software for photomanipulation, or even if they do, they don't know how to work in it. So, that's why I want to make completed banners. Besides, I voluneered for it, which means that I want to contribute as much as I can. :)
 
Ah well, we have enough time to arrange everything. :)
 
Ellynn
 
> On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
> Previously, the banners were displayed without any award category or place,
so it was wide open which ones could be used. There's nothing wrong with
displaying categories and places on the banners (I think it's a good idea to
show how text will look on them), but, as you mentioned in your post, an
author may want a different background for an award category.
> I'm not really sure of distribution, as I've always customized my own
banners, but I just went and took a peek at last year's banners, and it
looks like customized banners were uploaded to a Photobucket group (
http://www.photobucket.com/mefa09w, password "aelfwine", if you want to take
a look). So I imagine a "Customized" Album would be created, customized
banners uploaded there, and then the author is sent the direct links to
their customized banners.




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10692

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Dawn Felagund July 23, 2010 - 11:39:42 Topic ID# 10672
I seem to remember that, in past years, winners chose a banner, contacted
the MEFAs, and a volunteer customized the banner with the category and the
place that the person had one. That way, there was only one copy of each
banner up on the website. Is that how it's still done?

Of course, people with photomanip software could use the bases to customize
their own as well.

Dawn

--
~oOo~
Dawn Felagund
http://themidhavens.net/heretic_loremaster/
http://www.silmarillionwritersguild.org


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10693

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Aranel Took July 23, 2010 - 12:12:55 Topic ID# 10672
Hi Ellin,

I had forgotten that each category had a specific set of banners made,
separate from the banners offered for customization, so that's my bad.
You're right about that. However, the problem this year is that Picasa is
terrible for displaying the banners, dumping the entire set on you at once
(Photobucket split them up with 20 per page). I suggest making an album for
each Main Category, or even by Award Category (depending on how many banners
there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by hundreds of banners at
once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?

RE: Customization. As Dawn said, banner customization was done by request if
the author did not have their own means to do it. Authors would submit their
customization requests and we have "banner customizer" volunteers who take
the requests and create the banners for authors. Customizable banners should
probably be split across albums by category as well.

Aranel



On Fri, Jul 23, 2010 at 11:34 AM, Ellin Ithilwen
<ellin_revenger@yahoo.com>wrote:

> Uhm, when I try to click on last year's banners, it says "page not found".
>
> This is only my second year on MEFA, so I didn't know how it all worked for
> banners last year. From what you say, it seems that only plain pictures were
> posted, and then each author made his own banners?
> I had one story last year, and I made a banner for myself; I didn't use any
> of the offered pictures, but I made completely new banner (that is, 1st,
> 2nd, 3rd and HM for that category), and sent it to NiRi who had been
> coordinator.
> I know there are many people who don't have software for photomanipulation,
> or even if they do, they don't know how to work in it. So, that's why I want
> to make completed banners. Besides, I voluneered for it, which means that I
> want to contribute as much as I can. :)
>
> Ah well, we have enough time to arrange everything. :)
>
> Ellynn
>
> > On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
> > Previously, the banners were displayed without any award category or
> place,
> so it was wide open which ones could be used. There's nothing wrong with
> displaying categories and places on the banners (I think it's a good idea
> to
> show how text will look on them), but, as you mentioned in your post, an
> author may want a different background for an award category.
> > I'm not really sure of distribution, as I've always customized my own
> banners, but I just went and took a peek at last year's banners, and it
> looks like customized banners were uploaded to a Photobucket group (
> http://www.photobucket.com/mefa09w, password "aelfwine", if you want to
> take
> a look). So I imagine a "Customized" Album would be created, customized
> banners uploaded there, and then the author is sent the direct links to
> their customized banners.
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10694

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 23, 2010 - 16:36:48 Topic ID# 10672
> On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
> I had forgotten that each category had a specific set of banners made,
separate from the banners offered for customization, so that's my bad.
You're right about that. However, the problem this year is that Picasa is
terrible for displaying the banners, dumping the entire set on you at once
(Photobucket split them up with 20 per page). I suggest making an album for
each Main Category, or even by Award Category (depending on how many banners
there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by hundreds of banners at
once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?

Uhm, I guess it is a good idea to make several albums. Let's also wait and see what Neume says about this. If we'll split albums, I'll upload again those that I have already made.
As for making banners... I can go on like I started, that is, making banners for all categories (2 or 3 banners for each X all 4 versions-places). That way, if people will find what they like, they don't have to do it by themselves. And if someone wants something different, let him/her just ask. ;)
 
Ellynn




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10695

ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by telperion1 July 24, 2010 - 15:00:49 Topic ID# 10695
Hey guys,

Two major archives have experienced "downtime" over the past few days.
Downtime is when the archive is not accessible, either because of
scheduled repairs or unexpected technical problems. This happens to all
websites from time to time, and archives are especially vulnerable
because they are maintained by volunteers, usually working in small
groups. (This is why commercial websites often have downtime at times
when the website is less likely to be used.)

The two sites affected this time are http://www.henneth-annun.net/ and
http://www.storiesofarda.com/. HASA is back up, though I've been told it
may run a little slower the first few times you access it. SOA is still
down (for me, as of 3:49 PM US East Coast), though I know their
volunteers are working very hard to get it fixed as soon as possible.

In the meantime, I am going to work on getting functioning URLs for
stories hosted at SOA. For those who gave alternate URLs, I will use
those; for other authors I will email you and ask if you would like to
give an alternate URL in the meantime. Voters, this may take a few
hours, so if you come across a non-functioning link in the meantime
please put it on your wish list.

I am of course not expressing judgment against SOA. It's a fine archive,
and I am very sympathetic toward their technical problems! When their
problems are fixed, authors are more than welcome to email me at
mefasupportATgmailDOTcom, and ask that I change their URL back. If you
provide me the ID#, the story title, and the new URL, it is rather easy
to do.

I *would* appreciate it if members would keep from recommending new
archives here. This fandom has several good archives, and for those
members without alternate URLs, I will suggest several options
privately. But a public recommendation can look like we are saying one
archive is bad and the other is better. (Unintentionally, I'm sure, but
it can still seem like that.)

Speaking generally - archives go down all the time. If you ever see a
notice about your favorite archive having downtime, feel free to email
it to me at mefasupportATgmailDOTcom. I will announce it to the group if
it affects the MEFAs.

Marta

Msg# 10696

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 24, 2010 - 16:06:33 Topic ID# 10695
Right now (11 p.m. CET) not even MEFA site is available; when I click on it, there is error message. More technical problems? *worried*
 
Ellynn




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10697

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by Tanaqui July 24, 2010 - 16:21:44 Topic ID# 10695
Hi Ellynn

I've just checked and I can get to the MEFA site, but it looks from the
server status messages I can see like our hosting company has just
rebooted the server, so you may have just caught it as they were doing
that. Perhaps you could try again?

Tanaqui
MEFA Tech Support

Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
> Right now (11 p.m. CET) not even MEFA site is available; when I click
> on it, there is error message. More technical problems? *worried*
>
> Ellynn
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>

Msg# 10698

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by Voirrey July 24, 2010 - 16:23:55 Topic ID# 10695
MEFA site is fine for me. It's now, 22.20 BST, so a few minutes since Ellynn posted.

Wombat.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10699

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 24, 2010 - 16:24:33 Topic ID# 10695
Yep, everything is ok now. ;)
 
Ellynn

--- On Sat, 7/24/10, Tanaqui <tanaqui@btopenworld.com> wrote:


From: Tanaqui <tanaqui@btopenworld.com>
Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] ADMIN - archive downtime
To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
Date: Saturday, July 24, 2010, 2:15 PM


Hi Ellynn

I've just checked and I can get to the MEFA site, but it looks from the
server status messages I can see like our hosting company has just
rebooted the server, so you may have just caught it as they were doing
that. Perhaps you could try again?

Tanaqui
MEFA Tech Support

Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
> Right now (11 p.m. CET) not even MEFA site is available; when I click
> on it, there is error message. More technical problems? *worried*
>
> Ellynn
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>



------------------------------------

Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
Yahoo! Groups Links








[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10700

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by telperion1 July 24, 2010 - 16:27:35 Topic ID# 10695
On 7/24/2010 4:59 PM, Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
>
> Right now (11 p.m. CET) not even MEFA site is available; when I click on
> it, there is error message. More technical problems? *worried*
>
> Ellynn
>

Hi Ellynn,

By MEFA website do you mean http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/ ? The
site you usually log in to in order to read stories and vote? Or
something else?

If you mean www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/, that's working for me. If you
can't access that site, can you please email
techsupportATmefawardsDOTnet, with the browser you are using and the
exact error message, if any? Hopefully they can help you sort it out.

Marta

Msg# 10701

Re: ADMIN - archive downtime Posted by telperion1 July 24, 2010 - 16:30:59 Topic ID# 10695
On 7/24/2010 5:24 PM, Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
>
> Yep, everything is ok now. ;)
>
> Ellynn
>

*phew* Glad to hear it!

Marta

Msg# 10702

Re: SoA is down. Posted by telperion1 July 24, 2010 - 16:36:24 Topic ID# 10678
On 7/22/2010 9:37 PM, Elizabeth Nield wrote:
>
>
> SOA's back up! But...it looks like everything posted after the beginning
> of March is GONE!!! :(
>
> Kaylee
>

Hi Kaylee,

I've been talking with Rorrah who does tech support for SOA, and she
explained there was a technical problem to do with an upgrade by their
host company. I won't go into technical details, except to say they know
about the problem and really are doing everything they can to get the
site back up ASAP. I think Rorrah and Nilmandra are working to get the
data back, and they expect to, though as with all technical issues the
"when" is sometimes a bit less predictable. :-)

Larner forwarded an announcement made by Rorrah, to another listserv I
belong to. (I do not personally belong to the SOA listserv, where the
announcements were initially made.) I am including them below, for
everyone's information; I cannot be sure how up-to-date they are,
though. If you or anyone else wants to receive all SOA announcements,
their listserv is

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/stories_of_arda/

So I expect the data will be coming back, and urge everyone to be
patient. As for our own links to SOA, I am working right now on getting
those updated.

Marta



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: rorrah <rorrah@...>
Date: Thu, Jul 22, 2010 at 8:07 PM
Subject: [stories_of_arda] Re: Site Down
To: stories_of_arda@yahoogroups.com




All right, this ended up being partly our fault and partly the ISP's fault.

It turns out they migrated servers back in March. They even sent us an
email to
let us know.

Our fault, we didn't read it all the way through to realize we needed to do
something.

Their fault, they didn't tell us all that we needed to do.

So 4 months after migration, they decided to force the issue and we are
now on
their NEW system, bad news, the NEW system is exactly what the website
looked
like in March.

I have temporarily disabled the LOGIN feature until they fix the database.
They're going to track down the database that we've been using since
March and I
don't want any new data to get lost in the meantime.

It should all be resolved by tomorrow.

*crosses finger and contemplates buying KFC in lieu of sacrificing a live
chicken*

Rorrah

Msg# 10703

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 25, 2010 - 5:48:42 Topic ID# 10672
> On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
> I suggest making an album for
each Main Category, or even by Award Category (depending on how many banners
there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by hundreds of banners at
once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?

I am back on this topic, for I really like this idea. Instead of one huge album, we can have several. I tried to make a list of albums; each of them would be applied to one or more main categories. Number in the brackets marks the number of subcategories:
 
Genres: Adventure & Alternate Universe & Crossover & Longer Works & Mystery (7)
Genres: Character Study (10)
Genres: Drama (11)
Genres: Ficlet & Fixed-Length Ficlet (7)
Genres: Horror & Humor (8)
Genres: Non-Fiction & Poetry & Romance (8)
Races: Cross-Cultural (5)
Races: Dwarves & Elves & Other Beings & Villains (7)
Races: Hobbits & Men (7)
Times: First Age and Prior & Second and Early Third Age & Ring War (8)
Times: Modern Times & Post-Ring War and Beyond & Pre-Ring War (6)
 
So, even in the bigest album, and even if banner-makers upload all 4 versions for each category, the number of pictures shouldn't be over 120-130, which is OK, I hope.
I believe that several instead of one album will not make the search for banners difficult; quite on the contrary. What do the others say?
 
Ellynn




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10704

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Aranel Took July 25, 2010 - 8:16:12 Topic ID# 10672
Hi Ellyn,

Sounds like a good plan! I think that will help a lot to split them up, and
authors will be able to go right to the categories they need. If they are
all going to be tagged by content ("Hobbits", "Rohan", etc.), that will
allow authors to search for particular banners across all categories.

Aranel

On Sun, Jul 25, 2010 at 5:48 AM, Ellin Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@yahoo.com>wrote:

> > On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:
> > I suggest making an album for
> each Main Category, or even by Award Category (depending on how many
> banners
> there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by hundreds of banners at
> once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?
>
> I am back on this topic, for I really like this idea. Instead of one huge
> album, we can have several. I tried to make a list of albums; each of them
> would be applied to one or more main categories. Number in the brackets
> marks the number of subcategories:
>
> Genres: Adventure & Alternate Universe & Crossover & Longer Works & Mystery
> (7)
> Genres: Character Study (10)
> Genres: Drama (11)
> Genres: Ficlet & Fixed-Length Ficlet (7)
> Genres: Horror & Humor (8)
> Genres: Non-Fiction & Poetry & Romance (8)
> Races: Cross-Cultural (5)
> Races: Dwarves & Elves & Other Beings & Villains (7)
> Races: Hobbits & Men (7)
> Times: First Age and Prior & Second and Early Third Age & Ring War (8)
> Times: Modern Times & Post-Ring War and Beyond & Pre-Ring War (6)
>
> So, even in the bigest album, and even if banner-makers upload all 4
> versions for each category, the number of pictures shouldn't be over
> 120-130, which is OK, I hope.
> I believe that several instead of one album will not make the search for
> banners difficult; quite on the contrary. What do the others say?
>
> Ellynn
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10705

Re: Winner-banners Posted by nath kuijpers July 25, 2010 - 13:08:20 Topic ID# 10672
Good idea, but for those of us who mainly make generic pictures for people to choose from, there should probably be an album as well. When I make a forest banner for instance, I'm just as happy if it's used for a First Age Drama as a Character Study in the Third Age...

--- On Sun, 25/7/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com> wrote:

> From: Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com>
> Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] Winner-banners
> To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
> Date: Sunday, 25 July, 2010, 13:52
> Hi Ellyn,
>
> Sounds like a good plan! I think that will help a lot to
> split them up, and
> authors will be able to go right to the categories they
> need. If they are
> all going to be tagged by content ("Hobbits", "Rohan",
> etc.), that will
> allow authors to search for particular banners across all
> categories.
>
> Aranel
>
> On Sun, Jul 25, 2010 at 5:48 AM, Ellin Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@yahoo.com>wrote:
>
> > > On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@gmail.com>
> wrote:
> > > I suggest making an album for
> > each Main Category, or even by Award Category
> (depending on how many
> > banners
> > there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by
> hundreds of banners at
> > once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?
> >
> > I am back on this topic, for I really like this idea.
> Instead of one huge
> > album, we can have several. I tried to make a list of
> albums; each of them
> > would be applied to one or more main categories.
> Number in the brackets
> > marks the number of subcategories:
> >
> > Genres: Adventure & Alternate Universe &
> Crossover & Longer Works & Mystery
> > (7)
> > Genres: Character Study (10)
> > Genres: Drama (11)
> > Genres: Ficlet & Fixed-Length Ficlet (7)
> > Genres: Horror & Humor (8)
> > Genres: Non-Fiction & Poetry & Romance (8)
> > Races: Cross-Cultural (5)
> > Races: Dwarves & Elves & Other Beings &
> Villains (7)
> > Races: Hobbits & Men (7)
> > Times: First Age and Prior & Second and Early
> Third Age & Ring War (8)
> > Times: Modern Times & Post-Ring War and Beyond
> & Pre-Ring War (6)
> >
> > So, even in the bigest album, and even if
> banner-makers upload all 4
> > versions for each category, the number of pictures
> shouldn't be over
> > 120-130, which is OK, I hope.
> > I believe that several instead of one album will not
> make the search for
> > banners difficult; quite on the contrary. What do the
> others say?
> >
> > Ellynn
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> >
> >
> >
> > ------------------------------------
> >
> > Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> > Yahoo! Groups Links
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>     MEFAwards-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com
>
>
>

Msg# 10706

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Red July 25, 2010 - 15:00:05 Topic ID# 10672
Yes, I'm that kind of banner maker too. I don't do specific catagories, I do general scenic banners that can be used for plenty of different stories, personally customized for the winners.

Is there a way to set up a banner specifically for banners like ours?


--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, nath kuijpers <nath_kuijpers@...> wrote:
>
> Good idea, but for those of us who mainly make generic pictures for people to choose from, there should probably be an album as well. When I make a forest banner for instance, I'm just as happy if it's used for a First Age Drama as a Character Study in the Third Age...
>
> --- On Sun, 25/7/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@...> wrote:
>
> > From: Aranel Took <araneltook@...>
> > Subject: Re: [MEFAwards] Winner-banners
> > To: MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com
> > Date: Sunday, 25 July, 2010, 13:52
> > Hi Ellyn,
> >
> > Sounds like a good plan! I think that will help a lot to
> > split them up, and
> > authors will be able to go right to the categories they
> > need. If they are
> > all going to be tagged by content ("Hobbits", "Rohan",
> > etc.), that will
> > allow authors to search for particular banners across all
> > categories.
> >
> > Aranel
> >
> > On Sun, Jul 25, 2010 at 5:48 AM, Ellin Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@...>wrote:
> >
> > > > On Fri, 7/23/10, Aranel Took <araneltook@...>
> > wrote:
> > > > I suggest making an album for
> > > each Main Category, or even by Award Category
> > (depending on how many
> > > banners
> > > there will be), so that users aren't overwhelmed by
> > hundreds of banners at
> > > once. Other banner makes want to chime in on this?
> > >
> > > I am back on this topic, for I really like this idea.
> > Instead of one huge
> > > album, we can have several. I tried to make a list of
> > albums; each of them
> > > would be applied to one or more main categories.
> > Number in the brackets
> > > marks the number of subcategories:
> > >
> > > Genres: Adventure & Alternate Universe &
> > Crossover & Longer Works & Mystery
> > > (7)
> > > Genres: Character Study (10)
> > > Genres: Drama (11)
> > > Genres: Ficlet & Fixed-Length Ficlet (7)
> > > Genres: Horror & Humor (8)
> > > Genres: Non-Fiction & Poetry & Romance (8)
> > > Races: Cross-Cultural (5)
> > > Races: Dwarves & Elves & Other Beings &
> > Villains (7)
> > > Races: Hobbits & Men (7)
> > > Times: First Age and Prior & Second and Early
> > Third Age & Ring War (8)
> > > Times: Modern Times & Post-Ring War and Beyond
> > & Pre-Ring War (6)
> > >
> > > So, even in the bigest album, and even if
> > banner-makers upload all 4
> > > versions for each category, the number of pictures
> > shouldn't be over
> > > 120-130, which is OK, I hope.
> > > I believe that several instead of one album will not
> > make the search for
> > > banners difficult; quite on the contrary. What do the
> > others say?
> > >
> > > Ellynn
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > > ------------------------------------
> > >
> > > Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> > > Yahoo! Groups Links
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> >
> >
> >
> > ------------------------------------
> >
> > Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> > Yahoo! Groups Links
> >
> >
> > � � MEFAwards-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com
> >
> >
> >
>

Msg# 10707

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 25, 2010 - 15:34:04 Topic ID# 10672
Well, I guess we can have one album called "general", or something like that. ;)
But I don't understand what exactly you mean with your last question. *unsure* You mean one general banner for all categories, or...? *unsure*
 
Ellynn

--- On Sun, 7/25/10, Red <red.lasbelin@gmail.com> wrote:
> Yes, I'm that kind of banner maker too. I don't do specific catagories, I do general scenic banners that can be used for plenty of different stories, personally customized for the winners.
> Is there a way to set up a banner specifically for banners like ours?




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10708

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Red July 25, 2010 - 18:05:42 Topic ID# 10672
*face -> palm* I meant a folder for the general banners. Sorry about that.

Though I'm looking over this exchange, and I'm wondering if perhaps it wouldn't be more appropriate to take this offlist to Neume Indil, the banner coordinator for this year?

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Ellin Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@...> wrote:
>
> Well, I guess we can have one album called "general", or something like that. ;)
> But I don't understand what exactly you mean with your last question. *unsure* You mean one general banner for all categories, or...? *unsure*
>  
> Ellynn
>
> --- On Sun, 7/25/10, Red <red.lasbelin@...> wrote:
> > Yes, I'm that kind of banner maker too. I don't do specific catagories, I do general scenic banners that can be used for plenty of different stories, personally customized for the winners.
> > Is there a way to set up a banner specifically for banners like ours?
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>

Msg# 10709

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 26, 2010 - 3:29:03 Topic ID# 10672
>On Sun, 7/25/10, Red <red.lasbelin@gmail.com> wrote:
> Though I'm looking over this exchange, and I'm wondering if perhaps it wouldn't be more appropriate to take this offlist to Neume Indil, the banner coordinator for this year?

In my first e-mail on this topic, I wanted all the authors to know for my plans (making banners, customizing etc.), and I wanted some feedback, which turned out to be great - Aranel gave the idea for several albums instead of one. Perhaps we (banner-makers) can continue talking about further details with Neume, as soon as she comes - she didn't reply any of our e-mails so far. Maybe she's busy. *unsure* Anyway, I wouldn't open any category-albums (although I have made some banners by now) until she says her opinion.





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10712

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Red July 27, 2010 - 10:58:11 Topic ID# 10672
Yahoo did something strange and ate my messages then spit them out much later.

Okay. Just wanted to mention there were more than one banner maker who didn't do banners by placement.

--- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com, Ellin Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@...> wrote:
>
> >On Sun, 7/25/10, Red <red.lasbelin@...> wrote:
> > Though I'm looking over this exchange, and I'm wondering if perhaps it wouldn't be more appropriate to take this offlist to Neume Indil, the banner coordinator for this year?
>
> In my first e-mail on this topic, I wanted all the authors to know for my plans (making banners, customizing etc.), and I wanted some feedback, which turned out to be great - Aranel gave the idea for several albums instead of one. Perhaps we (banner-makers) can continue talking about further details with Neume, as soon as she comes - she didn't reply any of our e-mails so far. Maybe she's busy. *unsure* Anyway, I wouldn't open any category-albums (although I have made some banners by now) until she says her opinion.
>
>
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>

Msg# 10713

Re: Winner-banners Posted by Neume Indil July 27, 2010 - 13:36:55 Topic ID# 10672
I've been out of town for a family funeral. I should be able to address all
of these messages in the next day or two.

Neu

On Tue, Jul 27, 2010 at 11:53 AM, Red <red.lasbelin@gmail.com> wrote:

>
>
> Yahoo did something strange and ate my messages then spit them out much
> later.
>
> Okay. Just wanted to mention there were more than one banner maker who
> didn't do banners by placement.
>
>
> --- In MEFAwards@yahoogroups.com <MEFAwards%40yahoogroups.com>, Ellin
> Ithilwen <ellin_revenger@...> wrote:
> >
> > >On Sun, 7/25/10, Red <red.lasbelin@...> wrote:
> > > Though I'm looking over this exchange, and I'm wondering if perhaps it
> wouldn't be more appropriate to take this offlist to Neume Indil, the banner
> coordinator for this year?
> >
> > In my first e-mail on this topic, I wanted all the authors to know for my
> plans (making banners, customizing etc.), and I wanted some feedback, which
> turned out to be great - Aranel gave the idea for several albums instead of
> one. Perhaps we (banner-makers) can continue talking about further details
> with Neume, as soon as she comes - she didn't reply any of our e-mails so
> far. Maybe she's busy. *unsure* Anyway, I wouldn't open any category-albums
> (although I have made some banners by now) until she says her opinion.
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> >
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10714

Re: Winner-banners Posted by telperion1 July 27, 2010 - 14:05:03 Topic ID# 10672
Hi neume,

I'm really sorry to hear about your family's loss. *hugs* As for
banners, I emailed you and the other banner makers an hour ago. So why
don't we take the conversation over there, when you're ready?

(This isn't off-list discussions or anything, but I do think it's
something many list members may not necessarily want in their inbox. So
I'd just as prefer to finish up the conversation privately.)

Marta

On 7/27/2010 2:35 PM, Neume Indil wrote:
> I've been out of town for a family funeral. I should be able to address all
> of these messages in the next day or two.
>
> Neu
>
> On Tue, Jul 27, 2010 at 11:53 AM, Red<red.lasbelin@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> Yahoo did something strange and ate my messages then spit them out much
>> later.
>>
>> Okay. Just wanted to mention there were more than one banner maker who
>> didn't do banners by placement.
>>
>>

Msg# 10715

(no subject) Posted by harrowcatliz@netscape.net July 28, 2010 - 1:41:52 Topic ID# 10715

Msg# 10716

Re: Posted by Berni Crumb July 28, 2010 - 8:41:51 Topic ID# 10715
It looks like someone has hacked Harrocatz's account. SPAM!

Vorondavý ar linalmiý,
Rhyselle


Fantasy remains a human right: we make in our measure and in our derivative
mode, because we are made: and not only made, but made in the image and
likeness of a Maker. -- J.R.R. Tolkien, On Fairy-Stories, 1939

By chance, I have just had another letter regarding the failure of Frodo.
Very few seem even to have observed it. But following the logic of the plot,
it was clearly inevitable, as an event. And surely it is a more significant
and real event than a mere ýfairy-storyý ending in which the hero is
indomitable? It is possible for the good, even the saintly, to be subjected
to a power of evil which is too great for them to overcome ý in themselves.
In this case the cause (not the ýheroý) was triumphant because by the
exercise of pity, mercy and forgiveness of injury, a situation was produced
in which all was redressed and disaster averted. Gandalf certainly foresaw
this. See Vol. I p.68-69. Of course, he did not mean t o say that one must
be merciful, for it may prove useful later ý it would not then be mercy or
pity, which are only truly present when contrary to prudence. Not ours to
plan! But we are assured that we must be ourselves extravagantly generous,
if we are to hope for the extravagant generosity which the slightest easing
of, or escape from, the consequences of our own follies and errors
represents. And that mercy does sometimes occur in this life.

Letter 192, The Letters of JRR Tolkien


On Wed, Jul 28, 2010 at 2:37 AM, <harrowcatliz@netscape.net> wrote:

> http://straight-punch.de/about.php
>
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Visit our website: http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2009/
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10717

Re: Harrowcatliz and spam Posted by BLJean@aol.com July 28, 2010 - 10:33:26 Topic ID# 10717
Yes, it looks like it's been hacked, and went through her entire address book, I suspect. I got a message with a different link in it. Didn't click on the link, though I *did* read the message, and I hope I didn't catch any viruses that way.

Going to run a virus scan now.

Lin


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10718

spam Posted by telperion1 July 28, 2010 - 16:16:40 Topic ID# 10718
Hey guys,

As some of you noticed, harrowcatliz's email address sent a message to
this group, with a single link in it. I say her email address, because
I'm confident Harrowcatliz herself had nothing to do with it! I suspect
a hacker or script used her address book to send a message to everyone
in her address book. (It may even have sent the message to anyone she's
emailed in the past; some attacks can do that.) The same email and link
came in to a variety of other MEFA addresses I monitor, within seconds
of the one that arrived at MEFAwards.

I don't think the email is particularly dangerous, so long as you don't
click on the link. I opened the email sent directly to me through the
mefasupport address, but didn't click the link, and have since run my
antivirus scanner. So far everything seems fine. The fact that there was
no file attachment and that I got no warnings (either from my AV when I
opened the email, or when I did a scan since then) make me think that
the email itself wasn't dangerous. By all means scan your computer if
you are concerned, though!

Whenever this happens, I put the person whose email account was used on
moderation. This just means that I approve any emails before they are
sent to the group. It's the best way I know to prevent future spam,
short of moderating everyone (which I don't have time for). But really,
I don't expect future problems. This is just a precaution.

Marta+

Msg# 10719

Re: spam Posted by Bonnie L. Sherrell July 28, 2010 - 16:35:08 Topic ID# 10718
I just received a true email from Harrowcat, and she confirms it was a hack to
her work account that led to the email we all received. She says she would
never send a message with a blank subject line like this had.

There have been several individuals in the past few weeks whose email address
books or histories have been hijacked in this manner. Beware!

Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

Msg# 10720

SoA is back up--sort of. Posted by Bonnie L. Sherrell July 28, 2010 - 16:37:29 Topic ID# 10720
One can read and review and post, but not all has been completely restored. To
post one must include HTML tags, so it's been difficult for me to get everything
formatted precisely as I want it. Hope the WYSIWYG is restored soon!
Bonnie L. Sherrell
Teacher at Large

"Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends." LOTR

"Don't go where I can't follow."

Msg# 10721

Re: SoA is back up--sort of. Posted by Ellin Ithilwen July 28, 2010 - 16:45:10 Topic ID# 10720
Uhm, what is WYSIWYG?  *huh*

--- On Wed, 7/28/10, Bonnie L. Sherrell <blslarner@olypen.com> wrote:


From: Bonnie L. Sherrell <blslarner@olypen.com>
Subject: [MEFAwards] SoA is back up--sort of.
To: "LOTR Community" <LOTR_Community_GFIC@yahoogroups.com>, "mefAwards@yahoogroups.com" <mefAwards@yahoogroups.com>
Date: Wednesday, July 28, 2010, 2:37 PM


 



One can read and review and post, but not all has been completely restored. To
post one must include HTML tags, so it's been difficult for me to get everything
formatted precisely as I want it. Hope the WYSIWYG is restored soon!
Bonnie L. Sherrell





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Msg# 10722

Re: SoA is back up--sort of. Posted by telperion1 July 28, 2010 - 16:53:04 Topic ID# 10720
Hiya Ellynn,

WYSIWYG is "what you see is what you get." Basically try to answer this
question:

--- If you want to bold a word, do you highlight it and press a button?
That's wysiwyg.
--- If you want to bold a word, do you surround it with typed
characters, < b > at the beginning and < /b > at the end (minus the
spaces)? That's HTML.

The benefit of WYSIWYG is you can copy in word directly out of a Word
Document, without the need to insert HTML. The down side is that WYSIWYG
is often imprecise. Some people, myself included, prefer to use basic
HTML tags so you have more control over how your story is presented.
Others prefer the simplicity of not having to mess with HTML, and so
prefer to use WYSIWYG.

Marta

On 7/28/2010 5:45 PM, Ellin Ithilwen wrote:
>
>
> Uhm, what is WYSIWYG? *huh*
>
> --- On Wed, 7/28/10, Bonnie L. Sherrell <blslarner@olypen.com
> <mailto:blslarner%40olypen.com>> wrote:
>
> From: Bonnie L. Sherrell <blslarner@olypen.com
> <mailto:blslarner%40olypen.com>>
> Subject: [MEFAwards] SoA is back up--sort of.
> To: "LOTR Community" <LOTR_Community_GFIC@yahoogroups.com
> <mailto:LOTR_Community_GFIC%40yahoogroups.com>>,
> "mefAwards@yahoogroups.com <mailto:mefAwards%40yahoogroups.com>"
> <mefAwards@yahoogroups.com <mailto:mefAwards%40yahoogroups.com>>
> Date: Wednesday, July 28, 2010, 2:37 PM
>
>
>
> One can read and review and post, but not all has been completely
> restored. To
> post one must include HTML tags, so it's been difficult for me to get
> everything
> formatted precisely as I want it. Hope the WYSIWYG is restored soon!
> Bonnie L. Sherrell
>

Msg# 10723

Re: spam Posted by telperion1 July 28, 2010 - 16:58:23 Topic ID# 10718
On 7/28/2010 5:34 PM, Bonnie L. Sherrell wrote:
>
>
> I just received a true email from Harrowcat, and she confirms it was a
> hack to
> her work account that led to the email we all received. She says she would
> never send a message with a blank subject line like this had.
>
> There have been several individuals in the past few weeks whose email
> address
> books or histories have been hijacked in this manner. Beware!
>

Hi Larner,

I don't doubt it for a second! Harrowcatliz is a name I've seen around
fandom for years, not some random ID made up by a spammer, and so I was
sure she wasn't doing it intentionally.

I'm still moderating her for a while. This is standard operating
procedure, and the best way I know to protect the group and be fair. I
can't know everyone in fandom, and it's not fair to moderate some people
who I don't know beforehand, and not moderate those that I have seen
around for a while. (Because the ones I don't know may in fact have been
around the fandom for *ages* - just not at the places I hang out.) But
this is 100% not a judgment on harrowcatliz or anyone else it happens to
- just the best way I know to handle the problem fairly. At worst, it
will mean her posts to this group will be a bit delayed the next few
times she posts.

Marta

Msg# 10724

ADMIN - ratings and warnings Posted by telperion1 July 28, 2010 - 17:09:04 Topic ID# 10724
Hey guys,

Every so often I hear about a discussion going on, where people ask
whether NC17 stories can compete in the MEFAs. It seems like the kind of
thing a lot of people are confused over. Our policy on ratings used to
be a bit different than it is now. So I'd like to use this week's
educational post to explain some of the issues surrounding ratings and
eligibility.

By the way, you may be thinking this is the kind of thing we really
should have brought up during nominations. Perhaps we should have, and
I'll try to do that next year. But I think it's still good to talk about
now. You may be surprised to come across an NC17 story when reading this
year's nominations, since they are are allowed. You may also be keeping
lists throughout the year, of new stories you'd like to nominate. I
don't want stories rated NC17 on their archives to miss out *next* year
because you were confused about our rules. So it's good to think about
this topic now, so you understand the MEFA's positions on ratings.

Before we get to that, though, some quick reminders:

*********************************

1. Annmarwalk is posting reviews to the [mefa-reviews] Yahoo group and
the [mefas] LJ community. If you'd like to receive reviews by email,
sign up for one of these groups.

2. Don't forget, if you're setting a review goal, you need to do this by
August 15.

Now on to the main event. :^D

***********************************

ARE NC-17 STORIES ELIGIBLE?

It really depends on the story. At the MEFAs, eligibility depends on the
rating your story receives in OUR rating system. These are described at

http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQratingsguide

Stories that fall under General, Teen, or Mature can compete; Adult
stories cannot. As you can see, the Mature rating allows "Full sex
scenes [to] be depicted. The depiction should focus on the characters'
emotions and thoughts rather than a clinical description of the events."
We also consider whether any erotic content is part of a larger story
arc or is the main focus of the piece. But as you can see, our
guidelines are a bit more liberal than what you find at many archives.



WHAT IF I'M NOT SURE WHAT TO RATE MY STORY?

We have a ratings panel to help authors figure out what to rate their
stories. If you aren't sure what's appropriate, you can have these
volunteers read over your story, and they will decide what rating it
will have. If they decide it is Adult, the story can't compete in that
year's awards, though it will still be eligible in future years. (For
instance, you might remove/modify the adult part, or our ratings
guidelines might change.) And if they decide it's Mature, you can be
certain that your story will stay in the competition throughout the
whole awards.

It's the author's choice whether or not to have the ratings panel look
over a story. The disadvantage of *not* using this panel is, there's a
risk that the story will be withdrawn later. If a reader complains that
a story is too explicit later in the awards our ratings panel will look
at it then. If the ratings panel decides your story is adult rather than
mature, your story will be withdrawn from the awards. (And it may not be
eligible in the future, if it's withdrawn too late.) So if you're
unsure, you can take advantage of this panel to make sure you're
eligible. But really, there are many stories rated NC17 at some archive,
that actually qualify for our Mature rating - and they are eligible to
compete.



CAN I LINK TO A STORY IF IT'S RATED NC-17 AT ITS ARCHIVE?

We don't look at the rating you gave a story at its archive. Authors
rate the story at *our* website, and that's all we need to know, to see
if it's eligible or not.

There is one thing to think about, though. Some archives require you to
actually log in to read an Adult-rated story. If you nominate a story at
that archive, they'll be ineligible - not because of rating, but because
the link doesn't work! For the MEFAs you need a single link that goes to
your whole story, and where people can read the story even if they
aren't a member of that site. (It's fine if the archive makes readers
click a button or link, confirming they're of age; the website just
can't make you sign in.)



IS SLASH ELIGIBLE?

Slash comes in all ratings, just like het does. You don't have to warn
for slash or het, and you don't have to rate one type of story higher
than the other. Your rating should reflect how explicit the story is,
not the pairings involved. You do need to indicate romantic pairings on
our form, so readers can decide whether they want to read those stories.
Some people decide not to read het or slash; equally, some people decide
not to read a certain pairing because it doesn't interest them for some
other reason.

If your slash story is ineligible, it's not *because* it's slash.



WHAT IF I READ A STORY WITH THE WRONG RATING OR WARNING?

If you think you've read something with the wrong rating, I want to hear
about it. Email the story ID #, title, author, and what you think is
wrong about the rating or warning, to mefasupportATgmailDOTcom. If the
ratings panel hasn't already looked at the story, I'll have them do that
ASAP. (If they've alredy read it, it won't be read again.) Assuming the
ratings panel agrees with you, I will correct the information listed at
our website.

I do ask that you not leave a negative review for a story because the
content surprised you. That's not fair to them, or to other readers who
may not be bothered by the rating. It's also no guarantee that I'll see
the review, since I don't have time to read every review written, and I
can't fix what I don't know about. Of course you don't have to review
the story at all, if you were so surprised by the content that you
couldn't enjoy the story.



I WISH I HAD KNOWN ALL THIS A FEW MONTHS AGO! I WOULD HAVE NOMINATED
THIS GREAT STORY I READ...

The good news is, older stories are 100% eligible for the MEFAs. If you
read a story from 2009 - or 1999, or whenever - that you really liked,
and no one has nominated it yet, it's still eligible to compete. Just
nominate it next year.

********************************

For more on Ratings, see:

--- Are "adult" stories eligible for the MEFAs?
http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQratings#rat_1

--- Do I need to warn if my story contains het or slash?
http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQratings#rat_5

--- Ratings Guideline
http://www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/index.php?page=FAQratingsguide

********************************

Marta
(MEFA Admin.)

Msg# 10725

Hello all! Posted by Lady of DEE Lights July 29, 2010 - 23:42:28 Topic ID# 10725
Hey does anyone know where I can go to read the winner stories I would like to know..I have not been very active in here, but I would like to start.

Thanks

Brandy aka Haldirsbaby

Msg# 10726

Re: Hello all! Posted by telperion1 July 30, 2010 - 0:47:38 Topic ID# 10725
Hi Brandy,

This year's awards are still going on, so we don't have winners yet, but
you can read the nominated stories and vote for them.

--- Go to www.mefawards.net/MEFA2010/ and log in.
--- Click the "Stories" tab at the top of the list.
--- Browse around or, to find stories about a certain character etc.
click the "Show Filter" link.

Once you find a story, you can read it by clicking on the title, or you
can vote for it using the "Enter New Review" link on the right side of
the page.

You can also check out previous year's winners:

--- Go to www.mefawards.net/mefa-archive
--- Click the "Awards Results" link.
--- Choose a year and click the "Select" button.

You can no longer vote for these stories but you can read them by
clicking on the title. (Some links may no longer work, especially for
older years.)

Marta

On 7/30/2010 12:40 AM, Lady of DEE Lights wrote:
>
>
> Hey does anyone know where I can go to read the winner stories I would
> like to know..I have not been very active in here, but I would like to
> start.
>
> Thanks
>
> Brandy aka Haldirsbaby
>